Myregion.org looks at suspect poll data
Kevin Spear
Sentinel Staff Writer
February 9, 2007
Leaders of myregion.org suspect someone might have tried to stack the deck in
their heavily promoted public-opinion survey on how Central Florida should
grow in coming decades.
Myregion.org President Jacob Stuart said the growth-policy think-tank has
hired a security expert to investigate whether online forms were filled out
repeatedly by an unknown individual or someone using a computer program.
"At this point, there is no way to know exactly how many electronic
surveys have been duplicated," Stuart said in a written statement.
At stake is the credibility of myregion.org's $850,000 "How Shall We
Grow?" project, which has conducted extensive research and organized
community meetings last year that drew 9,000 residents.
The public-opinion campaign began Jan. 26, and in the past two weeks more than
5,600 surveys have been submitted that rank four growth plans: keeping current
development patterns, buying environmental lands, building compact communities
or pursuing more transportation options.
Myregion.org officials, who hope the survey results will influence
politicians' future decisions, said they didn't think particularly tight
security measures were necessary.
"We've worked hard to be inclusive and open. Why would an organization
with our values go out and spend its money to build a defense wall?"
myregion.org Chairman Randolph Lyon said.
The survey system automatically blocks users from filling out the online
survey more than once by logging the signature of a survey-taker's computer.
Any subsequent attempt to fill out the form automatically brings up the
results page instead.
But making a simple privacy adjustment on most computers can bypass the block,
allowing people to vote numerous times from the same computer.
A Winter Park computer firm, Avancent Consulting, will meet with myregion.org
directors today to sort out how they will tackle the problem.
Todd Rader, the firm's senior consultant and chief executive officer, declined
Thursday to talk about what steps will be taken.
Voting continues through Wednesday, but no more security measures are expected
to be installed before then, myregion.org officials said.
After all the results are in, Stuart said, the firm will be able to examine
every online vote to ferret out anyone trying to cheat. Dean Hybl, a
myregion.org program manager, said the security expert will identify surveys
taken on computers that didn't leave signatures.
"We have asked Avancent Consulting to also make an independent
recommendation as to how we should proceed with the evaluation and
authentication of each and every electronic survey at the conclusion of this
process," wrote Stuart, president of the Chamber of Commerce, where
myregion .org is based and directed by business, government and civic leaders.
Concerns arose last week when a Lake County resident, Rob Kelly, who is a
member of the county's Land Planning Agency and is active in growth issues,
noticed a dramatic shift in the survey's daily polling results.
Overnight, the option that emphasizes large public-works projects to establish
transportation corridors and is most likely to rev up the region's economy,
surged from third place to first place as the most preferred choice, Kelly
said.
Late Thursday, the transportation option was still ahead of the others,
getting a top ranking from 35 percent of submitted surveys.
Kelly said that big swing occurred between 11 p.m. Feb. 2 and when he next
looked at midmorning the next day, a Saturday, when the swing continued.
Until then, he said, survey results showed most people preferred the priority
of purchasing and protecting environmentally sensitive lands.
Data provided by myregion.org on Thursday show a significant change in favor
of the transportation choice. On Feb. 1, it was top choice in 22 percent of
surveys submitted that day. On Feb. 2, it was top choice in 20 percent of
surveys. But on Feb. 3, the transportation choice was ranked the top choice in
60 percent that day.
Suspicious of the turnabout, Kelly found he could vote repeatedly by
increasing the privacy setting of his computer.
"They left the Web site wide open to anybody doing anything," said
Kelly, who told myregion.org about his concern. "Then they are going to
wave around the results, saying, 'This is the way we want to grow.' "
Kevin Spear can be reached at kspear@orlandosentinel.com or 407-420-5062.
110-Mile Tollway Could Reshape Rural Central Florida
By BILLY TOWNSEND The Tampa Tribune
Published: Feb 9, 2007
LAKELAND - For now, the Heartland Parkway, a proposed 110-mile toll highway
roughly linking Lakeland and Fort Myers, looks a little like a wide-bodied
snake drawn on a map. Its possible routes cut a wide, indefinite swath through
some of Florida's most rural land.
What it might mean in reality for the giant cattle ranches, orange groves
and isolated small towns west of Lake Okeechobee depends on who's looking at
it.
Some environmentalists and planners see a multibillion-dollar boondoggle, a
classic "road to nowhere" sprawl creator and habitat killer that
should not be built.
The state Department of Transportation sees a needed north-south traffic
corridor to ease pressure in "high-growth" Polk County and on
Interstate 75, U.S. 17 and U.S. 27. It also sees a new hurricane evacuation
route. The road is one of the highways envisioned in the Florida
Transportation Commission's New Corridors study. State officials say it is
more likely to happen sooner than a proposed east-west corridor that could
crisscross it.
And a group of major area landowners represented by longtime state civic
and political leader Rick Dantzler sees the future of the seven-county
Heartland region, roughly defined as southern Polk, Highlands, Hardee, Glades,
DeSoto, Hendry and Okeechobee counties.
Dantzler's group has dubbed itself the Heartland Economic Agricultural
Rural Task Force, or HEART. Its chairman is Mark Morton, senior vice president
of land investment for Lykes Bros. The famous Florida agricultural company
owns 337,000 acres in Glades and Highlands, much of which lies in the path of
the road, as it is broadly proposed.
Both men insist that HEART's advocacy for the highway is about more than
converting agricultural land into right-of-way payments and lucrative
development potential. They see an economic and quality-of-life corridor, with
accompanying rail, telecommunications, utilities and wildlife corridors built
in, along with tight growth rules - "a whole host of public
benefits," as Dantzler puts it.
Beyond vision, Dantzler says his group brings something practical: "an
awful lot of land owned by relatively few people." That probably would
mean some form of right-of-way donation and greater likelihood of large-scale,
multicounty planning agreements.
HEART has sought out environmental and planning groups in the hope of
building broad support for the corridor idea. Some, such as the Florida
Wildlife Federation, like what they hear from Dantzler and are willing to
withhold judgment until more details emerge.
"HEART came together around the idea of a road," Dantzler said.
"But now we see it as a chance to organize the growth that's coming. It's
the planning of an entire region all at once."
What's Actually Happening?
Randy Fox is in charge of planning for Florida's Turnpike system.
His office is wrapping up a study of traffic potential for the parkway. The
numbers are not final, but Fox said the study will show that potential traffic
justifies construction of the road, most immediately for its northernmost
portion in Polk County.
If approved, Fox said, construction of the Heartland Parkway would begin in
Polk and move south as land and money become available. There's no real time
estimate, though advocates have tended to talk about a 20-year plan for the
road.
The Polk portion would happen sooner. It would create a large half-circle
loop around the population centers of Lakeland and Winter Haven, and include a
link to Interstate 4. The proposed loop - about 45 miles - also would tie into
the CSX Transportation freight distribution center Winter Haven hopes to bring
to a complex on its southeastern fringes, providing a route for the center's
heavy projected truck traffic.
In a December letter urging state support for the road, Winter Haven City
Manager David Greene wrote, "Many of the approximate one thousand
semi-trucks that will enter and leave [the CSX complex] daily will be able to
utilize the Parkway."
He added, "Growth is occurring and unless we expedite the process, the
suggested corridor may close due to development."
Dantzler echoes that sentiment, suggesting that his group needs a green
light in the next year to 18 months to maintain its cohesiveness.
If the financing and politics lined up perfectly, the Polk loop portion of
Heartland Parkway could exist within 10 years, Fox said.
The remainder of the route would roll south, roughly straddling the long
border separating Highlands, Glades and Hendry counties on the east and Hardee,
DeSoto, Charlotte and Lee counties on the west. It would end at State Road 82,
just east of Fort Myers.
It Will Take Billions
The money involved is enormous.
The central Polk section, the highway's most urban stretch, is likely to
cost more than $1 billion, Fox said. Estimates for the entire parkway top $3
billion. As is typical for any large, new project, tolls alone will not cover
that cost, Fox said.
But the proposed corridor is one of nine included in the Florida
Transportation Commission's study, which aims to identify ways to ease a
predicted congestion crunch driven by surges in population and freight traffic
in the 20 to 30 years.
With that in mind, Fox expects the state to pay for a preliminary design
and engineering study, which would better hone the route and costs of the
parkway. No matter what the study shows, building the highway would require a
patchwork funding arrangement involving tolls, governments at all levels, land
contributions from property owners and other financial tools, Fox said.
HEART's planning and the state's planning appear to be proceeding on
parallel tracks. Fox said he has had informal meetings with HEART but is not
coordinating with the group.
Everyone seems to agree that growth pressures are increasing for the
Heartland counties, as coastal living becomes increasingly expensive - both in
cost of land and insurance. Dantzler says some parcels in the area are selling
at square-foot prices that are too high to sustain agricultural uses.
And Morton, HEART's chairman, said he fears for the fate of the small towns
along U.S. 27 if that road and others don't get relief from freight traffic,
which the state says is expected to double statewide by 2020.
U.S. 27 is one of the few viable north-south freight routes not on either
coast. "Everything ends up on 27, and it disrupts our small
communities," Morton said. "Lake Placid could end up with an
eight-lane, divided highway."
A New Kind Of Road?
HEART has existed for about a year as a nonprofit organization.
Dantzler, a former state lawmaker, is its public face and lawyer. It also
has retained engineering consultants.
They all have been meeting with environmental and planning organizations.
Dantzler said HEART is preparing to release two documents about the Heartland
corridor proposal. The first is a list of principles "that will guide the
land-use planning of those who participate" in whatever arrangement HEART
might make with the state. Those principles could be released in the next few
weeks, Dantzler said.
The second is a more detailed vision of the corridor, which HEART will
debate and decide upon during a meeting this month, Dantzler said.
Without concrete plans, corridor advocates are left to talk about the
project in attractive but general terms.
"We want this to be a prototype, the most environmentally conscious
road in the history of the nation," Dantzler said.
Some of the features he touts include:
•An "enormous" amount of undeveloped space surrounding the
corridor.
•Extensive wildlife corridors and other protective measures, such as
fences to prevent roadkill, to protect such species as the Florida panther and
black bear.
•Limited access and exit points to the highway.
•Rail, utility and other corridors.
•Growth rules that would mandate clustering development near the road and
broad protection of the rural countryside beyond.
•Construction that seeks to preserve wetlands.
The key element, Dantzler said, will be a legal framework that locks in any
commitments by local governments and landowners.
If that is achieved, the Heartland Parkway could become a mechanism for
bringing growth to the Heartland region on its own terms and schedule,
reversing a long Florida pattern.
"In the past, we've grown and then tried to thread the transportation
corridors through existing growth," Dantzler said.
Curiosity And Skepticism
That all sounds good to Manley K. Fuller III, president of the Florida
Wildlife Federation. Fuller has met with Dantzler and representatives of HEART
and offered them suggestions.
"We don't like new highways," Fuller said. "They tend to be
giant growth stimulators. But whether we like it or not, there's going to be
more highways built.
"We'd like to see conservation planning totally connected to
transportation planning," Fuller said, and Dantzler's vision has the
potential to do that. Fuller said he is willing to wait on what emerges from
the state and HEART documents before recommending a position on the corridor
to his board of directors.
Not everyone is as forbearing.
John Ryan, a Sierra Club activist and a member of the Polk County Planning
Commission, calls the parkway "a completely unneeded road to nowhere
built solely for economic development." He adds, "There's no way in
hell that road can be justified on trip rates."
Ryan does agree the concept Dantzler is peddling is better than nothing -
if the road can't be stopped. But he also is skeptical that such a plan could
be forged and enforced over time.
"Rick's a nice guy with good intentions, but based on experience, we
don't see that scenario being played out the way he hopes it will," Ryan
said.
Dantzler said he understands that sentiment, acknowledging he often
"goes to war with myself" over the idea of a road. But he hopes
critics will "hold their powder" until a more specific plan is
revealed.
Reporter Billy Townsend can be reached at wtownsend@tampatrib.com
or (863) 284-1409.
Funds for state roads could drop by $752M
By LLOYD DUNKELBERGER
Sun Tallahassee Bureau
TALLAHASSEE - Some lawmakers and transportation advocates are puzzled by a
proposed $752 million reduction in the new state road budget.
The dip in spending for the Department of Transportation was embedded in the
$71 billion budget bill that Gov. Charlie Crist proposed last week. The
governor's recommended spending plan showed the road budget would drop from
$9.1 billion this year to $8.4 billion in the next budget year, which begins
July 1.
And although DOT officials have offered an explanation for the drop, some
lawmakers say they are concerned, particularly given fast-growing Florida's
need for new and improved roads.
''I need to get a better explanation,'' said Sen. Mike Fasano, R-New Port
Richey, chairman of the Senate budget panel that oversees road spending.
''It concerns me because any time you show a reduction in transportation
spending, that's the wrong message we should be sending to taxpayers.''
Part of the DOT's explanation for the dollar drop is that projects, and the
different phases of those projects, vary from year to year.
That means when you compare one year's road projects to projects the next
year, it's akin to comparing ''apples to oranges,'' a DOT official told
House members Thursday.
But Rep. Rich Glorioso, R-Plant City, was among those dissatisfied with the
explanation, noting that he has major road projects in his community that
have been delayed.
''I'm having a hard time understanding why our transportation spending in
the five-year work program dollars are not continuously going up,'' he said.
''I don't understand how they are going down.''
The governor's aides said Crist is satisfied with the DOT's explanation,
although he too was troubled when he first heard the numbers.
''The department describes it as the natural ebb and flow'' of scheduling
projects, Lisa Saliba, an adviser to the governor on transportation and
economic development issues, told Fasano's committee on Thursday.
But some transportation advocates say they are troubled by the apparent drop
in spending.
''I don't think Florida can afford an 'ebbing' transportation budget,'' said
Doug Callaway, president of Floridians for Better Transportation, a
coalition that includes the Florida Chamber of Commerce, the road builders,
businesses, airports and ports.
The transportation group cites a 2003 estimate that pegged Florida's
transportation backlog at $23 billion over the next decade just to keep up
with growth.
Callaway said he has been assured by DOT officials that no transportation
funding - which is largely supplied by the gas tax - is being diverted to
other government programs. But beyond that, Callaway said: ''We clearly need
to ask the Legislature to go beyond what's been proposed and actually
increase Florida's transportation spending.''
The most detailed explanation of the new DOT budget was sent to Callaway's
group by Lowell Clary, an assistant secretary at the DOT for finance and
administration.
''As you know, the (DOT's) work program is a different set of projects each
year so it naturally moves up and down somewhat over time due to very large
projects being in one year and not in the next,'' Clary told the group.
But he said the biggest reason for the drop is that this year's budget
included a one-time appropriation of $542 million for growth-management
related projects that won't be available for next year's road program.
Another factor is that the DOT didn't receive legal permission to increase
the bonding cap for the Florida Turnpike projects this year because a
transportation bill was vetoed last year.
The combination of not increasing the cap as well as dealing with the rising
cost of new transportation projects means the Turnpike will be spending less
in the next year, Clary said.
Some lawmakers say they don't see a big problem with the DOT budget. Sen.
Dan Webster, R-Orlando, is a veteran of transportation issues. He said that
what appears to be a drop in funding is a reflection only of the normal rise
and fall in costs that come with fluctuating prices in multi-year projects.
''It's nothing unusual,'' he said.
Rep. Dean Cannon, R-Winter Park, chairman of the House Economic Expansion
and Infrastructure Council, said his panel would seek more information on
the DOT's budget, while warning that lawmakers are already getting signals
that next year's budget overall will not be as generous as this year's
spending plan.
He said ''meeting the transportation infrastructure needs'' of a state with
a growing population and aging transportation system remains a high priority
for the House. But he also said ''the budget is just one piece of the
puzzle.''
Cannon said House leaders were also looking at broader solutions for the
state's transportation needs, including the use of more public-private
partnerships for projects and the use of toll facilities.
Cann Finalist for Fla. Road Chief
By Bill
Rufty
The Ledger
LAKELAND - Stanley Cann, who heads the District 1 office of the Florida
Department of Transportation in Bartow, was named Thursday as one of three
finalists for the statewide job of DOT secretary.
Cann was the only one of the DOT's seven district heads mentioned as a
finalist for the job.
The Florida Transportation Commission, which started with 23 applicants to
replace FDOT Secretary Denver Stutler Jr. who resigned in January, had
narrowed the field to seven, whom they interviewed. The commission sent the
three finalists' names to Gov. Charlie Crist.
Crist will now select the new secretary of DOT from Cann, interim DOT
Secretary Stephanie Kopeloousos and James E. Crawley, vice president of the
private contractor DMJM Harris.
Cann, who previously served as secretary of DOT District 6 headquartered in
Miami, became the District 1 head in July, 2004 after a sex scandal in the
Bartow administrative offices left the secretary's office vacant.
He has been praised by the Polk County Legislative delegation and county
officials for his openness and his willingness to try to help solve local
road concerns.
"I think Stan would be a breath of fresh air up here," state Sen.
Paula Dockery, R-Lakeland, said from Tallahassee on Thursday. "He
understands the importance of local road networks and not just the big
intermodal roads. He is very easy to work with and is responsive to local
government needs and legislative inquiries; not always a trait found in the
past."
Bill Rufty can be reached at bill.rufty@theledger.com
or at 802-7523.
Cuts not soothing for road worriers
Gov. Crist's budget plan sets off alarms
TALLAHASSEE -- If you are stuck in bumper-to-bumper congestion on roads such
as U.S. 301 in Sarasota, you may blow your horn when you hear what the
governor and state transportation officials are thinking.
Gov. Charlie Crist's first proposed budget calls for cutting state road
spending by $752 million -- more than 8 percent.
The proposed funding cutback comes on top of what one public interest group
says is already a $23 billion shortfall the state faces over the next decade
just to keep up with growth.
Funding shortfalls are so severe that only half of the 140 state and federal
road projects in Manatee, Sarasota and Charlotte counties rated as
priorities are expected to be completed by 2030.
"It's been a death spiral," said Manatee County Commissioner Joe
McClash. "We're just gradually sinking into the ground until one day
the average citizen doesn't want to live here anymore because of the traffic
congestion."
Crist's plan, which still must be considered by the Legislature, reduces the
Department of Transportation's budget from $9.1 billion to $8.4 billion in
the next budget year, which begins July 1.
Some state lawmakers, who generally have lauded the new governor, say the
proposed cuts in the transportation budget need a closer look.
"I need to get a better explanation," said Sen. Mike Fasano, R-New
Port Richey, chairman of the Senate budget panel that oversees road
spending. "It concerns me because any time you show a reduction in
transportation spending, that's the wrong message we should be sending to
taxpayers."
Part of the Department of Transportation's explanation for the dollar drop
in Crist's budget is that projects, and the different phases of those
projects, vary from year to year. That means when comparing one year's road
projects to the next's, it's akin to comparing "apples to
oranges," a DOT official told House members Thursday.
The governor's aides said Crist is satisfied with the DOT's explanation,
although he, too, was troubled when he first heard the numbers.
"The department describes it as the natural ebb and flow" of
scheduling projects, Lisa Saliba, an adviser to the governor on
transportation and economic development issues, told Fasano's committee on
Thursday.
But some transportation advocates say they are troubled by the apparent drop
in spending.
"I don't think Florida can afford an 'ebbing' transportation
budget," said Doug Callaway, president of Floridians for Better
Transportation, a coalition that includes the Florida Chamber of Commerce,
the road builders, big businesses, airports and ports.
Callaway said he has been assured by DOT officials that no transportation
funding -- which is largely supplied by the gas tax -- would be diverted to
other government programs.
But beyond that, Callaway said: "We clearly need to ask the Legislature
to go beyond what's been proposed and actually increase Florida's
transportation spending."
Crist's proposed budget cut would be just the latest for the FDOT, which
manages all state and federally funded roadwork.
When tourism and, subsequently, sales tax revenues dropped after the Sept.
11, 2001, terrorist attacks, former Gov. Jeb Bush and the Legislature
started dipping into the state's transportation trust fund to pay for other
needs.
And that shifting of dollars compelled mayors, county commissioners and
other local elected officials who sit on transportation planning boards
known as Metropolitan Planning Organizations to -- again and again and again
-- postpone or cancel local projects on the FDOT's to-do lists.
"The work program from the FDOT from the past few years has been
devastating for us," said Mark Gumula, executive director of the
Charlotte MPO. "We're already way behind the eight-ball."
Keith Drake, a planner for the Sarasota-Manatee MPO, said he can't foresee
how much of an impact more budget cuts will have "until you break it
down by county."
If the Legislature agrees to the cuts, each district office of the FDOT will
have to recommend changes in its work program, Drake noted.
Local officials wonder whether more high-priority and long-delayed projects
could get stalled again.
U.S. 301 is an example of one that Sarasota County Commissioner Nora
Patterson worries about. "It's still not fully funded but we were
getting closer."
The FDOT hoped to come up with enough of the $32 million needed to widen
that thoroughfare from downtown Sarasota to the Manatee County line to at
least get the project started by 2011. But it could end up having to shift
those dollars to a less costly project and postpone the work -- yet again.
When it comes to roads, the buck hardly stops at the governor's desk. Local
cities and counties are also falling far behind in road work.
Sarasota County, for example, has $320 million worth of high-priority
projects, but only $80 million in funding during the next five years.
In recent years, construction bids have been coming in about 25 percent
higher than the engineers' estimate, siphoning off funds for other projects,
said Jim Harriott, the county's public works director.
The county commissioners faced some hard realities this week, including
extending work on Honore Avenue well into the future. Making Honore a
north-south alternative to U.S. 41 and Interstate 75 has long been a
priority for the county. But there are only enough funds over the next five
years to pay for about 20 percent of the project.
_____
Staff writer Doug Sword contributed to this report
Plight
of pedestrians - big roads bad for downtown areas
By Erin Ehrlich
For The Herald
Motorists impatiently speed down
narrow State Road 26 in downtown Newberry, trying to beat out traffic.
Drivers get caught in rush hour
traffic, aggravating the situation even more.
This is the situation families face
when they cross the road to go to Newberry’s Backyard Bar-B-Q. Parents
have to grab hold of their children’s hands, fearful for their lives if a
car does not stop.
But the problem of pedestrians
having trouble getting across the street in downtown Newberry is not unique
to just Newberry.
In fact, this problem has become
more prevalent throughout the Crescent Communities as more and more traffic
clogs the U.S. highways and state roads that intersect most of the cities in
the area.
Residents at various locations find
themselves having to run and dodge traffic to cross roads, even at
crosswalks where the law says pedestrians have the right-of-way.
The case at Newberry’s Backyard
Bar-B-Q grew to be such a problem that restaurant owner Rocky Voglio even
hired a crossing guard. Voglio said the cross guard barely helped. The guard
usually got cursed at or threatened.
Traffic would get congested because
the guard would stop cars, and in turn, drivers would actually call the
restaurant and threaten to run the guard over if he was to stop traffic
again.
“These people think they’re on
the Daytona Speedway,” Voglio said.
A blinking traffic light has since
been installed and has taken the place of the crossing guard.
The need for such measures is
because motorists and pedestrians just don’t pay attention these days,
said Dwight Kingsbury, assistant state pedestrian/bicycle coordinator for
the Florida Department of Transportation.
It all comes down to being aware
and being safety-conscious, he said.
“People don’t observe the
laws,” he said.
He said pedestrians and drivers
usually go by their own rules of the road simply because they don’t know
the actual laws.
“You still have to yield to
pedestrians in the crosswalk,” Kingsbury said. “Just because (the light
is) green doesn’t mean just go.”
For example, at an intersection
where the crosswalk signal shows a solid red hand – meaning “do not
cross” – there should be no pedestrian in the crosswalk.
If someone is walking across,
though, motorists should still wait until that person is safely across the
road before continuing.
However, pedestrians are still
subject to traffic laws and should not think these rules do not apply to
them, Kingsbury said. This is how accidents happen.
If a pedestrian decides to cross
the road at any point other than at an intersection crosswalk, Florida
traffic laws dictate that the person should yield to the vehicles.
Kingsbury said as long as any
person driving or crossing the road is alert and aware of what is going on,
there should be no problems.
High Springs Police Detective Sgt.
Gordon Fulwood said the streets are as safe as one makes them.
“You have to pay attention to
your surroundings,” he said.
Often, he said, someone is talking
on a cell phone, and that causes a lot of close calls.
Fulwood said the biggest mistake a
pedestrian can make, even on a crosswalk, is to assume what the vehicle’s
next move is going to be.
“Eyes can be deceiving,” he
said. “If there are any questions, err on the side of caution.”
Voglio said he has seen people line
up like track runners and just sprint across the street, hoping to beat the
oncoming car.
This happens every day in High
Springs at the intersection of Main Street and Railroad Avenue. The
intersection has a crosswalk but no signal.
Drivers getting off of U.S. 441
often go down Main to get through High Springs. Because there is no signal,
no light and not even a stop sign, people must dodge cars and decide when
they believe it is safe to run – not walk – across.
By law, a pedestrian should be able
to cross the road and cars need to stop. This just isn’t the case, though.
In Alachua, at the major
intersection of U.S. 441 and County Road 241, the problem of getting across
U.S. 441 was solved with a pedestrian overpass.
Alachua Police Chief Robert
Jernigan said the overpass discourages people, especially children, from
crossing the highway. Adults use the overpass quite often, too, he said.
“I would say it has been a good,
preventative action,” he said.
He said the overpass was hit by a
crane at one point, but luckily no one was on the bridge at the time.
Besides that, he said, pedestrian safety has not been much of a problem in
Alachua.
As for crosswalk signals, Gina
Busscher, public information director for the Department of Transportation
in District 2, said the time on the signal has been calculated specifically
to the width of the road.
“It should give you plenty of
time to walk across,” she said.
The Department of Transportation
sets the signal to a certain number of seconds – generally one second for
every 3 feet of road.
Thus, Busscher said, a 4-lane road
signal would obviously give more time for a pedestrian to cross than a
2-lane road.
She said if a pedestrian does not
get across in the allotted time, or if they are worried they will be hit by
a vehicle, that situation usually occurs because they are not aware of the
signal.
“If you’re not paying
attention, then you’re using up your time [the signal] has given you,”
she said.
Busscher explained the signal
system as three steps. The solid red hand always means “don’t cross.”
The green man is the universal symbol for “go.”
Finally, the blinking red hand –
and she said this is a big misconception to the public – means don’t
start crossing the road if you haven’t already.
She said the blinking hand often
causes unnecessary panic in the crossing pedestrian even though the blinking
hand is only to warn others not to start.
The other major misconception is
the public’s idea of when the signal is activated.
She said that simply by standing on
the corner, the crosswalk signal will not know there is a pedestrian waiting
to cross. One must push the button on the light pole in order for it to be
activated.
Although the blinking traffic light
is satisfactory for Newberry’s Backyard Bar-B-Q for the moment, Rocky
Voglio said he wants to re-hire a crossing guard within the next month or
two.
He is thinking about getting an
off-duty deputy to work the street and possibly get drivers and pedestrians
to garner a little bit of respect for the laws.
Overall, he said, drivers seem to
be more aware of pedestrians today.
“[Drivers] are getting better,”
he said. “They haven’t killed anybody yet.”
In marketing effort,
Alachua pays $2,400 for articles on mayor, city manager
By Ronald Dupont Jr.
Herald Editor
ALACHUA - From a billboard on
Interstate 75 to television commercials and magazine ads, the city of
Alachua has not been shy about marketing itself.
But two recent marketing efforts
raised a few eyebrows when the city paid a magazine to publish two articles
in praise of two particular city officials - Mayor Jean Calderwood and City
Manager Clovis Watson Jr.
The articles, in which both
Calderwood and Watson are highly touted in paid-for stories, cost $2,400 to
be published. The money came from city funds.
The articles at first glance appear
to have been written or compiled by a magazine journalist but are actually
marketing efforts.
But both Calderwood and Watson said
there is nothing nefarious about the articles, which ran in the September
and November/December issues of the "Good Life Community"
magazine.
They said that part of the effort
in marketing the city is letting people get to meet two of the key leaders
of the city.
"I believe that people like to
hear what their community leaders have to say about their community,"
Calderwood said.
Watson echoed similar comments.
"We always look at ways to
market the city and market the community," Watson said. "We want
people to move here and people to live here - and know the leadership."
The city's marketing efforts are
not unusual, said Richard Lutz, a University of Florida marketing professor.
He said many cities, from Las Vegas to Gainesville, market themselves.
But he said he wondered how Alachua
officials thought they were advertising the city to outside markets by
writing articles about the mayor and city manager.
"It sounds like they're trying
to reassure voters instead," Lutz said.
The Two Articles
In the article about Calderwood,
the headline reads, "Jean Calderwood, the petite powerhouse of the city
of Alachua, never stops!"
The article states that "her
concern for the welfare of the residents is evident in the broad range of
causes and issues she has championed over the years."
The article then lists many of
those causes and issues, then gives details on the city's growth and the
mayor's involvement in that.
The concluding paragraph states:
"It is true that good things
come in small packages - the dynamic and personable mayor of Alachua proves
that. Pound for pound, she has been the best return on investment the voters
could have chosen."
In the marketing page about Watson,
various people are asked to give their opinion of Watson and his work.
Watson is praised by a variety of people, including Gussie Lee, the owner of
Lee's Preschool; Bob Bieniek, a broker for Alachua Properties; Dexter
O'Steen, vice president of O'Steen Brothers and Jim Brandenburg, the
principal of Alachua Elementary.
The concluding paragraph on the
page includes a quote from Eric Parker, president of Joe Parker Realty and
Parker Land Company.
He says, "Clovis Watson has
done an extraordinary job as city manager. Let's talk about jobs. Arguably,
this man has helped create more jobs than any other individual that I am
aware of in the entire county in the last 100 years."
The Ethical Issue
Of Paid-For Stories
When Alachua officials chose to
market the city in a magazine that runs paid-for articles, the city
unwittingly became part of an ongoing debate over the ethics behind such
articles.
Some magazines allow regular news
articles and paid-for articles to run side-by-side without giving a reader
any clue as to which articles are paid for and which ones were written on
their own merits.
Sometimes, magazines try to give
clues to readers on which articles are marketing pieces but those clues
aren't always clear.
In the "Good Life
Community" magazine article on Calderwood, the phrase "Special To
Good Life Community" appears in small type at the bottom of each page.
But in the paid marketing piece on
Watson, no such language appears.
Trish Utter, the publisher of the
magazine, could not be reached late Tuesday for comment.
Another magazine that allows
paid-for articles is "Gainesville Today." But Terry Hevel, the
production and operations manager for the magazine, said that readers are
given a clue that an article is a paid advertisement when the business's
logo, telephone number and other information is included on the page.
"They're like
infomercials," Hevel said. "We call them profiles."
But two other magazines, "Our
Town" and "Gainesville Magazine," only allow paid articles
when the article appears as part of a paid advertisement and the
advertisement is clearly marked as such.
"You get a lot of requests for
self-promotional articles," said Charlie Delatorre, publisher of
"Our Town."
He said the magazine struggled with
the idea of paid-for articles for a while until the arrival of Editor
Patricia Camburn Behnke. He said after she arrived, the line between
"real" articles and paid-for articles became clear.
If a reader doesn't know the
difference, "the product tends to lose credibility," Delatorre
said.
In "Our Town," any
paid-for articles have the words "Special Advertising Feature" put
on them.
The same is true with
"Gainesville Magazine," which is owned by the Gainesville Sun
newspaper.
"If the advertising department
creates any ad that could look like a story, it's marked as a special
advertising piece," Editor Jacki Levine said. "Our credibility is
at stake. The reader has no way to know (if a story is paid for) if it is
not marked."
Both "Gainesville
Magazine" and "Our Town" also have a policy that only the
advertising department can write paid-for articles. The news and feature
writers are not allowed to write paid-for articles.
Alachua's Aggressive
Marketing Efforts
Out of all the area's small towns,
the city of Alachua has been the most aggressive in marketing efforts.
The first efforts began in the
early 1990s when then-City Manager Mark Duchon would work with the Chamber
of Commerce to give personal tours to prospective businesses thinking of
moving to town.
One such business was Sabine, which
ended up moving to the city.
In 1995, the city got a major,
unintentional marketing boost when the city was named the best rural town in
Florida. Soon thereafter, a sign was placed on I-75, letting motorists know
they were entering a city that has been named the best of its kind.
Soon thereafter, efforts between
the city and the Alachua Chamber of Commerce were combined, and a billboard
on Interstate 75 appeared that advertised the city.
A few years ago, the city hired an
agency to create a television commercial and theme song for the city. The
city didn't like either, and that "fell by the wayside," Watson
said.
But recently, the city stepped up
its marketing efforts, particularly with the news that the Wal-Mart and
Sysco distribution centers were coming to town to join the Dollar General
Distribution Center.
That meant thousands of new jobs,
and the city spent $20,000 to market a new bus service to transport people
from east Gainesville to the jobs in Alachua.
Then came a big advertising blitz
in various media in which the city advertised its day-long Fourth of July
event, culminating in a giant fireworks show.
Following that was a television
commercial featuring the mayor and city manager.
Soon after that, the articles about
Watson and Calderwood appeared in the "Good Life Community"
magazine.
Watson said that when people see
just how extensive the marketing effort by the city has been over the years,
they'll see that the articles on himself and the mayor were the next step in
the marketing effort.
"We don't look at ourselves as
a little town anymore," Watson said. "We want the surrounding
communities to know about Alachua. We have to let them know what the
leadership is about."
Mall sure to be issue for Davie voters
Initial approval of a giant shopping and office complex at Shotgun Road
and Arvida Parkway sets up a big election issue in Davie.
BY BREANNE GILPATRICK
In a contentious meeting that lasted until after 3 a.m. Thursday, Davie
gave the initial OK for development of a lavish shopping and dining complex
on land that had been set aside for farming or sprawling home lots.
Developers and town leaders say The Commons, a 152-acre commercial
development proposed along Interstate 75 will generate millions in taxes.
And developers early Thursday morning promised to give some of the money to
the town before the project is built.
The initial approval also sets up a key issue in races for two Town
Council seats, since the project will come up for final approval after the
March 13 elections.
Neighboring Weston is dead-set against it, and many Davie residents fear
it will degrade the Western-themed town's charm and bring traffic and other
urban headaches to their neighborhoods.
''What's wrong with leaving it residential?'' said Warren Niles,
president of the Highland Ranch Estates homeowners association. ``Leave the
homes on it.''
Town Council members listened to more than six hours of speeches by
developers, more than 50 residents and several outside consultants before
voting 4-1 to give developers the first permission needed to build at the
northeast corner of Shotgun Road and Arvida Parkway.
The required supermajority vote allows Davie Commons Holdings Corp. -- an
alliance of Turnberry Associates and Retail Estate -- to request county and
state approval for a commercial development on the agriculturally zoned
land.
It's likely to be back on the town agenda for final approval in about
nine months.
The town's current land use plan calls for no more than one home per
acre.
400 AT MEETING
More than 400 residents packed Town Hall Wednesday night, spilling over
to watch on a screen outside or on a television in another part of Town
Hall. Others lined the stretch of Orange Drive in front of Town Hall, waving
hand-drawn signs reading, ''Yay Davie Commons!'' and ''No Stinking
Commons!'' at passing drivers.
''We're elated,'' Jodie Siegel, an attorney for Turnberry, said after the
meeting. ``It's nice to see the culmination of all your hard work and
effort. We have a long road ahead. But we're looking forward to traveling
it.''
The Commons would include offices, a 300-room hotel and more than a
million square feet of retail -- possibly including stores such as
Nordstrom, Bloomingdale's and Saks Fifth Avenue.
Advocates cited estimates that the project would pump $3.5 million a year
into the town's budget.
''This town is not going to remain solvent in perpetuity if we don't do
something,'' Mayor Tom Truex said.
But some questioned the need for more shopping options, since the
proposed site is less than 10 miles from both Sawgrass Mills in Sunrise and
Pembroke Lakes Mall in Pembroke Pines.
''Is there a need for another mall?'' 11-year-old Elizabeth Grindell
asked the council. ``I think we should use the land for a more useful thing,
like a park.''
Developers downplayed the potential traffic impact, claiming it would add
fewer cars to local roads than a new housing subdivision.
In exchange for the town's approval, developers will ask that the
agricultural exemption on the 152-acre property be lifted beginning in 2008.
The change would increase the taxable value of the land from less than
$100,000 to about $20.1 million, creating a windfall for the town, Siegel
said.
In addition, if the land-use change receives final town approval,
developers have agreed to pay $3.5 million per year to guarantee that Davie
receives the amount of revenue the project is estimated to generate.
ONE NO VOTE
Councilwoman Judy Paul cast the dissenting vote, saying the project goes
against the rural historical character of West Davie.
''I have supported open spaces,'' she said. ``And I'm trying to preserve
what's left of our rural lifestyle.''
Weston officials already have said they plan to fight, and hired
consultants to speak against the project Wednesday. They argue the project
would bring additional traffic to Weston roads without benefit to Weston.
Council members also have said there's no guarantee they'll cast the same
vote when The Commons returns later this year.
''I want to see this project move forward,'' Vice Mayor Mike Crowley said
Thursday morning. ``It doesn't mean they're going to have my support when
they come back around a second time. But I think it's close enough where
this council should move forward with it.''
Letter surprises Elgin residents
By MICHAEL D. BATES
mbates@hernandotoday.com
BROOKSVILLE — Losing your home to a four-lane highway on Elgin Boule-vard?
Not to worry.
U.S. Home is there for you.
That’s the gist of a letter that the company sent out to people who
live along that highway. But the letter raised some concerns because it was
sent to people on both sides of the road, including those who are not in the
way of the road.
“As we understand a four-lane highway would have a big impact on the
decision you make, we would like to introduce an amazing, prominent
community right in your neighborhood,” wrote Howard Vogin, vice president
of sales for U.S. Home’s coastal region in a letter sent to homeowners
dated Feb. 2.
Vogin then proceeds to tick off the merits of Sterling Hill, near Elgin
Boulevard and Barclay Avenue. There are homes “to fit every lifestyle”
ranging from the low $200,000s to mid $300,000s.
“U.S. Home also features programs to help you sell or lease your
existing property,” the letter ends.
“I was very upset when I received that letter because I think they’re
soliciting,” homeowner Anthony Langone said. “I feel it’s wrong.”
Langone’s home is on the south side and not scheduled to be torn down.
He said he has no intention of moving to Sterling Hill.
A county consultant is recommending the county buy up the 34 homes on the
north side of Elgin — from Mariner Boulevard east to Village Van Gogh —
to make way for a new four-lane highway, to be built in the next two or
three years.
County commissioners will discuss the consultant’s recommendation and
propose a settlement agreement at an upcoming business meeting, probably on
Feb. 27.
The county will pay for an independent fee appraisal to determine the
home’s current market value.
If a mutually agreed-upon price is reached, the county and property owner
will make the deal.
If a deal can’t be reached, the county will go to court and try to take
the property by eminent domain through the condemnation process.
Terry Tegzlaff, whose home is on the north side of Elgin and scheduled to
be demolished, said he did not receive the letter. Tegzlaff now lives in
Citrus County and has his Elgin home up for sale.
The county’s taking his home actually will benefit him, he said.
As for the letter: “It’s kind of ambulance chasing, just like the
lawyers,” he said. “But it is an opportunity for both sides. They’re
just putting themselves out there and saying they’re available (to
help).”
Langone’s brother, Steven Langone, called the letter a “slap in our
face.
“Why didn’t they send letters to us before?” he asked. “Why did
they wait until now after all this broke loose?”
U.S. Home’s new home consultant Eric Parks said the letters were
inadvertently sent to homeowners who live on the south side of the road. He
apologized for any misunderstanding and said he would e-mail Vogin of the
error.
“I didn’t know the letter went out until today (Thursday) when a
homeowner brought it to my attention,” Parks said.
He said the letter was only meant to help those residents who are
affected by the planned road and give them options in relocating.
“It was all in good faith,” he said.
Parks said residents can call him about the letter or U.S. Home at
727-804-7719.
Reporter Michael D. Bates can be contacted at 352-544-5290.
Port St. Lucie to deal with Martin on road
By Teresa Lane
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Friday, February 09, 2007
PORT ST. LUCIE — The western Palm City corridor won't be a road to
nowhere, city council members conceded Thursday after months of threatening
to prohibit a connection with Port St. Lucie Boulevard near Becker Road.
City council members said they'll draft a proposed pact with Martin
County that allows developers in southwest Port St. Lucie to be assessed for
road impacts on the corridor and a few other Martin roads as long as future
Martin County developers pay their fair share also.
Martin County Commission Chairman Michael DiTerlizzi said he thinks the
compromise will be agreeable to his board and will present it in two weeks.
Though Councilman Jack Kelly said the connection means a planned
roundabout at Becker and Port St. Lucie Boulevard will fail because of the
added traffic, City Manager Don Cooper hinted that major development
projects planned for the region could mean redesigning Becker Road anyway.
One of those is a regional shopping mall planned just west of Becker and
Interstate 95, slated to open sometime after 2011.
Council members also adopted a years-in-the-making joint planning
agreement with St. Lucie County that requires both agencies to share
information on major developments planned inside their borders.
Group pushes for pretty stormwater ponds
By NATHAN CRABBE
SUN STAFF WRITER
Fritzi Olson has been successful at getting local groups to adopt beautiful
rivers.
Now she'll see if she has the same luck with ugly stormwater ponds.
Olson is executive director of Current Problems, the Gainesville group best
known for the Adopt A River program. The group's latest program, Plant A
Pond, recruits community groups for planting vegetation around stormwater
ponds to improve water quality.
"It will make them look better and make them worth more than just flood
control," she said.
Stormwater ponds have historically been used to prevent flooding, with
aesthetics and water quality as secondary concerns at best. Consequently,
area ponds are often barren of vegetation and surrounded by fencing.
Plant A Pond is among efforts to change the look and purpose of stormwater
ponds.
In Gainesville, Springhill residents successfully pushed for the area around
a neighborhood stormwater pond to be turned into a park. In Alachua County,
developers are now required to plant native vegetation around newly built
ponds.
On the University of Florida campus, a stormwater basin was recontoured and
planted with diverse vegetation.
Such vegetation filters and absorbs pollutants from water entering the pond,
said Mark Clark, a water-quality specialist at UF. That means water quality
is improved before it seeps into the aquifer or flows into other water
bodies.
Plants also provide wildlife habitat and give stormwater ponds a purpose for
the community beyond flood control, he said.
"They can be so much more," he said.
The Plant A Pond program will provide participants with training and an
initial batch of plants for free, Olson said. Participants will be expected
to do regular upkeep four times a year for at least two years and report
back on their progress.
The effort is in part based on Hillsborough County's Adopt-A-Pond program.
The county was the first in the state to encourage groups to plant
vegetation around stormwater ponds, said John McGee, the Adopt-A-Pond
program coordinator.
Since the program started in 1991, he said, about 300 ponds have been
adopted and planted. McGee said most participants are looking to improve the
look of ugly ponds.
But he said they eventually get a better understanding of how planting
vegetation and reducing fertilizer use in neighboring yards can improve
water quality.
"The biggest benefit is people understand how their actions impact the
pond," he said.
Already, Gainesville residents have taken action to improve stormwater
ponds. The Springhill Neighborhood Association pushed for a pond being built
in that neighborhood to be turned into a park.
Vivian Filer, who heads the association, said residents were initially upset
that a stormwater pond was being built without their consultation.
They eventually persuaded the city to install a path and other amenities for
residents to use, she said.
Olson then helped plant native vegetation around the pond. Filer said
neighborhood children can now learn about native plants and how to care for
them.
"I think it's just such a great opportunity to do some
neighborhood-friendly things," she said.
Olson said the Springhill effort is the prototype for Plant A Pond. She
hopes the program will help stormwater ponds become more than just barren
ditches surrounded by fences.
"There's no reason they can't help water quality and wildlife habitat
and diversity," she said.
Nathan
Crabbe can be reached at 352-338-3176 or crabben@gville sun.com.
FYI: About Plant A Pond
- Gainesville-based Current Problems is starting a program, Plant A
Pond, for community groups to adopt local stormwater ponds. Participants
agree to plant vegetation around the pond, improving the appearance and
water quality.
- Groups commit to maintain the ponds for two years. Participants attend
a workshop and are given a manual and the initial batch of plants for
free. They are expected to pay for any future plants or work.
State commission approves
coal-plant plan
By Bruce Ritchie
DEMOCRAT STAFF WRITER
The Florida Public Service Commission staff Thursday recommended approval
of a proposed coal-fired power plant in Taylor County.
The city of Tallahassee is a partner in the proposed 800-megawatt plant
near Perry.
Environmentalists say the plant will increase pollution in the region and
can be avoided with renewable energy and conservation. The partnership says
the plant will use modern technology to reduce pollution.
The Public Service Commission held four days of public hearings in
January to determine whether the plant was needed. Environmental issues were
not to be considered in the hearings, said PSC Chairwoman Lisa Polak Edgar.
The staff recommendation says the coal plant "will add to electric
system reliability and integrity and appears to be cost-effective."
The proposed plant, called the Taylor Energy Center, also will provided
needed fuel diversity and will save $899 million for the municipalities who
are involved in the project, according to PSC staff.
The commission will meet Tuesday to make a decision on the project, said
Anthony De Luise, the agency's director of public information.
He said individual commissioners, in making a decision, will consider the
recommendation along with their own review of the evidence.
A Taylor Energy Center spokesman said that if the PSC approves, the
partnership will apply in the near future for site-certification from the
Florida Department of Environmental Protection.
Cypress Creek Road Apartments Stalled
By KEVIN WIATROWSKI The Tampa Tribune
Published: Feb 9, 2007
WESLEY CHAPEL - The partnership planning apartments for Cypress Creek
Road will have to wait two weeks to learn the project's fate.
Pasco County's Development Review Committee delayed until Feb. 22 further
consideration of James and Sylvia Scarpo's plan to turn land they and their
neighbors own into a 488-unit complex.
The property is directly north of King Ranch. The ranch owners plan a mix
of 548 apartments and town houses next to the Scarpo group's land.
The rest of the ranch, which is north of County Line Road between Cypress
Creek Road and Interstate 75, would be given over to offices and other
work-related development.
The changes by both Scarpo and King Ranch are being driven by the looming
construction of Cypress Creek Town Center, a regional mall, to the north of
both properties.
The county wants the Scarpo group to improve Cypress Creek Road, which
falls below Pasco's standards.
Those improvements include relocating a set of power lines, which would
require the Scarpos to work on part of King Ranch.
Therein lies the problem, said the group's attorney, Jerry Figurski.
King Ranch's owners won't cooperate with the Scarpo group on the Cypress
Creek Road changes, he said.
King Ranch attorney Clark Hobby pledged his clients would sort things out
with their neighbors.
"There is insignificant right of way to make any improvements from
King Ranch south to County Line Road," Hobby said. "In short, they
have to work with us to sort this out."
Reporter Kevin Wiatrowski can be reached at (813) 948-4201 or kwiatrowski@tampatrib.com.
Condo Market Morphing
By SHANNON BEHNKEN The Tampa Tribune
Published: Feb 9, 2007
ORLANDO - The frenzied condominium building boom in Florida's major cities
appears to be slowing dramatically, and as a result some developers may scrap
their plans while others shift to apartment construction.
At least that's the assessment of some of the builders and developers
gathered here at one of the nation's largest annual builders conferences, the
International Builders Show.
"There are too many high-end projects in many of the cities in
Florida," said Bill Donges, chief executive officer of Lane Co., an
Atlanta firm that specializes in developing and managing multiunit projects.
Donges was among the builders and developers who sat on a panel Thursday to
discuss the outlook for the condominium and apartment market. Panel members
said they expect major condo projects that are under way in Florida's major
cities to be completed but for unsold units in those projects to take longer
to sell. That could further cool the appetite for starting high-rise condo
construction projects, panel members agreed.
A representative from the National Association of Homebuilders, the show
organizer, said there still is a demand for condominiums, including the dozens
scheduled to open in downtown areas of Florida's big cities this year.
However, panel discussion members said too many developers latched onto the
boom and planned more projects than the market can absorb - particularly
luxury high-rises.
Developers in Florida cities such as Tampa, where more than 30 condo
buildings have been proposed for downtown, likely will scratch more than half
of the planned developments or postpone them until the condo market gains
steam again, Donges predicted.
"These high-end units will be in the market and will have to be
absorbed at some time," he said.
In Tampa, eight condos are expected to open in the downtown core this year.
Several are nearing completion, including SkyPoint, Grand Central at Kennedy
and Towers of Channelside. The developers have said their projects are nearly
sold out.
Panel members noted that many units being built in Tampa are priced for a
well-heeled clientele, and that raises an affordability issue.
Prices for condo units in projects planned for Tampa have ranged from
$200,000 to more than $1 million, with the majority of sold units priced at
more than $300,000. That's more than the median price of a single-family home
in the Tampa Bay area.
Donges said his company wanted to jump into Tampa's condo market and was
planning to build one at Kennedy Boulevard and Hoover Street. But as the
market slowed, the company decided to build a 210-unit luxury apartment
building on the site.
Steve Patterson, chief executive officer of Orlando-based Zom Inc., also
sat in on Thursday's panel discussion. He said his company, which historically
has been an apartment builder, converted many of its projects to condominiums
in recent years and got into condo tower development.
But the company is changing its strategy now and focusing on building
apartments, converting some condos back to rental units and trying to build
more affordable apartments.
In Tampa, the company has focused on apartments, including the Arbors at
Carrollwood and Arbors at Fletcher Island.
The apartment-to-condo conversion trend has been white hot in the Tampa Bay
area, where several high-end apartment complexes near the city were converted
to condos. As the median priced single-family home jumped from the low
$100,000s in 2000 to about $230,000 in 2006, converted condos in suburban
areas offered an affordable alternative to some homebuyers.
In all, more than 28,000 Tampa Bay area apartment units were purchased for
condo conversions in the past 2 1/2 years, according to New York-based Real
Capitol Analytics, which tracks real estate trends.
With so many condo conversions in suburban areas, there is a demand for
affordable work-force housing, Patterson said
"We're faced with having to pay these high land prices and
construction prices and still build affordable" units, he said.
"We're going to have to push the limits on rents and accept bare minimums
on returns." Many of the converted condos are sitting empty, and
investors who fueled the conversion boom by buying up blocks of units are
struggling to sell or lease them.
"The conversion started with Class A apartments, then the conversion
craze moved down. Apartments that were built in the 1970s were
converted," he said. "That eliminated many affordable units."
Reporter Shannon Behnken can be reached at sbehnken@tampatrib.com
or (813) 259-7804.
Brit investors find dream homes aren't
Mark Pino
Sentinel Staff Writer
February 9, 2007
KISSIMMEE -- Dipti Kanani put down a $50,000 deposit on a Four Corners
investment home in 2005.
And then she waited for work on the $249,900 home near ChampionsGate in
Osceola County to begin. Not only did construction never get under way, but
the developer still does not have the county approvals required to build its
project.
More than a year later, Kanani sued to get her money back from the developer,
British American Homes LLC.
"I intended to invest to secure holiday property for myself and friends
in Orlando," said Kanani, who now lives in Sydney, Australia. "I
enjoy the Floridian sunshine, and the appeal of Disney nearby was a major
factor in securing the deposit."
But when the company told Kanani and other investors that the homes would cost
17.5 percent more than the original price, buyers started asking for their
money back.
When the company didn't comply, they sued. Five other investors from the
United Kingdom have similar suits pending in Osceola Circuit Court. Like
Kanani, most are seeking the return of about $50,000 per unit. A judge entered
a default judgment on Kanani's behalf after the company failed to respond to
the suit, and she collected late last year.
The development, called Elliot's Landing, was marketed as a vacation haven and
investment close to Walt Disney World. It is in the booming Four Corners area,
where signs for vacation homes dot U.S. Highway 27, and the Omni hotel towers
over the landscape near Interstate 4.
The last action by county staff on the project was in January 2006, records
show. A planner working with the development said the project stalled over
negotiations with the county for a road that would serve the 123-acre
development. Planners envision 243 units in a gated community that is supposed
to include a clubhouse and recreational amenities including swimming pools,
volleyball and tennis.
British American Homes has not filed any response in the Osceola suits, and a
representative reached for this story said she was not authorized to speak for
the company, which lists offices in Orlando and Miami.
A print of an October e-mail in one of the court files from Hudson Gabay, the
head of British American Homes, states, "The refund process IS under way
and clients HAVE been refunded and are being refunded every week."
Gabay wrote that investors' refunds will be given "anywhere from days to
within 6 weeks." The note states that buyers are bombarding an employee
with hundreds of daily e-mails and voice messages.
Eric Glazer, a Miami attorney who represented Kanani and has two other suits
pending against the company, said he wasn't aware of anyone who had gotten
their money back without legal action.
Investors in several other cases asked for default judgments, court records
show.
The six investors started asking for refunds in June 2006 after they received
word of the cost increase.
"I realized that the cost to build has risen dramatically over the last
18 months and the houses can no longer be [built] for the original estimates.
They therefore can not be completed and sold for the original estimates,"
wrote Jason Asbury, a developer whose company was bought by British American
Homes and said he was working on Elliot's Landing.
The note said buyers could get their money back or pay more -- including
another $10,000 within 10 days -- to stay in the deal.
Glazer said he is "extremely confident" of prevailing for his
remaining clients and has no doubt the company can return the deposits --
because of the value of the land where the development is supposed to be
built.
The state Attorney General's Office has received six complaints about the
company in the past 16 months, a spokeswoman said.
Anyone with a complaint may call the department's fraud-prevention line at
1-866-966-7226.
Kanani, 33, said she had complained to the state but hadn't heard anything.
She had been to Florida before and came to Osceola to check out the property
for herself before investing.
"It seemed real. It seemed like it was all going to happen," she
said by telephone from Australia.
One buyer, who didn't want to be named, said he entered the deal without ever
coming to Florida and hoped to flip the house after a year or two.
"It would be terrible if Orlando got a reputation as a place for sucker
real-estate investments," Glazer said.
Mark Pino can be reached at mpino@orlandosentinel.com or 407-931-5935.
50,000 More People
By GARY PINNELL
gpinnell@highlandstoday.com
SEBRING — Sun ’n Lake of Sebring conducted a census last year.
“We had 7,400 people during snowbird season, and we’re under 3,000 year
around,” said Mick Grosh, assistant general manager of the housing
development, north of Sebring on U.S. Highway 27.
So when he heard the latest Highlands County population estimates – that
we’ll grow more than 50,000 people in 10 years – Grosh wasn’t surprised.
“That’s probably a reasonable guess,” Grosh said. He looked at the
reports for driveway permits in Sun ’n Lake, a unincorporated community of
3,230 homes, filled mostly with retirees.
In 2002, only 15 driveway permits were issued, he said. In 2003, the number
jumped to 70; then 121 in 2004, 89 in 2005, and 211 in 2006. And so far this
year, permits for new driveways are averaging one per day.
“We could be headed toward a record year again,” Grosh said.
And the demographic is changing too, Grosh thinks. Sun ’n Lake started as
a golf course community for retirees. Now, he says, “People are bringing
children with them. The houses with five and six bedrooms are selling the
most.”
Census Numbers
The U.S. Census Bureau estimated Highlands County had a population of
95,496 in 2005, a 9.3 percent increase from the April 1, 2000 head count.
Don Hanna, a planner for Highlands County, used the University of
Florida’s Bureau of Economic and Business Research 2006 estimate of 96,672
to project a winter population of 117,206.“That’s a 20 percent
increase,” Hanna said.
“I would say that’s low,” said Mike Willingham, executive director of
Sebring Airport Authority and an economic developer who is familiar with
population estimates. “I’d say the number ought to be more like 35,000 to
40,000. But that’s just my guess... I base that on the roadways during this
time of year, the occupancy of the hotels and restaurants, Wal-Mart, you name
it.”
Sebring is attracting more vacationing and residential tourists, and it’s
also getting more in-migration from coastal cities to escape the congestion
and traffic, Willingham agreed with Grosh. “Younger people with families are
moving here to work. No question about it.”
The Highlands County Profile 2006-2007 predicts 155,300 permanent residents
by 2025.
And because property values have doubled or tripled in Highlands County
during the past 10 years, Willingham predicted Florida’s most rural
counties, like Hardee and DeSoto, will see more growth in the next 10 years.
“Central Florida is Florida’s last frontier,” Willingham said.
Not So Fast
Others aren’t as sure. Marty Roepstorff, utilities director for the city
of Sebring, says sewer and water use in Highlands County’s largest city
remains consistent.
“We don’t seen a significant increase in pumpage,” Roepstorff said.
The number of meters read goes up and down throughout the year, without a
significant upward trend in the winter.
“Fifty thousand people sounds awful high,” said Highlands County
Commissioner Edgar Stokes. When the commissioners were deciding whether to
pass impact fees, Stokes studied how many deeds were recorded and how many
building permits were sold.
“The number of deeds recorded has fallen,” Stokes said. “We knew it
was just a buying frenzy.
“We thought we were growing like crazy,” Stokes said, “but we
weren’t.”
He produced the Highlands County Profile 2005-2006, and compared its
projections with the University of Florida’s Statistical Abstract 2005.
The abstract projects low, medium and high categories. He believed Hanna is
using the highest possible growth category.
Florida’s Department of Community Affairs used similar reasoning for
limiting growth in Highlands County, said Hanna.
Hanna’s boss, Development Services Director Jim Polatty, wrote a memo to
DCA, pointing out that high and low categories existed because of the
uncertainty of precise medium growth categories.
“Historically speaking ... two-thirds of all (67) county forecasts should
fall within the Low and High forecasts,” he wrote.
Snowbird Season
Hanna projected a population increase of 50,000 during tourist season –
the six coldest fall and winter months – over the next 10 years.
“It doesn’t really surprise me,” said South Florida Community College
President Norman Stephens.
“Snowbirds – I use that as an affectionate term,” he said, “are at
the heart of the cultural programs we put on here. We set our schedule for
them. We don’t want to have a program too early, or too late.”
The life-time learners program designs classes to attract visiting senior
citizens, including aquatic exercise. During the spring and summer, buffets
are suspended at the college-operated Hotel Jacaranda. A Sebring restaurant,
Sweetie Pye’s, closes in the summer.
The county grew 3.5 percent between 2004 and 2005, from 92,057 to 95,496,
the U.S. Census Bureau estimates.
Stephens divided the 50,000 estimated increase into 10 years, and realized
it would mean only a 2 percent increase per year.
“That’s realistic,” he reasoned
Move These Houses, Expert Says
By SHANNON BEHNKEN The Tampa Tribune
Published: Feb 8, 2007
Home builders should offer incentives or slash prices to sell off hundreds
of thousands of vacant new houses glutting markets nationwide, housing experts
warned Wednesday at the International Builders Show in Orlando.
In addition, until the new home inventory is gone, builders should hold off
constructing more homes, said David Seiders, chief economist for the National
Association of Home Builders.
"I'm telling builders that we absolutely have to move these
houses" before the real estate market will rebound, Seiders said.
The Tampa Bay area is among the places with an oversupply of new homes on
the market.
There were 4,606 vacant new homes in the Bay area at the end of the fourth
quarter of 2006, an increase of 1,700 from the same period a year ago,
according to housing research firm Metrostudy.
Tony Polito, a Tampa-based director for Metrostudy, said the Bay area is
faring better than the rest of Florida, which has an average of a four-month
supply of new homes for sale. Inventory in the Bay area is at 2.8 months, he
said, meaning it would take that long to sell all the homes at the current
sales pace.
Nationwide, economists estimated home builders constructed about 600,000
more homes during the past three years than the market could absorb.
The number of homes under construction is dropping, and builders are
offering incentives, such as free upgrades and discounted prices.
Polito estimates it will take three to six more months to work through the
inventory in the Bay area.
Economists from mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac predicted
Wednesday at the builders conference that the housing market will see more
drops in the number of sales and prices in some markets, but that the
cool-down will bottom out later in the year and a gradual recovery will begin.
"But that doesn't mean we'll bounce back to 2005 levels," said
Frank Nothaft, chief economist for Freddie Mac. "Absolutely not."
The new home market is suffering in part because of the record number of
existing homes on the market, economists said.
More than 34,000 existing homes are on the market in Hillsborough and
Pinellas counties, according to local real estate trade groups.
The slowdown in building and the need to move the inventory of new and
existing homes is good news for some, Nothaft said. It has gotten tougher to
afford a home because of the record price increases since 2000, he said.
If home prices come down in some markets, more people will buy, he said.
In the Tampa-St. Petersburg-Clearwater metropolitan area, the median sales
price of an existing home in December was $230,800, up 3 percent from the same
month in 2005, according to the Florida Association of Realtors. In December
2000, the median sales price was $108,200.
Reporter Shannon Behnken can be reached at (813) 259-7804 or sbehnken@tampatrib.com
New Mall's Neighbors Plan Apartments
By KEVIN WIATROWSKI The Tampa Tribune
Published: Feb 8, 2007
WESLEY CHAPEL - As Cypress Creek Town Center gets closer to construction,
its neighbors are moving to remake their property more in the regional mall's
image.
A group of landowners along Cypress Creek Road has asked Pasco County to
rezone 29 acres to allow construction of 488 apartment units.
The property is on the west bank of Cypress Creek. The mall will be on the
east bank.
The Development Review Committee will consider the rezoning proposal at
1:30 p.m. today in Dade City.
James and Sylvia Scarpo are joined in their proposal by Carlyle and Judith
Wolding and Randall and Diane Sherman. The three couples own abutting
properties along Cypress Creek Road.
Greystar GP LLC, a Texas-based company, will develop the land.
Just to their south, the owners of King Ranch also have proposed turning
their property into a mix of commercial and residential uses.
King Ranch is south of the regional mall site, between Cypress Creek and
County Line Road.
Mall developer Richard E. Jacobs Group plans to extend County Road 54 south
across their property and King Ranch to County Line Road.
As part of their proposed project, the landowners will have to make several
improvements to Cypress Creek Road and County Line Road. The list includes:
•Widen Cypress Creek Road between Laurel Ridge Drive and Bald Cypress
Lane.
•Add northbound and southbound turn lanes to Cypress Creek Road.
•Add eastbound and westbound turn lanes on County Line Road at Cypress
Creek.
IF YOU GO
WHAT: Development Review Committee consideration of apartment
project on Cypress Creek Road
WHEN: 1:30 p.m. today
WHERE: Historic Pasco County Courthouse, 37918 Meridian Ave., Dade
City
Reporter Kevin Wiatrowski can be reached at (813) 948-4201 or kwiatrowski@tampatrib.com
Creek restoration raises concerns
By Julian Pecquet
DEMOCRAT STAFF WRITER
A Leon County project that was billed as a way to save a threatened creek
is raising concerns among some residents that it could end up damaging the
environment.
Last year, the county began construction on the Black Creek restoration
project, which will move a stretch of McCracken Road out of Black Creek. Since
then, some residents have raised concerns that the destruction of forest land
is too much for what should be a small connector road serving only a few
hundred cars a day.
"It's a lot bigger than anybody thought it was going to be," said
Susie Howell, who lives off McCracken Road. "I wonder where all the
animals are going to go."
But County Commissioner Cliff Thaell, the lead commissioner behind the
project, said plans for two 11-foot lanes of road and three stormwater ponds
haven't changed from what was presented to the public.
"I don't know why (residents) would be surprised," Thaell said.
"You can't cut a road through a property without cutting down some
trees."
Kim Wood, the project manager, said a little more than 100 trees that are
more than 12 inches across were taken down, plus an uncounted number of
smaller trees. The project will add 344 trees and 5,000 underbrush plants
where the old road now runs, she said.
Efforts to restore Black Creek began several years ago because residents
were concerned that the creek fills with sediment every time it overflows and
washes over McCracken Road, which is a dirt road.
Residents opposed the idea of paving McCracken because they like the slow
speed limits and the area's rural feel, said Edith Sheeks. Instead, in 2003,
they backed a plan to move the road and let the wetland revert to its natural
state. The county bought 70 acres of land, assessed at $533,000.
Over the following few years, the county worked on permitting and design,
said Tony Park, the county's director of Public Works. Last November, county
commissioners voted to move forward with a $1.8 million construction contract.
Work should take about a year.
Some residents, such as Sheeks, were opposed to the project from the
get-go.
"I feel very strongly that this whole thing was a mistake and is very
damaging to our quality of life and our environment," she said.
But Howell and several others started worrying more after seeing the trees
come down.
"We just have concerns that other parts of the environment are being
impacted," said Kelly McGrath, who moved into the neighborhood recently.
Others, however, expect unintended benefits from the project.
Andy Bruggner, who lives off Miccosukee Road, said he's seen at least four
crashes at the curve near his home in the five years he's lived there. He
hopes signals at the new intersection will have a calming effect on traffic.
"It'll slow them down a bit," he said. "At times, it gets to
be a racetrack out here."
Fern fuels fears over control of refuge
By Michael C. Bender
Palm Beach Post Capital Bureau
Thursday, February 08, 2007
TALLAHASSEE — Some conservationists are concerned that a climbing fern
flourishing in South Florida - and overwhelming any native plant in its path -
might also doom a delicate balance of control for the Arthur R. Marshall
Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge.
"It is a nightmare come true," former U.S. Department of the
Interior Undersecretary Nat Reed said about the Old World climbing fern (Lygodium
microphyllum).
Reed, a Jupiter Island resident, was involved in a barrage of e-mails
circulated this week between environmentalists worried that a state House
committee would use the fern to evict the federal government from the
147,000-acre refuge.
But state Rep. Will Kendrick, R-Carrabelle and chairman of the House
Committee on Conservation and State Lands, tried Wednesday to assuage those
fears.
"This is to establish whether there is a need for additional policies,
modified policies, new policies or whatever," said Kendrick, a third-term
lawmaker who switched parties after the November election. "It is not
specifically to pull a lease from the Loxahatchee National Wildlife
Refuge."
Some environmentalists fear that the fern invading about 40 percent of the
refuge could provide the state with an opportunity to break its lease with the
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, which manages the refuge. Such a threat could
be used as leverage against federal requirements to reduce the amount of
phosphorus entering the Everglades, they warn.
Under the 50-year contract approved by the South Florida Water Management
District, the state leases the land to the federal government, requiring
certain standards be met during five-year periods. One of those standards,
which will be measured in July, requires the federal government to control
invasive exotic species.
While refuge officials say they have cut the number of melaleuca trees in
half since 2002, water district officials say the climbing fern has
multiplied.
Refuge manager Mark Musaus told the committee that he was meeting all of
the performance measures in the contract.
"We're working as effectively as we can," Musaus said.
"We're trying to use all the technologies that are out there."
Rep. Richard Machek, D-Delray Beach, the committee vice-chairman, said the
state lawmakers needed to lobby Congress to better pay for the project.
"I don't know if there is another refuge like this," Machek said.
"It's a diamond."
Oppenheimer Report
THE OPPENHEIMER REPORT
Global warming likely to hit hard in Americas
Andres Oppenheimer
aoppenheimer@MiamiHerald.com
If you listen to some of the
experts who issued a much-awaited United Nations report on global warming in
Paris last week, it sounds like rising oceans will soon make their way to your
bedroom and force you to hop out of bed in the middle of the night.
It sounds a little bit far fetched, but many scientists say that climate
changes will have a greater impact -- and closer to home -- than many of us
think.
Earlier this week, after more than 500 leading scientists from 113 nations
issued the preliminary findings of a U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change, I called several authors of the report to ask them what can we expect
to happen in the Western Hemisphere if global warming continues at its present
pace.
The U.N. report said that world temperatures will rise by two to 11 degrees
this century -- mainly because of the massive U.S. burning of fossil fuels and
the rapid deforestation of the Amazon forest -- and that this will cause
oceans to rise by seven inches to two feet over the same period of time. The
report did not give regional forecasts. A more specific report is due out
later this year.
So, based on these general projections, I asked Osvaldo F. Canziani,
co-chairman of one of the panel's groups, in a telephone interview, what we
can expect to happen in this part of the world.
Canziani said we will see a 1- to 2-centigrade rise in temperature over the
next two decades, which will cause havoc in several countries:
• Rising oceans will cause severe
flooding in U.S. coastal areas, Caribbean beach resorts, the Gulf of Mexico
and the Rio de la Plata Basin. This could affect major cities, such as Buenos
Aires and Montevideo.
• Glaciers in the Andean mountain range
of Peru, Colombia and Ecuador will melt at an increasingly faster pace,
creating water accumulations that will cause flooding and mudslides. This will
pose great danger to many mountain villages.
• Meantime, deforestation of the Amazon
as Brazil and its neighbors destroy huge jungle regions to, among other
things, expand their booming soybean exports to China, will reduce rainfall in
much of South America. This will lead to more forest fires and a greater
shortage of water in many areas.
• Shifting air currents, in addition to
deforestation, will make rainfall levels drop in some areas and increase in
others. Rainfall will drop by up to 20 percent in Mexico, Central America,
northeastern Brazil and southern Chile, while it will increase by up to 15
percent in South America's Rio de la Plata Basin stretching through Paraguay,
Argentina, Brazil and Uruguay.
Most experts agreed that poor people in the region will suffer the greatest
losses because they tend to live in more exposed areas and in more fragile
homes and often lack quick warning systems.
''In Latin America, politicians haven't realized the seriousness of this
issue yet,'' Canziani told me.
Critics of the U.N. report say there have been many previous U.N.
apocalyptic warnings that turned out to be wrong, and that it's far from
certain that global warming is caused by fossil fuel emissions, as the U.N.
panel concluded. They point out that there were periods of global warming
thousands of years ago, long before humans began driving Hummers.
''The panel's report is not conclusive,'' says Israel Ortega, a spokesman
for the Heritage Foundation in Washington, D.C. ``The debate is just
beginning.''
My opinion: I agree that U.N. scientific panels are not always right. In
the late 1970s, U.N. climate experts were predicting an imminent Ice Age and
worsening famines in India.
Instead, the world turned out to get hotter, and India is now exporting
food.
But common sense tells me that something weird is happening. Over the past
few years, we have seen extreme weather conditions in the United States, the
first hurricane along Brazil's coast and golf-ball-sized ice cubes falling on
usually balmy Buenos Aires. The weather is going crazy. So it may be time to
focus our energies on climate changes, before the water starts rising under
our beds.
Post script: The Venezuela Information Office, which according to its
website is funded by the Venezuelan government, says I incorrectly stated in
my last column that a new ''enabling law'' will allow President Hugo Chávez
to, among other things, call a referendum to change the Constitution and allow
his indefinite reelection. Indeed, Chávez has repeatedly said he will do
that, but this is unrelated to the new law
Disney may expand into urban frontier
The company talks of themed hotels and entertainment districts across U.S.
Scott Powers
Sentinel Staff Writer
February 8, 2007
Walt Disney Parks and Resorts is considering putting Disney-themed hotels and
nightlife districts into downtown areas of major cities that don't currently
have Disney properties.
Disney is not yet making any commitments to "urban Disney hotels" or
stand-alone Disney entertainment districts, Disney Parks and Resorts Chairman
Jay Rasulo told investors Wednesday night. But he outlined them as "some
of the ideas our business team and Imagineers are thinking about" as ways
to expand Disney's tourism business into new locales. Imagineers are Disney
designers and engineers.
In addressing investors, Rasulo said Disney is thinking about developing major
"flagship" hotels -- such as the Disney Grand Floridian at Walt
Disney World -- or themed hotels that could be built in large cities that
already are tourist draws. He did not cite examples.
He also said the Downtown Disney concept has been so successful at both Disney
World and Disneyland in California that the idea could be transplanted into
major urban areas.
Disney's also considering increasing the Disney Cruise Line fleet, its Disney
Vacation Club properties and its Adventures by Disney vacation-package
programs.
Disney also is contemplating small, immersive "niche theme parks"
and water parks in other cities, Rasulo said.
"Our relationships with millions of families will enable us to expand to
new businesses and new markets," Rasulo said. "We will never stop
dreaming."
Scott Powers can be reached at spowers@orlandosentinel.com or 407-420-5441.
Staff Writer
DAYTONA BEACH -- A once heralded countywide
water planning effort begun in 2003 appeared to be losing steam with a City
Commission action Wednesday.
Commissioners in Daytona Beach unanimously agreed to establish the Eastern
Volusia Regional Water Authority, along with Holly Hill and South Daytona.
Meanwhile, representatives of 14 cities directing the countywide Water
Authority of Volusia, called WAV, are expected to vote on the future of that
organization March 21.
"I really do feel that down the road a way, a unified effort is the
way to go," said Commissioner Shiela McKay, who nevertheless voted to
establish the east Volusia agency.
Commissioners agreed to pay $244,606 in dues owed to the Water Authority of
Volusia, pending a vote on changes including stripping the countywide water
authority of operational responsibilities and leave it as a planning group.
"We owe them money and we need to pay them," Mayor Glenn Ritchey
said. "We also need to stay a member of WAV."
Goals for the new eastside water authority include ensuring water supply,
conservation and applying for grants and liaisons with other governments and
agencies -- all missions of the countywide Water Authority of Volusia.
City officials in Daytona Beach began challenging the countywide authority
in 2005. Key issues included residents in one part of the county paying for
water projects elsewhere in the county and the possible takeover of city water
plants by the authority.
Efforts to develop a countywide solution to water supplies were praised in
2003 by experts because the county has one underground water supply source.
But Daytona Beach officials assert that pumping on one side of the county does
not deplete water from the other side of the county because of a high pressure
ridge.
As the countywide Water Authority of Volusia declines, local governments
could be looking at higher price tags for projects because fewer cities would
help pay the costs.
For example, westside residents in and around DeLand, DeBary and Deltona
might wind up paying more if a project moves forward to provide drinking water
from the St. Johns River because costs would likely not be spread out
countywide.
In the new Eastern Volusia Regional Water Authority, residents will only
pay to participate in projects agreed to by their cities.
Holly Hill and South Daytona officials will consider signing on to the east
Volusia water authority on Tuesday.
In an unrelated action, the City Commission repealed a controversial policy
adopted Jan. 10. The policy required city boards to get approval from the City
Commission before taking actions to adopt or amend city ordinances.
"The intent of the policy was to stimulate public involvement,"
City Manager Jim Chisholm said. "However, the public discussion has been
something other than that."
Critics asserted the policy was intended to control city boards, which have
been increasingly assertive on development proposals.
The first meeting scheduled under that policy, for 1 p.m. today, was
canceled.
Commissioner Rick Shiver asked for regular reports by boards to the City
Commission.
john.bozzo@news-jrnl.com
Storms pressure housing market
A Stetson University summit will address the hundreds who suddenly need
affordable homes.
Tanya Caldwell
Sentinel Staff Writer
February 8, 2007
Central Florida's affordable housing crisis just got a lot worse.
It was hard enough to find housing in Volusia County before Friday's
tornadoes, officials said. That problem was compounded last week after the
twister displaced hundreds of residents who have been dragged into the market
to look for new homes.
"The big problem is that you have a lot of elderly people that were
affected. They were able to survive on their Social Security checks as their
only source of income," County Chairman Frank Bruno said Wednesday.
"What compounds it is that property values have been inflated, property
taxes have gone up and so have insurance rates," Bruno said. "It's a
real major issue when you keep stacking all these things up."
Finding enough affordable housing has been a national problem for years, said
Sara Truhlar, a member of the Daytona Beach-based nonprofit FAITH, which
stands for Fighting Against Injustice Toward Harmony.
On Friday, FAITH will assemble community leaders to look into the housing
problem and pitch solutions. The reservations-only summit will take place at
Stetson University and will include officials from the Volusia County
government, NAACP, lenders and developers.
"The goal is for everyone to get together and realize how big of a
problem this is," Truhlar said. "Federal funding is not enough. We
need the congregations and the community to come together."
Truhlar said the group will present a number of possible solutions to solve
Central Florida's affordable-housing problem. But some officials who are
well-versed in the crisis are skeptical.
"Affordable housing has been an issue in our county for many years,"
said Edward Jasper, the county's community assistance director. "I've
participated in a lot of conference calls with people who have been in the
business across the country. I didn't hear any solutions countrywide. So if
they have solutions, I'm more than open to hear them."
Volusia County has an income-based down-payment assistance program for
first-time homebuyers.
But it hasn't eased the county's growing needs at a time when "housing
has skyrocketed and the income has not gone up along with it," Jasper
said.
More than 800 people have been displaced by the storm, according to estimates
by Jim Ryan, director of Volusia's emergency management services.
Some of them are still living in houses that were deemed destroyed, so it's
difficult to get a better idea of how many people have been permanently
displaced.
Many victims, such as Richard Thigpin, have had to make do on their own,
hoping that the Federal Emergency Management Agency would help them get back
on their feet.
They were wrong.
Thigpin moved his family into his brother's home after Friday's tornado
destroyed his two-bedroom apartment on Hontoon Island west of DeLand.
He was hoping to get a house with FEMA help, but the agency only offered him
$730 in federal aid. Thigpin said that wouldn't even pay one month's rent
because he can't find anything for less than $1,000 per month.
"I'm not on welfare," said Thigpin, who builds floors for a living
and is working despite a storm-related leg injury. "I'm trying to work my
way up, but they're [FEMA officials] just pulling me back down."
On a recent hunt, Thigpin managed to find an apartment complex with a vacancy
-- a rare find in Volusia County these days.
It would cost him $1,000 to move in and another $1,000 every month to live
there, Thigpin said.
"I don't understand how anybody can afford that," said Thigpin, who
paid $650 for his Hontoon Island apartment. "If the rest of the people
are getting what I'm getting [from FEMA], nobody's gonna find nothing."
So far, 1,200 applicants have filed for FEMA's help in Central Florida, almost
half of them from Volusia County, said FEMA spokesman Donald Daniel. It has
approved $1.4 million for individual households and dispersed $270,734 so far,
he said.
Bruno said he hopes to work with federal and state officials to find possible
solutions.
"I'm going to ask for any assistance that I can get from FEMA,"
Bruno said. "We've got to have opportunities for people. We don't want
our teachers and our firefighters living in other communities."
Tanya Caldwell can be reached at tcaldwell@orlandosentinel.com or
386-851-7910.
Meeting set to discuss progress on S.R. 17
By SHELLY GODEFRIN
News Chief staff
LAKE WALES - Progress on the Scenic Highway corridor is the focus of a
meeting for landowners.
The Concerned Property Owners of Polk County supporters will participate
in a meeting at 3 p.m. Monday at the Florida Natural Grove House/Visitor's
Center to discuss progress on Scenic Highway (State Road 17).
The meeting will bring everyone up to speed on the progress during the
past year, including the design criteria of the Scenic Highway corridor.
The property owners group was created out of a need to address new land
regulations when the road was named a scenic highway, a decision that left
some landowners unhappy.
Heather Nedley, Polk County Farm Bureau executive director, said the
meeting is designed to allow landowners to bring up any issues they may have
in regard to their land on Scenic Highway.
Scenic Highway, a 38 mile stretch of road between Frostproof and Haines
City, takes drivers through the rolling hills part of peninsular Florida and
is used as an alternate route for U.S. Highway 27.
During the past couple of years, proposals were brought to the table that
didn't completely fix the problems landowners were facing. Nedley said they
have a great proposal on the table now and the meeting will be a time for
landowners to go over the proposal and give their input.
"We're hoping for landowners to look at the draft and understand how
they'll be effected," said Nedley.
Contributing landowners are encouraged to attend, provide input and ask
questions.
michelle.godefrin@newschief.com
Residents protest Salvation Army plan
DAVID DeCAMP
Published February 8, 2007
WESLEY CHAPEL - It was bad enough when the car dealerships started going up
nearby, spoiling the vista from valuable new homes.
But now - gasp - it's the Salvation Army hitting central Pasco County.
The charity wants to build a 23,300-square-foot store to resell donated
goods. The store would be on 3 acres on State Road 54 west of Interstate 75.
It also would be across the road from the entrance to Lexington Oaks, a golf
course and housing development where homes sell from $200,000 to $500,000. And
where a big mall is in the works.
The thought of what a Salvation Army store might bring has triggered ill
will usually reserved for big-box retailers and adult video shops. The stack
of e-mail from mostly Lexington Oaks residents is at 60 complaints and growing
the past week.
They worry about the clientele, increased crime and lower property values.
They fret the Salvation Army will addle their community with big delivery
trucks, and expose children to "drug addicted vagrants on their daily
jaunt to school," as resident David Di Marco wrote to County
Administrator John Gallagher.
They also want something that sells higher-end goods.
"We deal with the Dollar General a ways down the road, we do not need
this, and I don't want it," resident Carol Scarborough wrote.
"I want my family to live in our home and enjoy having guests over,
but I don't want to tell them to make a right or left at the Salvation
Army."
The Salvation Army has a different take. The charity calls the project a
"family store." Parking for 114 vehicles is planned, with a double
row of shrubs along the perimeter.
Salvation Army spokesman Chris Priest in Atlanta said it would be a
satellite office of a bigger Tampa store off Nebraska Avenue.
"It will be purely retail," Priest said, and rehabilitation for
substance abuse would be done elsewhere.
People treated for substance abuse would be eligible for jobs there, but
only after reaching a proper level of sobriety, Priest said.
But mostly, the complaints come back to upscale desires. Michael Bock, a
three-year resident of Lexington Oaks, wants higher-end businesses - and the
Salvation Army store built elsewhere.
"I think it's a good facility. I think it's a great idea," Bock
said. "But I look at what I see in Tampa ... and it's mounds of
crap."
Priest said he could not explain why the Salvation Army chose the high-end
location in Wesley Chapel for a store. They often are in areas with lower
income levels. Local Salvation Army officials did not return messages.
"I honestly don't know why they wanted to put a Salvation Army
there," said County Commissioner Pat Mulieri, whose district includes the
location.
The Salvation Army bought the property in February 2006 for $2.1-million.
The land is zoned to allow commercial uses. The proposed store's docks and
storage area allow for some distribution, which normally is an industrial use.
But Pasco zoning administrator Deborah Zampetti decided the project meets
code because most of the building will be for retailing.
"It's permissible," Zampetti wrote in a note Monday.
Still, the county's Development Review Committee must approve the plans for
the site at a meeting to review technical details Feb. 22.
Mulieri, recipient of many of the complaints, said she is urging people to
attend so the Salvation Army can hear what residents want. The charity
probably has the legal right to build there, but neighbors could influence the
design, she said.
Not that she prefers the Salvation Army, either.
"Yeah," Mulieri said, "I would like to see something more
upscale there."
David DeCamp can be reached at 727 869-6232 or ddecamp@sptimes.com
Panel OKs two Wal-Mart projects
Plan calls for 514,000 square feet
By Julian Pecquet
DEMOCRAT STAFF WRITER
Plans for two Wal-Marts - one at Fallschase, the other on North Monroe
Street - are moving forward after receiving approval from county staffers
Wednesday.
Leon County's Development Review Committee, a three-member panel,
unanimously approved both projects. One county staffer, however, criticized
the first phase of the Fallschase commercial plan, which calls for 514,000
square feet of commercial building space - including a Wal-Mart and a Costco -
at Buck Lake Road and Mahan Drive.
"Given the resources and the land available here, it's disappointing
to see basically the same type of big-box development that you see all over
the country," said Roxanne Manning, a city-county planner. "I think
there was an opportunity and there was certainly input by staff to try to do
something of a higher quality than this."
Rick Bateman, an attorney for Fallschase, said the developer would take
into consideration staff's recommendations when designing the stores that will
occupy the site.
"We are going to try to make them look nice," he said. "We
have architectural standards with our permit that we're going to live up
to."
The first phase of Fallschase's commercial development was approved in
October; on Wednesday, the developer sought approval for 119 more parking
spaces than earlier approved, which brings the total number of parking spaces
to 2,472. The developer also asked for a reduction in the size of commercial
building square footage, from 522,520 square feet to 514,000. Wednesday's
approval means the developer can move forward with construction.
The Wal-Mart Supercenter on North Monroe, however, now goes to the
Tallahassee-Leon County Planning Commission, which will issue its own
recommendation to the County Commission. The County Commission has final
approval. The store, which would be built on the site of a former Sam's Club,
drew protest from some residents at the meeting.
"The real issue for us is that ... traffic is so bad on that part of
(U.S. Highway) 27 anyway, and this is only going to make it worse,"
Sharon Collins said.
The committee was also supposed to hear plans for 247 residential units at
Fallschase, but that was delayed until March 7
Suwannee Landing construction to
start soon
By Robert Bridges, Democrat Reporter
Suwannee Landing, an upscale airpark west of Live Oak, is set to
begin construction on phase one of the development.
A model home, which will become the sales office when completed, is to be
built in Armstrong Estates, as phase one is now designated. The current sales
office is located at 232 Court St. in Live Oak. The office was relocated after
the development site was replatted and the entrance road moved.
Bulldozers and other heavy equipment are already onsite installing culverts
and working on the entrance road. A turn lane from CR 136 West is to be
installed.
Also to come is a gatehouse, for possible use by a security guard, as well as
a secure school bus stop.
“It’ll be a great community,” said Barb Mellinger, one of the
developers. “The amenities are especially nice.”
She said Suwannee Landing will have an exercise facility, swimming pool and
community room, as well as nature trails.
The 270-acre development borders the Suwannee County Airport on the south. Of
the 250-plus homes to be built, at least 114 of them will have hangars for
owners’ planes, which they can taxi onto the airport runway.
The project will be restricted to residential use and will contain covenants
limiting noise, John Scott of TSS told the Democrat recently.
The Suwannee River Water Management District recently gave its blessing to the
project. Suwannee Landing is designed so that storm water runoff will be
contained on the property.
Robert Bridges can be reached by calling 386-362-1734 ext. 134 or by e-mail at
robert.bridges@gaflnews.com
Cities unite to obtain
underground utilities
BY R. NORMAN MOODY
FLORIDA TODAY
When Hurricane Frances knocked out power to 254,000 Florida Power &
Light customers in Brevard County in 2004, Cocoa Beach's Bob Stickland was
among those who fired up an emergency generator.
In another beachside community, Satellite Beach, Kitty and Bud Wade's
generator remained silent in the days after the storm because they never lost
power. Thanks to underground utilities in their neighborhood, storms have come
and gone, but power has remained on throughout.
Even with vastly different experiences, the Wades and Stickland support
moving power lines underground, although they wonder how the expensive process
-- conversion costs anywhere from $500,000 to $4 million per mile -- would be
paid for.
As hurricane-wary communities work to be better prepared for major storms,
including burying the maze of cables now overhead, cities across the state are
grappling with the same issue: how to best pay for the massive conversion from
overhead power lines to underground. Consumers and the utilities have starkly
different ideas.
"FPL is not going to come up with enough money," Stickland said.
"It's a tremendous amount of expense."
Cocoa Beach, Satellite Beach, Melbourne, Cocoa and Rockledge are among an
association of cities moving forward with efforts to get power lines
relocated. The Cocoa Beach City Commission recently approved a resolution
urging the Florida Public Service Commission to encourage underground
utilities.
"We started that because we realized that we're going to have to get
involved with the (Public Service Commission) and we thought there would be
strength in numbers," said Tom Bradford, deputy manager for the town of
Palm Beach, which spearheaded a move to unite cities on the issue. The group
has about 50 participating communities that have formed the Municipal
Underground Utilities Consortium and pooled about $120,000 to fund a study and
for legal representation to lobby FPL and the PSC.
The PSC will look at the companies' and communities' proposals for sharing
the costs of getting utilities underground.
"As part of our duty to consumers, we need to ask more
questions," commission spokesman Anthony DeLuise said. "Are they
going to cover that or are they going to pass it on to consumers? Where are
they coming up with that figure?"
DeLuise said communities across the state are interested in burying power
lines, an issue that also is a priority for the commission.
Under new rules to make its line more resistant to storm damage, FPL is
offering to pay for 25 percent of the conversion cost, but cities want more.
"We're bringing in all the other factors," said Ken Killgore,
Cocoa Beach finance director. "The study says the we should get about 51
percent."
The consortium's study has analyzed whether Florida power companies would
save because of less frequent repairs and less damage from storms, and it
looked at the financial impact of fewer outages. Underground lines eliminate
the need to trim trees around overhead power lines, and reduce the need for
extensive restoration work after a major storm. From a liability and safety
standpoint, they also eliminate vehicle crashes into power poles.
FPL officials said they support underground wiring. Spokesman Jim Davidson
said the company has 37 percent of its lines already underground, compared to
20 percent for other companies.
FPL serves about 4.4 million customers in 35 counties in the state.
"We're looking to them (PSC) for guidance," Davidson said.
"They are the regulatory body."
Brevard and other counties already require power lines, excluding main
feeder lines, to go underground in new developments. Developers say they like
the aesthetics, but also the other benefits. There are pockets of
neighborhoods in Satellite Beach, Cocoa Beach and other communities in Brevard
County that have underground electric, cable television and telephone wiring.
"This year is important for us," said Laura Canady, acting
Community Development director for Satellite Beach. "We need to know how
this is all going to work out."
About two years ago, Satellite Beach started talking about underground
power lines, especially along State Road A1A.
"This is our year to develop our technical expertise and continue to
pursue regulatory and financial options," Canady said.
Proponents of burying cables know cost is an obstacle for many communities.
"It just seems to me that in time the cities are going to do it,"
Satellite Beach resident Kitty Wade said. "It think its going to happen
all along the coast."
Wade believes power companies, the cities and the state should share in the
cost to convert.
Contact Moody at 242-3651 or nmoody@floridatoday.com
Local farmer gains national recognition
By DEBORAH BUCKHALTER
Jackson County Floridan
Thursday, February 8, 2007
A Jackson County farmer who earned local awards for his crop production last
year has gained national recognition as well.
Larry Ford was the 2006 Peanut Farmer and High Corn Yield Producer of the
Year for Jackson County. He also won first place in the "irrigated
division" of the 2006 National Corn Growers Association's corn yield
contest in Florida.
His fields yielded a fraction over 236 bushels per acre.
According to a press release from the company that produces the seed Ford
used, he planted Pioneer-brand hybrid 31D58's on March 7 of last year. He
planted them into 36-inch rows at a rate of 29,900 seeds per acre.
He applied 295 pounds of nitrogen, 85 pounds of phosphorus and 250 pounds
of potash per acre to encourage fertility.
Ford planted about 150 acres, harvesting in early August.
In November, when he was interviewed about his local awards, Ford said he
is a third-generation farmer and started his own operation in 1970. He added
several hundred acres to the original family farm and has about 3,000 acres
now.
Ford also plants cotton, raises cattle and has timberlands on the
Greenwood-area property.
Experts' Vs. Public Interest
By Tom Palmer
tom.palmer@theledger.com
Over the past two weeks, planners have been trying to get the public to
tell them how to shape Polk County's future growth.
However, most of the nearly 200 residents who attended these meetings had a
hard time getting past their current discontent with how the system is set up
that makes their lives increasingly miserable.
Nevertheless, the process to remake Polk's growth will proceed because the law
requires it.
The public will get more input in October, but the question that bothers some
of Polk's growth critics is how the public interest will fare when the
critical stage of the revision occurs. I'm talking about the actual rewriting
of the growth plan.
In December, County Commissioner Jack Myers announced he wanted to form a
"technical committee" to suggest changes in the growth plan.
The Polk County Builders Association, the official lobbying arm of the local
development community, announced their support of such a committee - they were
even lining up people to serve on it - about a month before Myers, a PCBA
ally, broached the idea.
Some members of the public have raised questions about the idea. So have a
couple of Myers' colleagues, which has put things on hold.
The proposal will come back during the commissioners' annual retreat in early
April.
There are two issues involved with the formation of this committee: expertise
and accountability.
Advocates of the committee's formation have one main argument: Trust us, we're
experts.
Who is better suited to provide input on rewriting Polk's development
regulations, their argument goes, than the people who deal with it daily and
who have the professional experience to understand these complex issues?
I guess that depends on what you want to accomplish.
If you want to figure out the easiest way to get permits with the least amount
of paperwork, the laxest government oversight and the lowest fees, Team PCBA
wins hands down.
However, if your goal is to preserve green spaces, to control urban sprawl and
to make sure road improvements, new parks and schools follow more closely
behind the flood of new building permits than they do now, perhaps another
approach may work better.
I was curious whether anyone in the area used the kind of technical committee
Polk County is considering, so I called around to other planning departments.
The answer everywhere was the same: the local planning staff is in charge of
proposing changes in development regulations.
This proposal, like a similar committee that preceded it, appears to be a
unique creature of Polk County politics.
The previous committee, known informally as the "Glitch Committee"
was appointed at PCBA's behest in 2000 when the ink was barely dry on the
county's new development regulations.
That committee's job was to fine-tune the regulations, looking for
inconsistencies and errors.
To me, one of the amazing aspects of that decision was that county
commissioners so readily agreed the document they had just approved was
imperfect even though they took far longer than any other Florida county to
come up with a set of regulations in the first place
State law requires local officials to rewrite their development regulations
within a year after they complete their growth plans.
Polk County submitted its growth plan in 1991, but instead of having an
approved set of development regulations the following year, the process
dragged on for nine more years.
And even after nine years of managing to aid and abet the delay in complying
with state law, the development community still wanted to delay the
implementation date and they wanted the committee to fiddle with the
regulations some more.
When commissioners appointed the first developer committee in 2000, the
aforementioned Glitch Committee, public reaction was resignation or
indifference rather than outrage.
One reason may have been that the earlier committee was supposed to have been
an ad hoc committee that would be in existence for only a few months and was
to disband before the new regulations took effect later that year. The
committee, of course, didn't disband, remaining active for years afterward,
continuing to influence growth regulations.
The other reason for lack of criticism at the time is that the public outrage
over the seemingly lopsided way development regulations are written and the
PCBA's perpetual iron grip on the process had not reached the level that it
has today.
Back to the committee, which some people are calling Son of Glitch.
There's no question that PCBA or anyone else is free to lobby the County
Commission in their logical self-interest.
And because they are professionals, their opinions may carry some weight on
technical issues.
But the question is not whether they're technically competent or whether they
have a right to participate in the discussion.
Instead, the question is whether they should be allowed once again to become
the gatekeepers through which any change in the county's growth plan must pass
before it comes up for consideration.
The draft resolution setting up the committee appeared to put the panel on a
par with the Planning Commission and may even allow the proposed committee to
bypass the Planning Commission.
County commissioners have argued they're the final arbiters of what will or
will not be in the growth plan or the development regulations.
However, they can't vote on something they never see.
There's also evidence that even when a proposal does come before them and they
do vote, the votes are perfunctory; there's very little debate.
That's how dry retention ponds came to be considered the functional equivalent
of playgrounds in new subdivisions and that's how a lot of sneaky little
provisions ended up in the development code.
It's clear from the meetings during the past two weeks that the public wants
something better.
Tom Palmer can be reached at tom.palmer@theledger.com
or 863-802-7535.
Doubling homestead exemption
sounds good but bad idea, officials say
By Christa Desrets
Herald Writer
HIGH SPRINGS – Although saving extra money on property
taxes sounds like a great idea to most residents, a proposed law that would do
just that could be detrimental to small, local governments, High Springs
commissioners said.
One property tax reform that newly elected Governor Charlie Crist has said he
supports is doubling the amount of money that homeowners are exempt from
paying on their property taxes.
The current Homestead Exemption Act allows homeowners to not pay taxes on
$25,000 of their home’s net worth. Doubling that amount would mean residents
would not pay taxes on $50,000 of their home’s value.
And while that idea may seem like it would save homeowners plenty of money,
High Springs officials said, the city would suffer as a result.
The amount of property tax income that the city would lose as a result would
be about $400,000, according to City Manager Jim Drumm.
To make up for such a drastic cut in the city’s budget, he
said, officials would have to consider either raising the percentage that the
city charges for property taxes or cutting the services that the city
provides.
Commissioner Kirk Eppenstein said in such a case, the city would have to
consider providing little more than the emergency services of police and
firefighters.
But instead of getting to that point, commissioners said, they should be
proactive with the situation and let lawmakers know that the proposed change
to the Homestead Act would adversely affect small-town governments.
House Representative Debbie Boyd, who sits on a working group for property
taxes, said that she wanted to hear the concerned voices of commissioners in
her district.
“I understand that if you increase that exemption, it could be very, very
detrimental to our small towns and counties,” she said. “If High Springs
and the cities and counties in my district feel that this extra $25,000 would
be detrimental to their budget – I think it's good that they have that voice
and to put it in writing.”
Before enacting such a law, Commissioner Larry Travis said,
the state should look at other ways to enforce the act, such as only adding
the exemption to homes that are appraised at a set value.
Commissioner Jim Gabriel also said that the issue still needs much discussion
before state officials should make any decisions.
“I just hope we impress upon our leaders to look at the situation and be
strong about it,” he said.
Although rallying against such a cause may seem cruel to some who think they
would benefit from such an exemption, Eppenstein added, residents should
realize that costs of services are always increasing.
“We’re not trying to be heartless and say that people should be taxed out
of their homes,” he said.
Commissioners also discussed the idea of adding impact fees – or fees to
offset the costs for services – to new homes.
The city should study the option of impact fees, Drumm said, because
commissioners always say they wish there were more impact fees in place when
they have to decide whether to approve a new development.
Although water and sewage impact fees have already been passed, he said, there
are none for parks, recreation, roads, police, rescue or fire services.
“Someone has to pay for the impact of the addition of that house,”
Eppenstein said.
Real estate agency's abrupt closure stuns agents
Re/Max Advantage Realty gave no notice it would shut down Tuesday, its
agents say.
JODIE TILLMAN
Published February 7, 2007
PORT RICHEY - Re/Max Advantage Realty, once a dominant real estate agency
in Pasco County, abruptly shut down Tuesday.
Nearly 25 affected agents did not learn of the decision until Tuesday
morning. At least some of them were notified by e-mail from a representative
of company owner Donald J. Hachenberger.
The e-mail said agents needed to collect their personal belongings Tuesday
afternoon. There was no explanation for the office's closing.
"It wasn't done right," said Bill Baptista, who was standing
outside the office Tuesday with a handful of other displaced agents.
Rick Miller, who said he represented the owner, would only say Tuesday that
the closing "was just a business decision." He declined to
elaborate.
The well-documented slowdown in the real estate market could be partly -
though not wholly - to blame for the closing, said agents and outside
observers.
Carol Austin, the executive director of the Greater Tampa Association of
Realtors, said she was surprised to hear the news. In spite of all the
hand-wringing over the market, she said, "We've not seen any major
companies closing."
In its heyday, Re/Max Advantage Realty, in the U.S. 19 strip with
Carrabba's Italian Grill, had more than 60 agents working the area.
"When they first started in this market, they were the cat's
meow," recalled Robert Memoli, a past president of the West Pasco Board
of Realtors.
The company was once owned by prominent commercial real estate agent Mark
Swartsel, who sold it but stayed on as an agent.
Re/Max later lost key agents who started their own firms and also began
facing more competition, Memoli said.
Broker Barry Grover, who is one of the Re/Max contractors now looking for a
new firm, said the real estate boom brought in inexperienced agents.
When the market was hot, they did well. But as the market has slowed, he
said, some had problems paying their company fees, which can run about $1,500
a month.
Now that the office has closed, the agents must find work with new firms.
They said Tuesday that they expect to continue working with their current
roster of clients. Some will transfer the clients to Re/Max New Dimensions in
Trinity, which has different owners.
The agents cannot take on additional clients until they link their licenses
with new companies.
Grover, who was just announced as one of Re/Max Advantage's top listing
agents, producers and selling agents for 2006, said clients shouldn't expect
any big changes. What disappoints him, he said, is the handling of the
closure.
"It's not dignified," Grover said. "It's not right."
Other than the sight of people hauling files to their cars, the office had
no other indication it was closing Monday except for a sign on the door saying
the office "is temporarily closed for repairs." Asked about the
sign, Miller said it had been hung on Friday when some work was being done.
Grover and Baptista, however, laughed at that explanation. They said they
never saw the sign until they showed up Tuesday to clean out their desks.
Times staff writer James Thorner contributed to this report. Jodie Tillman
can be reached at 727 869-6247 or jtillman@sptimes.com
Condo Buyers Hit Hard Times
By SHANNON BEHNKEN The Tampa Tribune
Published: Feb 7, 2007
TAMPA - With a premier address and waterfront views, ParkCrest Harbour Island
was irresistible to many investors, who repeatedly bought and sold units since
it opened two years ago. Now, dozens of owners want out, and there are signs
some can't pay their bills.
Sixteen of the 336 units are in some stage of foreclosure, and 67 of the
condos are for sale, according to public documents and a database used by real
estate agents. An additional 41 units are listed in the database as leased or
for rent.
"This is excellent anecdotal evidence of what's happening in the Florida
housing boom and the bust we're now in," said Jack McCabe, a real estate
consultant in Deerfield Beach.
The foreclosures are precursors of what's to come, he said.
Over the past couple of years, developers have built dozens of condos in the
Sunshine State's downtowns, and McCabe estimates that 70 percent to 80 percent
of the sales were made to speculators. Many of those buyers planned to flip
their units for a profit but now can't sell them and are running out of money to
make monthly mortgage payments.
Dozens of residential condominium projects have been proposed for downtown
Tampa, but just two with heights of nine stories or more have been completed.
The other project is Parkside of One Bayshore, at Platt Street and Bayshore
Boulevard. It also had a lot of investor activity, but has had only one
foreclosure.
As the real estate market slowed, some developers dropped their plans, but
others are moving forward. Eight condo towers are expected to open downtown this
year.
'Investors Are Overextended'
Of the 16 foreclosures in ParkCrest, five are a result of owners not paying
condo association fees. The rest are being foreclosed on by the financial
institutions holding the mortgages.
None of the owners in foreclosure could be reached for comment. It is not
clear how many of them are investors, but three own two units each.
"I tend to think the overall trouble in the condo market is because
investors are overextended," said Jim Pyburn, president of the ParkCrest
Harbour Island Condo Association. "I'm optimistic that this will get
better, but that doesn't help the people who are in dire straits trying to sell
their units."
Pyburn said other condo owners are on the verge of foreclosure for not paying
monthly fees. The fees vary depending on unit size, but a 1,300-square-foot
condo runs $573 a month in maintenance fees, he said.
ParkCrest Harbour Island, along the Garrison Channel in downtown, opened in
March 2005. The building was originally planned as an apartment complex, but the
developer, Tampa-based CKT Development Co., decided during construction in 2004
to convert the project into condominiums. Within six weeks, the building was
nearly sold out, the company said at the time.
Investors have converged on the building since the beginning. There are 397
total sales in the building listed in the Multiple Listing Service, the database
used by real estate agents. Some of the units have sold multiple times.
Developers typically sell units themselves and don't use the listing service,
so many of the sales listed in the database are resales, said Emmy Purcell
Reynolds, vice president of Tampa real estate company Henry Purcell Inc.
Reynolds said she has taken clients to see units in ParkCrest three times and
isn't surprised by the amount of foreclosures.
"The apartment-condo idea may have been good in its infancy, but
developers oversaturated the market," Reynolds said. "The units
themselves [in ParkCrest] don't feel like condos; they feel like
apartments."
Of the 67 units on the market, 15 have been for sale less than a month; 10
have been on the market for more than 200 days and two have been waiting for a
buyer for more than a year, according to listing data.
Forty-three units have sold through the listing service since this time last
year. Sellers who didn't use a real estate agent aren't included there. In July
2005, the Tribune reported 66 units were for sale.
There are so many units on the market that the ParkCrest condo association
has decided not to allow lockboxes to hang on the doors. Instead, the lockboxes,
used by agents to gain access to units, go in a cabinet.
"If you walked in a building as a buyer and saw 67 lockboxes, you might
be a little intimidated," Pyburn said.
Association Foreclosures Rise
Michael Brudny, a lawyer with Brudny & Rabin in Oldsmar, is representing
the condo association at ParkCrest. Brudny said the firm represents 400 condo
associations in the Tampa Bay area and that foreclosures on behalf of
associations are on the rise.
"It's the only remedy associations have when people don't pay,"
Brudny said, noting that some condo owners face losing their property over as
little as $2,000 in assessment fees.
For some condo investors, the foreclosure process is a way to buy time to
come up with the money, he said.
"Sometimes investors get in a cash crunch &hellip" Brudny said.
"At the last minute, they pay to avoid the foreclosure."
But if they can't, others are watching and waiting to buy units at a
discount.
McCabe, the real estate consultant, said he is advising these investors to
wait for better deals. "In my opinion, it's still a little early. After the
current snowbird season is over, I think we'll see lenders take back properties
from developers and foreclosures will go up dramatically."
Reporter Shannon Behnken can be reached at (813) 259-7804.
Report card gives oceans of trouble
An assessment of U.S. oceans policy shows a dangerous lack of
funding and leadership.
LARA V. HENRY AND KRISTAN UHLENBROCK special to the Times
Published February 7, 2007
You wouldn't allow a C-minus medical student to perform surgery on you,
or entrust your taxes to an accountant who averaged a C-minus in math. But
the government, to whom we have entrusted the protection of our natural
resources, is putting in only a C-minus effort toward managing our oceans.
Every day we use goods and medicines, breathe air, drink water or deal
with weather that in some way relates to the ocean. Yet the health of
ocean and coastal ecosystems is declining because the government's
approach is ineffective.
The nonpartisan Joint Ocean Commission Initiative has just released its
2006 U.S. Ocean Policy Report Card on the government's performance in
ocean affairs. This year's grades are troubling.
Fisheries management reform: B-plus (previously a C-plus).
A major accomplishment was reauthorization of the Magnuson-Stevens Act,
a bipartisan bill increasing effective management of U.S. fisheries. The
bill includes stronger language on illegal, unregulated and unreported
fishing in international waters.
Recreational fishing in Florida generates an estimated $8.3-billion in
economic impact, while commercial fishing yields $1.1-billion. Such
numbers call for better enforcement of fisheries stock and management.
International leadership: D-minus (up from last year's F).
The oceans are an international resource, yet our senators have not yet
ratified the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea. Ratifying this treaty
would let us sit at the table with countries negotiating to extend their
Exclusive Economic Zones beyond the 200 nautical miles we each now claim.
National ocean governance reform: C-minus (up from last year's D-plus).
Tampa Bay is unique in that local businesses generously support public
education in ocean sciences. Here, USF marine science graduate students
learn scientific diving techniques.
With a stroke of the pen, the president created the Northwestern
Hawaiian Islands Marine National Monument, which includes nearly 140,000
square miles of ocean territory. However, little has been done to change
an inefficient system, and there is still a need for a multi-issue,
interagency mechanism to guide, oversee and coordinate all aspects of
coastal and ocean science and policy.
Regional and state ocean governance reform: A-minus (raised from a
B-minus).
Several states have implemented conservation measures. But there can
still be better communication between state and regional groups under a
national framework, coordinated with the federal government.
Research, science and education: D-plus (from a D).
We invested in science and technology several decades ago, leading us
to where we are today. Now, instead of finding ways to keep our edge, we
have cut funding for science education and research. Science education is
failing at all grade levels. Only about 30 percent of adults understand
basic environmental concepts, and even fewer are familiar with more
complicated issues such as ecosystem decline or watershed degradation.
Everyone seems to have formed an opinion on global warming, yet most
people know little about this problem. Understanding nature is necessary
for better management of ocean resources. We need to train future
generations of scientists and engineers, and continue investing in
research.
New funding for ocean policy and programs: F.
The oceans play an essential role in daily life. Our waters support
more than 2-million jobs and generate about $117-billion in revenue every
year. Some 80 percent of Floridians live or work in coastal counties, and
more than 1,000 people move to Florida every day. Yet our federal
investment in ocean research is now a mere 3.5 percent of the total
federal research budget, compared to the 7 percent we used to invest 25
years ago.
The U.S. Commission on Ocean Policy recommended that Congress establish
an ocean trust fund of royalties and fees collected for private use of
marine resources that belong to all of us. This would be reinvested in
research, education and management.
Lack of money shows lack of commitment. Lack of action shows lack of
leadership. If our priorities don't change, we'll end up lacking healthy
coasts. This new Congress has a responsibility to take actions recommended
by the President's Ocean Commission in 2004.
Ultimately, each of us has to become involved and press our elected
leaders to have effective environmental and ocean policies. Ask your
elected officials what they are doing to keep your resources.
Although, our ocean policy grades have slightly improved this year, we
are still on academic probation. If your child brought home a similar
report card, would you put it on the refrigerator?
Lara V. Henry and Kristan Uhlenbrock are students in Frank Muller-Karger's
Ocean Policy Class, College of Marine Science, USF. Students Patrick
Casey, Christine Cass, Marianne Dietz, Erica Hudson, Kelly Kowal and
Suzanne Stickley contributed to this article. They have set up an online
public forum at: http://www.marine.usf.edu/oceanforum/forum/
Cemex now in permit trouble
By Terry Witt
The company operating a coastal limestone mine near Inglis is being
cited for three violations of its 2005 environmental resource permit, a
state agency official said Tuesday.
Howard Hayes, program administrator for the Bureau of Mine Reclamation
in the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, said Cemex was
“very late” filing its 2005 annual report and missed five quarters of
testing for salt levels in the 200-acre manmade lake created by the mining
operation.
Cemex also failed to build a required stormwater containment system by
the date designated in the company’s environmental resource permit,
Hayes said.
Susana Duarte, spokeswoman for Cemex, said the company has corrected
the permit violations, although she acknowledged the salinity testing was
spotty and the results were submitted late. However, she said the company
is now complying with testing requirements and has built a stormwater
containment structure.
“We are taking extraordinary measures to make sure it never happens
again,” she said of the testing violations.
DEP’s draft consent order listing the three violations must be
reviewed by agency attorneys before it is sent to Cemex for comment. Hayes
said it is too early to discuss potential penalties.
DEP considers salinity testing important because of the potential for
saltwater intrusion in a coastal area, according to Hayes. However, he
said the one testing report submitted by Cemex in November of 2006 showed
low levels of salt content at the bottom of the lake, where concentrations
should be highest.
Chloride is an indicator of salt content in water. The chloride level
at the bottom of the 70-feet deep lake was 202 milligrams per liter, Hayes
said. Drinking water can have up to 250 milligrams of chloride per liter.
He said the salt content in the mid to upper levels of the lake was even
lower.
However, Hayes said DEP was not given test results for 15 months, which
means the agency was unable to monitor chloride content in the lake from
one year to the next. DEP scientists want to monitor whether salt content
in the lake is rising or falling over time.
Cemex and Dixie Hollins, from who it leases the property, have applied
for a modified permit that would allow the mining operations to expand
into two other areas on both sides of the northernmost part of the lake.
But Hayes said Cemex has not provided enough information to properly
evaluate the permit request.
“They did not provide the information, so that makes it difficult for
us to approach the application for an expansion of the mine,” Hayes
said.
DEP issues environmental resource permits to evaluate wetland impacts
and control stormwater discharges into surface waters. The limestone mine
actually operates in the Floridan Aquifer. The rock is blasted at the edge
of the lake and crushed into small stones of different sizes.
Hayes said it is legal to drill holes in the aquifer, a limestone
formation that provides Florida with much of its drinking water, but the
mines cannot cause saltwater intrusion. However, he said it’s difficult
to determine whether a mine on its own caused saltwater intrusion.
He said wells or groups of wells that withdraw large amounts of water
can influence whether saltwater migrates farther inland. Drought
conditions can cause saltwater intrusion, and the rising and falling of
the tide can influence saltwater levels.
“The hard part is teasing out saltwater intrusion; if it’s been
caused by mining or other things,” he said
Experts urge green living
By NATHAN CRABBE
Sun staff writer
Stop driving everywhere, and ride a bike instead.
Turn down the thermostat. Replace light bulbs and appliances with
energy-saving models.
Local experts say last week's report on global warming should be taken as a
call for these kind of actions. Rather than get depressed by the report's
dire forecasts, they say people should get motivated to do something about
them.
"People a lot of times don't think they can make a difference,"
said Chris Bird, director of the Alachua County Environmental Protection
Department.
"But if you do the math, what every individual does really adds
up."
The International Panel on Climate Change report issued Friday says global
warming is "very likely" caused by humans. Power plants, factories
and automobiles are releasing carbon dioxide and other gases that cause this
greenhouse effect, according to the report.
The report represents a broad consensus of scientists and should not be
taken lightly, said Stephen Mulkey, an associate professor of botany at the
University of Florida.
While he said the report's findings are sobering, the situation isn't
hopeless.
The worst-case predictions of sea-level rise and extreme weather can still
be avoided, he said. "We can still do something about it," he
said.
If that's not motivation enough, local residents have financial perks to
reduce their energy use and consequently their contribution to global
warming.
This year, Gainesville Regional Utilities has more than quadrupled spending
on programs offering rebates for conservation measures.
"It gives them a little bit of incentive to go that extra mile,"
said Bill Shepherd, GRU's interim energy and business services manager.
The Gainesville City Commission launched the conservation push last year,
while deciding against building a traditional coal-fired power plant. The
commission in the coming months will consider a range of alternatives.
Local conservation advocates are pushing for an option producing the least
amount of greenhouse gas emissions. The city also needs to have the
political will to promote energy-efficient building methods, said Ken
Fonorow, a local building-science consultant. "The lack of leadership
is a big part of the problem," he said.
Fonorow said homes waste energy in many ways that can be addressed
immediately. He recommends sealing duct work, replacing incandescent bulbs
with compact fluorescent bulbs and switching old refrigerators to
energy-saving models.
"You don't have to wait for anything," he said.
On a larger scale, the University of Florida has signed a commitment to
reducing its greenhouse gas emissions. The first step is cataloguing
greenhouse gas emissions caused by its operations and employees, said Mark
van Soestbergen of the Gainesville-based International Carbon Bank and
Exchange.
The carbon bank is starting the effort by identifying every
university-caused emission from power use on campus to flights taken by
university employees. Van Soestbergen said the work includes a GRU database
that may eventually be available to the public, allowing any resident to
determine their individual contribution to emissions.
"We hope by making these tools available, people would care and it
would mean something to them," he said.
The city of Gainesville and Alachua County have also signed commitments
pledging a reduction of greenhouse gases. The county was a leader in its
purchase of hybrid vehicles and now is looking to expand such efforts, said
Bird of the Environmental Protection Department.
On a state level, the Legislature has created the Century Commission for a
Sustainable Florida. The group recommends state policies to encourage the
best use of land, water and energy.
UF's Mulkey serves as science adviser to the group. He's also working on a
contract for Environmental Defense to gauge the potential for forestry and
other activities in Florida to capture carbon.
The political will of elected leaders will determine what action will come
from these efforts, he said. But he said the climate-change panel's experts
should be taken seriously as the state decides how to address global
warming.
"If we ignore them, we do so at our own peril," he said.
The International Panel on Climate Change report issued Friday says global
warming is "very likely" caused by humans. The report predicts an
increase in temperatures, sea level and hurricane intensity that could
affect Florida in the following ways:Warmer weather:The report
predicts a temperature increase between 2.5 to 11.5 degrees by 2100. The
heat would increase the need for irrigation of crops, taxing water supplies.
Human health could be affected by an increased frequency and intensity of
heat waves, increased air pollution and a wider occurrence of infectious
diseases and disease carriers.
Shrinking coastlines:The report predicts a sea level rise up to 23
inches by 2100, which could be boosted even more by ice melting from
Greenland and Antarctica. Rising sea levels could erode, flood or inundate
coastal lands. Saltwater intrusion could compromise coastal freshwater
supplies that many people depend on, at the same time jeopardizing the
health of wetlands and organisms they support.
Stronger hurricanes:The report found an increase in hurricane
strength since 1970 is "more likely than not" the result of
man-made global warming. Surface water temperature feeds the stretch of
hurricanes, so a jump in water temperatures would cause storms to be more
intense. Florida and other coastal states could see more storms like
Hurricane Katrina, destroying property and lives.
Source: International Panel on Climate Change, U.S. Global Change
Research Program
Nathan
Crabbe can be reached at 338-3176 or crabben@gvillesun.com
Loss of cranes a major blow to recovery efforts
St. Petersburg Times editorial
Published February 7, 2007
Compared to the devastating losses of life, property and peace of mind
suffered by our neighbors to the north and east, the deaths of 17 whooping
cranes in the Chassahowitzka National Wildlife Refuge may seem
insignificant.
But the loss of these rare birds is a major setback to an innovative
program aimed at reviving a dying species. It also shows that nature's fury
spares nothing in its path.
The birds had arrived in January after making an amazing migration from
Wisconsin to Florida. Snowbirds who make similar trips by car know how
demanding a journey it can be; just imagine the determination and endurance
it takes for a gangly bird to flap its wings for 1,200 miles, all the while
following an ultralight aircraft piloted by a human in a bird costume.
But groups of these intrepid birds have been making this arduous trip for
six years as part of a recovery program led by a collection of wildlife
groups known as the Whooping Crane Eastern Partnership. Through efforts like
this, the world's largest bird, standing a majestic 5 feet tall, is being
saved from extinction.
But even these marvels of nature are no match for the ferocity of a
string of tornadoes.
As the elements of last week's storms gathered in the Gulf of Mexico
Thursday night, the winds howled and the waters rose. The birds, tucked away
in their pens in a remote location in the wildlife refuge that straddles the
line between Citrus and Hernando counties, were in the storms' path.
In past years, the pens had been open on top so the birds could come and
go. When storms brewed, the cranes could fly out and seek shelter. But this
time the pens were topped by nets to keep older whooping cranes that live in
a remote area of Hernando County from invading and possibly harming the
younger birds.
The netting, as well as the location in a watery site, were steps taken
to protect the cranes from predators. Ironically, they wound up contributing
to their demise.
As the wind-whipped storm surge rolled in, the water and mud inside the
pens rose, trapping the birds. The speed of the storm, plus the remote
location of the pens, prevented potential rescuers from getting to the
cranes. In the end, 17 of the cranes perished.
The lone survivor was a renegade crane that somehow managed to escape.
The same bird, No. 615, had caused fits for the humans during the migration
by being headstrong and flying away from the flock before rejoining its
buddies. Turns out, this independent streak may have saved its life.
The survival of this single whooping crane does little to ease the pain
of the scores of scientists and volunteers who have labored so hard over the
past 6 years to restore the numbers of these unique creatures.
But just as the people of Central Florida are slowly piecing their lives
back together, the story of No. 615 demonstrates that even in the face of
devastation and hopelessness, the indomitable spirit to survive carries on
in all species.
Group focuses attention on Ichetucknee
Springs
By TONY
BRITT tbritt@lakecityreporter.com
Tuesday, February 6, 2007 10:53 PM EST
The Ichetucknee Springs Basin Working Group has launched a
public information campaign where members will place awareness posters in
local businesses.
Jim Stevenson, Ichetucknee Springs Basin Working group coordinator and Loye
Barnard, the Save Our Suwannee Representative who is part of the Ichetucknee
Springs
Basin Working Group, are scheduled to circulate the awareness posters to local
business beginning today.
“Tomorrow (Wednesday) Jim Stevenson and I are going to try to put these
posters around
Lake City,” Barnard said.
She said Hunter Printing and its owner, Glenn Hunter, took the responsibility
of printing 100 of the basin posters because of their importance to Columbia
County.
“We've got to find the places where people are a captive audience and also
have curiosity about the DOT (Department Of Transportation) signs
defining the Ichetucknee Basin,” she said of pending poster locations.
The working group was formed in 1995 to protect the waters flowing to
Ichetucknee Springs. The Ichetucknee Springs Basin includes 38 percent of
Columbia County reaching north to Interstate-10. Rain falling on the
600-square-mile basin recharges the underground reservoir that supplies water
to Ichetucknee Springs. Rain seeps through the soil and enters the limestone
where it moves slowly toward the springs. Water is also transported in the
three creeks that cross the basin and enter sinks that are connected to caves.
Once the water reaches the caves it flows rapidly to the springs, sometimes at
the rate of three miles per day.
Barnard said the Ichetucknee Springs Basin Working Group wanted to circulate
the posters throughout the community so that local residents would understand
the importance of clean and quality water practices.
“Lake City's wastewater, septic tanks and fertilizer-charged stormwater is
showing up in the aquifer and ultimately in Ichetucknee Springs and our
drinking water,” she said. “The people in Columbia County are beginning to
realize that they are part of the problem with septic tanks, and now they can
be part of the solution.”
Keep Thirsty E-Grass Out Of Everglades
Tampa Tribune Editorial Published: Feb 7, 2007
An imported, fast-growing plant called giant reed is being touted as
an energy crop that Florida farmers could turn into ethanol.
The import from South Asia has been used as a landscape ornamental in
Florida for many years and has not been considered a threat to native
vegetation. But planting thousands of acres of the stuff would raise the
threat considerably.
The Florida Native Plant Society opposes agricultural use of the
bamboo-like plant, Arundo donax. The group's concerns are valid. The state
should proceed with great caution.
The reed spreads during floods when twigs as short as two inches are swept
downstream where they take root. One wayward sprig can spread to cover
hundreds of acres.
In California, giant reed has become a giant pest. A columnist writing in
the Santa Barbara Independent says it "can be seen choking out just about
every trickle of a stream around here." It grows 10 times faster than
native plants, robs wild animals and fish of habitat, soaks up water like a
sponge and causes erosion. The newspaper reports it "reproduces faster
than nymphomaniac rabbits on speed."
If large tracts are planted in the tall grass - sometimes called E-grass
when used as an energy crop - hurricane winds could sow clippings across the
state. Should the reed, which grows about 20 feet tall at a pace of up to two
inches a day, get into Lake Okeechobee or the Everglades, the cleanup costs
would be astronomical.
California has found it costs up to $17,000 an acre to get rid of it.
Ethanol for fuel is a good idea, but state officials should take a
conservative approach to potential runaway plants that might dry up streams
and soak taxpayers.
Goodness Snakes, Toughen Serpent Rules
Tampa Tribune Editorial Published: Feb 7, 2007
The Florida Fish & Wildlife Commission is poised to pass a new
rule banning people from keeping tigers and alligators in residential
neighborhoods, which is a good thing.
The commission should apply the same logic to venomous snakes.
The state began tightening its exotic pet restrictions after a series of
incidents involving pythons, anacondas and Nile monitor lizards that have been
dumped into the wild where they now thrive.
But more needs to be done.
Imagine learning that your next-door neighbor had 15 venomous snakes and
some crocodiles in his home. That's what happened to residents in a Town N'
Country mobile home park three years ago. They made the discovery after the
owner was nearly killed by an African black mamba. And they were shocked to
hear that keeping a poisonous snake in their neighborhood was perfectly legal.
Poisonous snakes have no business as pets and should be included in the
restrictions on exotic pets. Imagine firefighters answering an emergency call,
only to come face to face with a deadly viper.
At a minimum, the state should make it easy to find out who has permits for
these snakes. Hillsborough County keeps a database of dangerous dogs. The same
should hold for venomous snakes. The difference is that the state holds sole
regulatory power over snakes.
People are entitled to have dangerous hobbies, but the public deserves a
bigger buffer from dangerous playthings.
Tighten rules on wildlife
A TIMES EDITORIAL
Published February 7, 2007
Imagine hearing that your neighbor was bitten by a deadly black mamba
snake, one of 15 poisonous snakes kept at his house. It happened in a Tampa
mobile home community. Or consider children frolicking on the Starkey
Elementary School playground in Pinellas County, unaware that tigers and other
big cats pace in chain-link cages nearby. In both instances, the proximity of
dangerous animals to unsuspecting adults and children is perfectly legal.
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission will meet today to
consider tougher rules for people seeking permits to keep dangerous wildlife
in captivity. And while the changes recommended by the commission's staff are
an improvement over existing regulations, they don't go far enough to protect
Floridians.
Now, any animal no matter how dangerous can be kept in a residential
neighborhood as long as minimal lot size and caging requirements are met. The
commission staff would exclude "Class 1 Wildlife" (the largest wild
animals) from residential areas, but still allow "Class 2 Wildlife"
and poisonous snakes to be kept there. That means animals as dangerous as
cheetahs, hyenas and cobras could be in cages a few dozen feet from your door.
One group arguing for tougher regulations is the Florida Animal Control
Association, the officials in each county who must deal with nuisance and
unwanted animals. The residential restriction "should be on any animal
that is a danger to families or pets," said Bill Armstrong,
Hillsborough's director of animal services and a spokesman for the
association.
Those animal experts have some other helpful suggestions the Wildlife
Commission should consider before it passes a final rule. Houses that harbor
dangerous animals in cages should have signs indicating so in plain public
view, and their locations should be posted on the commission's Web site.
Owners of dangerous animals should be required to report escaped animals
immediately, and a disaster preparedness plan filed with emergency responders
should be at the ready.
While accidents such as the one with the black mamba are not common, they
aren't unheard of, either. Escaped pythons have become a nuisance in the
Everglades, where they threaten native wildlife, pets and maybe, one day,
humans.
The Wildlife Commission owes it to unsuspecting Florida residents to
provide more protection.
Permanent 1-day-a-week watering rule discussed
By TONY MARRERO
lmarrero@hernandotoday.com
BROOKSVILLE — County commissioners got their first look Tuesday at proposed
changes to the county’s landscape ordinance meant to eke out more water
conservation.
The discussion soon turned to the county’s watering ordinance, however.
At least two commissioners said it’s time to put a permanent,
one-day-a-week watering policy in effect and the issue could be on an upcoming
meeting agenda in the near future.
Commissioner Dave Russell said that action would save the county and
developers time and money to enforce what he called “draconian measures”
outlined in the landscape ordinance.
“If we have one day week watering ordinance in place, it would follow
that any developer is going to recommend putting in a Florida yard that
doesn’t require watering as often rather than a water-thirsty lawn,”
Russell said. “It seems to me it would be a simpler way to deal with the
water shortage rather than mandating what could be very expensive fixes.”
It would also help ease the confusion for residents, said commissioner
Diane Rowden.
“We need to stick with something and not keep going back and forth,”
said Rowden, who asked staff to put a proposal together for an upcoming
commission agenda.
Currently, Hernando County has a twice-a-week watering policy, but is under
a once-a-week mandate by the Southwest Florida Water Management District, or
Swiftmud.
Swiftmud declared a water shortage last month and instituted the
one-day-a-week mandate for all 16 counties in the district.
Grant Tolbert, the county’s development services director, highlighted
some of the main strategies to save water that the county could employ in a
revised landscape ordinance. The ordinance was last revised in 2001.
The changes would apply primarily to new commercial and residential
development.
Among some of the suggestions from staff:
— Increase the percentage of a commercial site that must include
preserved, natural vegetation. The current ordinance requires 3 percent. That
could be bumped up to, say, 10 percent, Tolbert said.
“The greater conservation area we have, the greater water conservation we
have,” Tolbert said.
— Make it mandatory to commercial development use shallow wells, lakes or
reclaimed water for irrigation, if possible. This would alleviate stress on
the county’s potable water system, Tolbert said.
County administrator Gary Kuhl said the county is currently looking at
grants to help pay for infrastructure and retrofit water treatment plants to
provide reclaimed water to areas of new growth, such as the planned
development district near the State Road 50/Interstate 75 interchange in Ridge
Manor.
— Reduce from 75 to 50 percent the amount of a development site that can
include high-water-use turf grasses such as St. Augustine and Floratam. Those
grasses could be banned altogether, Tolbert said.
Commissioner Chris Kingsley said he supported bringing the percentage down
to at least 50 percent.
— Require commercial and residential sites to install irrigation systems
that feature soil moisture sensors.
Bob Eaton, chairman of the government affairs committee for the Hernando
Builders Association, said he was concerned that his organization hasn’t
been asked for input as it was in 2001.
He said builders and developers could help put some of the theories into
real-world perspective.
“This is the first our industry has seen of this,” Eaton said. “We
haven’t looked at any cost data for these proposals.”
Local builder Joe Pastore warned commissioners about putting severe limits
on grass types that would force developers to use less attractive options.
“Be careful what you wish for,” Pastore said. “It’s going to look
ugly and people aren’t going to want to move here.”
Tolbert said he would form a focus group and invite builders and developers
to provide input. The commission will then hold a public hearing before voting
on the revised ordinance.
Reporter Tony Marrero can be contacted at 352-544-5286.
Drought remains despite some rain
A water district spokesman says the area still has a
large deficit.
You may have seen a relentless downpour at the Super Bowl in Miami, and
thunderstorms wetted the coast before spawning devastating tornados in central
Florida, but El Nińo's weather patterns have done little to alleviate the
region's drought.
Despite the recent rains, the Southwest Florida Water Management District,
which includes Manatee, Sarasota and Charlotte counties, remains under a
severe water shortage order issued last month. And much of Florida is still in
a drought.
"The rain always helps, but we're trying to overcome a 12-inch rainfall
deficit," said Michael Molligan, a spokesman for the water management
district. "We need a whole lot more of it."
The last time the district issued a water shortage order was in April 2000,
when the region experienced its most severe drought on record. That water
shortage order lasted until October 2001.
Average annual rainfall for this region is 52 inches. In 2006, just 41 inches
fell, making it the fourth driest year in 50 years.
Expectations that El Nińo would bring a wetter winter to make up the
shortfall have not been realized, so the district's water shortage order will
remain in effect until July 31. A severe water shortage order calls for higher
levels of conservation such as watering lawns no more than one day a week.
The conditions that prompted the region's water management district to issue a
severe water shortage order include abnormally low ground-water levels, below
normal flow in most of the region's rivers and either abnormally dry or
drought conditions in all 16 counties served by the water management district.
The drought also prompted the district to allow the Peace River Water
Authority to take water from the river at lower flow levels than previously
allowed or recommended.
Environmentalists are concerned that the district hasn't gathered enough
scientific evidence to ensure the health of the environment.
"We had this huge fight," said Becky Ayech, who founded the
Environmental Confederation of Southwest Florida. "Environmentalist said
we know you're going to bleed that river dry. They promised they wouldn't take
water at these flows. It's appalling that they've gone back on that."
Taking water from the Peace at low flow levels is perhaps the most drastic
measure allowed so far.
Rains aren't expected to increase flows before the summer.
Glades mining study OK'd
By Mitra Malek
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
It's a small step, but at least it's movement.
The county will begin studying how rock mining affects the Everglades
Agricultural Area by reviewing the permitting process it already has in place.
The study, which the Palm Beach County Commission approved last year, is
supposed to evaluate mining's long-term impact on water resources and the
environment.
County Water Resources Manager Ken Todd said Tuesday that the county's
current application process to mine new land already addresses those issues.
So the first phase of the study, lasting six months, will take a closer look
at whether those issues are being addressed adequately.
If phase one doesn't show the effects of mining well enough, then
commissioners can consider phase two, projected to take two to three years.
Phase two would take sediment borings and pump tests to analyze water from a
regional perspective. The entire study should be done by Dec. 1, 2008.
The commission voted unanimously Tuesday to follow the phased approach.
Environmental and growth watchdogs said they are happy the county is doing
the study, period. They also repeated long-standing concerns they've had about
blasting for rock.
"You're changing the geology, and you're bound to affect the
water," said Rosa Durando, the Audubon Society of the Everglades'
conservation chairwoman.
Commissioners last year voted to stop new mining in the Everglades
Agricultural Area until the study is done. The only exceptions are for
expansion of existing mines so long as they prove additional blasting won't
cause long-term damage, and mining related to water management and
restoration.
The county's policy is expected to be effective by the end of March. Until
then, applicants can submit mining proposals. For example, Rinker Materials
recently submitted an application to mine about 3,000 acres west of the
Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge and south of the county's planned
landfill.
Toward the end of Tuesday's discussion, Commissioner Warren Newell
disclosed that his engineering firm, SFRN, of which he is a "minority
stockholder," has done work for Florida Crystals, one of the study area's
major landowners.
"That may be one of the properties being looked at" in the study,
Newell said, adding that he didn't think a conflict existed with his vote
supporting the study.
Last month, Newell did not mention his engineering firm or disclose the
firm's work with the sugar company during two commission votes on zoning
measures in which Florida Crystals sought to allow ash landfills on its land.
Meanwhile, Newell had simultaneously pushed for more detailed disclosure of
companies and landowners seeking land-use and zoning changes. He also
suggested the creation of a county ethics commission, which his fellow
commissioners did not support.
Newell, who left Tuesday's meeting early, could not be reached for comment.
Cost to fix Lake O's leaky dike skyrockets
By Robert P. King
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
The Army Corps of Engineers' new, improved plan for leak-proofing the
Herbert Hoover Dike carries a new, improved price tag: $856 million, or nearly
triple what the agency said last year.
The jump reflects the increased complexity of the corps' latest repair plan
for the 143-mile-long Lake Okeechobee dike, which has appeared prominently in
recent studies of the nation's most troubled dams and levees. The engineers
also blamed the rising costs of construction materials, fuel and skilled labor
that are plaguing most construction projects.
The new plan replaces a more modest design that state consultants had
called likely to fail. That proposal would have cost about $300 million, corps
leaders said last year.
They called both figures rough estimates.
"This is our shot at what it costs to do what we're doing," said
Richard Bonner, the corps' top civilian engineer in Jacksonville.
"Everything's gotten very expensive right now."
Expensive or not, South Florida congressmen said the federal government
must do what it takes to safeguard the roughly 40,000 people who live near the
leak-prone dike.
"This is a project where you have public safety, so it's got to go to
the top of the list," said U.S. Rep. Tim Mahoney, D-Palm Beach Gardens.
"At some point you've got to let the experts decide what is the most
effective way to get this job done."
An aide to U.S. Rep. Alcee Hastings made a similar pledge, calling the dike
repair "probably the number one issue" for the Miramar Democrat.
"Obviously that's a high number," said Fred Turner, Hastings'
chief of staff. "He's going to work with the appropriators and the
administration to see that it gets the funding that it deserves."
Besides the money, the new cost estimate adds to questions about how long
the repairs will take.
At $56 million a year - the amount President Bush is seeking for the dike
in the 2008 budget - the corps would need 15 years to finish the job. That's
assuming the cost doesn't rise even higher.
Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., will seek whatever money it takes to speed up the
repairs, spokesman Bryan Gulley said. "If that means get it done in five
years, we should get it done in five years."
Under a decades-old agreement, Congress must pay to repair the dike while
the state buys the necessary land. Bonner said the estimated land costs for
the current design total about $31 million. The South Florida Water Management
District is expected to calculate more precise estimates based on maps the
corps provided Monday.
The dike has suffered for decades from increasingly troubling leaks caused
by high water in Lake Okeechobee, but the issue gained new urgency following
the catastrophic failure of New Orleans' levees after Hurricane Katrina in
2005.
Months later, the water district commissioned a study by engineering
experts who warned that the dike is vulnerable to a similarly disastrous
collapse. They labeled the dike a "grave and imminent danger" - both
to residents near the dike and to South Florida's water supply.
A more recent corps study has used nearly as blunt language to describe the
dike, calling it an "''urgent and compelling' dam in active
failure."
Les Bromwell, leader of the water district's consulting team, said it's not
surprising that the new repair design costs so much more. But he said it also
will do a lot more than the old plan to protect residents' lives.
The new plan, announced in October, enlarges a leakproof concrete wall that
the corps already had planned to embed inside and underneath the dike.
Bromwell's team had criticized the earlier plan, saying the wall didn't extend
deep enough to stop all leaks and might even worsen them.
The new design also calls for building a sand-and-gravel berm around the
dike to block leaks. The corps had included such a berm in one version of its
repair plans in 2000, but then shelved it to save money on land.
Bromwell said both steps should be enough to fix the leaks, the dike's most
immediate threat.
But he said it still wouldn't provide some safety features common in dams
that protect human life, such as an emergency outlet to release quickly rising
water.
"What they're doing is adequate," he said. "It's not a total
solution."
Swiftmud to Pay $400,000 for Land
The Southwest Florida Water Management District Governing Board on Tuesday
agreed to spend $400,000 to buy a 20-acre parcel along Rock Ridge Road to
expand the agency's Green Swamp Wilderness Preserve.
The property was purchased from William M. Raulerson of Polk City. The
agency's governing board approved the purchase Jan. 30.
The property will be added to the 142,000 acres protected by Swiftmud through
ownership or conservation easements.
The Green Swamp is one of the state's most significant water resources. Four
major rivers flow from the swamp. Also, its unique topography aids in flood
protection and acts as a natural filter to provide quality water.
The natural systems within the Green Swamp provide diverse ecosystems and
habitats for an array of wildlife.
County ideal for wildlife sanctuaries
By CINDY SWIRKO
Sun staff writer
Alachua County is where the wild things are, and more are likely on the way.
Sanctuaries, preserves and research centers that make their home here protect
animals such as cougars, bats, monkeys and tortoises from lands as far away as
Madagascar and India.
The reasons why they located here vary from the somewhat whimsical to the
perfectly understandable. But operators say the climate of Alachua County —
literally and figuratively — makes this an ideal place.
"Out where we live, philosophically, your business is yours," said
Bruce Capin, who has five cougars at his Yahtok'ya Animal Sanctuary in
northern Alachua County.
Capin was recently given a special exception to zoning regulations from the
Alachua County Commission for Yahtok'ya, just one of several permits generally
needed for operations that deal with wild or exotic animals.The intent of the
county regulations is to ensure that the facility is an appropriate use of the
land and is compatible with neighboring property. The state and federal
permits are aimed at the welfare of the animals and safety.
The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission has permitting authority
over facilities that deal with wild or exotic animals. Ken Holmes, an area FWC
officer who inspects the facilities, said he believes more of them will be
opening in the region in the future because rural land here is abundant and
relatively inexpensive.
"I came from the Naples area and there are a lot more of the big cats and
things like that down there. However, I do think that trend is going to
change," Holmes said. "The price of property is getting so high in
South Florida. I know two people who just moved up to Levy County."
Capin and his wife, Erika, moved to Alachua County from Las Cruces, N.M.,
several years ago. They have long wanted to work with cougars, and Capin, who
works as a college fencing instructor, wanted to relocate to a university
town.
The Gainesville area seemed ideal, he said, because of the availability of
land and the University of Florida. Yahtok'ya means "sunlight" in
the Zuni Native American language, which the Capins chose because it signifies
rays of hope.
Kari Bagnall was living in Las Vegas and was searching for a more humid
climate for her growing number of monkeys that were mostly either unwanted
pets or castoffs from the entertainment industry.
She opened Jungle Friends Primate Sanctuary between Gainesville and LaCrosse
in 1998 with 13 monkeys and now has about 80 — primarily capuchins, spiders,
marmosets and tamarins.
They live in more than 50 large enclosures furnished with tree limbs and
bamboo along with toys such as barrels that are plastic, open-ended and
hanging. They also have balls, hammocks and plenty of items on which to swing.
Many are connected by elevated fence tunnels, allowing the monkeys to romp
freely in between or pick at the heads of people passing underneath.
"Land in Vegas was very expensive and we were looking for a better
climate. Gainesville was kind of tropical. I would have gone farther south but
didn't because of the hurricane situation," Bagnall said. "Also,
having UF here was a factor. I don't think there is any veterinarian in this
town who will see monkeys, except at UF. And I was hoping to get some good
volunteers, and we have."
Linking the efforts of Bagnall and Capin is the inappropriateness of big cats
and monkeys as pets.
Most of their animals were pets of people who didn't realize that cougars get
big, eat a lot and can get rough, or that monkeys bite, scratch, escape and
develop other behavioral problems.
"I think a lot of people do it because they want to be cool and show off,
and then can't handle it. Their stupidity and ignorance costs the cat,"
Capin said.
Added Bagnall, "People really need to know what terrible pets monkeys
make. They are wild animals. They become prisoners, and prisoners are mean. In
their heart of hearts, they know something is wrong."
Bagnall said she gets interns from throughout the world who want experience
with monkeys. Other research-oriented facilities here also draw students —
and animals —from afar.
Ray Ashton created the nonprofit Ashton Biodiversity Research &
Preservation Institute in 1999 to promote and fund research projects with
gopher tortoises and species from foreign countries with similar habitat.
The institute is on a 200-acre preserve near Watermelon Pond — a site that
is a natural for gophers. Interns and scientists visit to learn more about
tortoises and animals that share their habitat.
Ashton said notable research is being done that can help save tortoises across
the globe.
"We are finding that tortoise foraging behaviors are as complicated as
any primates," Ashton said. "We also discovered that they
communicate with each other. That means they probably have social structures.
So we're starting to look at relocation and moving families and pods
together."
The Lubee Bat Conservancy near Gainesville has a similar mission in research,
conservation and education.
Not all of the county's animal facilities deal with captive wild or exotic
animals.
Pete and Mary Gregory for 23 years have operated Mill Creek Farm, a 245-acre
home to 135 horses that are retired from mounted police patrols, seized in
cruelty cases or abandoned, retired circus animals and others that could
otherwise be sent to the slaughterhouse or a less gentle place.
The Conservation Commission issues permits for captive wildlife such as big
cats, bears and larger primates. Capt. John West said 347 permits have been
issued statewide for facilities with up to 25 animals and 81 for those with
more than 25 animals.
Permits cover not just sanctuary or educational facilities but also zoos,
circuses and those who exhibit or sell exotics. Animals such as big cats
cannot be owned as pets in Florida.
West said some of the requirements have been changed to mandate more land or
larger enclosures, which could also prompt more facilities to relocate to this
region.
"It's become more strict because of the way Florida is growing. More and
more people are moving here and areas are becoming more urbanized and less
rural. Some of the larger cats have to be placed on five acres," West
said. "A lot of people don't want the animals to be held in a really
suburban-type situation. They want them in a more rural area. They have more
space between them and the neighbors and possibly less stress for the
animals."
Cindy Swirko can be reached at 374-5024 or swirkoc@ gvillesun.com
Attorney dives into springs feud
A fan of the mermaid park will work for free against Swiftmud.
CHANDRA BROADWATER
Published February 7, 2007
BROOKSVILLE - Jacksonville lawyer Leslie Goller was 6 when she fell in love
with the Weeki Wachee mermaids.
At 49, she still is. So much that she has volunteered to help the
attraction for free in its ongoing legal battle with the Southwest Florida
Water Management District.
Goller will help Weeki Wachee attorney Joe Mason as the two sides prepare
to head back to court in August. They are expected to pick an exact date
sometime this week.
After three years of trials, mediation, appeals and meetings, there are
still differences that stem from a lease - Swiftmud owns the land the
attraction is located on - plus a few other disagreements.
"I'm picky with who I'll handle," Goller said from her office at
the Terrell Hogan law firm in Jacksonville. "To me, Weeki Wachee is not
the polluter in this situation."
Goller said she made her decision after a weekend trip to the attraction
last month. She had lived in Dunedin until she was 7, when her family moved to
Washington, D.C.
After attending Duke University and graduating from the law school at
Washington and Lee University, Goller came back to Florida in 1983. Though she
primarily handles personal injury cases, she has fought her fair share of
environmental battles in Florida courts.
In the past, she received Sierra Club awards and worked in various
capacities to protect the St. Johns River and other state waters.
During her recent visit, Goller was shocked to find out from women in the
gift shop that Weeki Wachee was still in litigation.
Goller believes that Swiftmud is to blame for the shoddy condition of the
springs. The dead eelgrass and huge globs of algae growing along the river bed
- visible from the river cruise - are because of runoff from U.S. 19, she
said.
As landlord, Swiftmud is responsible for dealing with that, she said. She
believes runoff is also to blame for the sand that accumulated on the springs
beach, which the park tried to fix during the infamous dredging incident.
Swiftmud has disputed that and maintains that the park illegally dug sand
in the middle of the night.
The water district also continues to argue that the city of Weeki Wachee
broke state law by keeping the private company, Weeki Wachee Springs LLC,
intact when it was donated to the city by the previous owner.
But the primary concern of Swiftmud - which has been a major sticking point
in negotiations with Weeki Wachee - is to have the park obtain permission, or
what's been referred to as an "underwater lease," from the state
Department of Environmental Protection to use the springs and the river the
attraction is located on.
"The litigation goes away if we resolve the issue of the underwater
lease," said Michael Molligan, Swiftmud spokesman.
Last May, Swiftmud Chairman Tom Dabney and Weeki Wachee Mayor Robyn
Anderson met in Tampa - without lawyers - and went through the existing lease
between the two parties line by line for hours.
Except for the underwater lease, Molligan said both sides agreed to other
changes. At the time, the parties said they felt confident about coming to an
agreement.
But then a few weeks after the Tampa meeting, Mason filed a request to
start formal court mediation again. Swiftmud fired back a motion to continue
arguments before a judge.
Most recently, the water district received a revised lease - written by
former DEP employee Dale Adams, hired several months ago as an environmental
consultant by the park - which Molligan said was different from what had been
agreed to.
Weeki Wachee spokesman John Athanason said that no business would sign an
agreement without consulting an attorney and other officials. And that's what
Weeki Wachee did.
In the meantime, all the back and forth has caused Hernando Circuit Judge
Richard Tombrink to lose patience - again - with both sides. During a Jan. 29
hearing, he ordered the parties to settle or pick a trial date.
To Goller, the case between the mermaid park and the water district is
evidence of little guy getting picked on.
"The violator is Swiftmud, not the park," Goller said. "And
it's been going on since they've owned it."
Chandra Broadwater can be reached at cbroadwater@sptimes.com
or (352) 848-1432.
Developer launches 2-pronged
attack
Besides lawsuit, Rainbow River Ranch
negotiating possible sale with state
BY FRED HIERS
STAR-BANNER
DUNNELLON - The controversial issue of Rainbow River Ranch, a proposed
development near the Rainbow River that could include as many as 450 new
homes, is heating up again despite the City Council's decision last month to
hand it over to a lesser Dunnellon board to decide.
Rainbow River Ranch LLC developer Gerald Dodd said Friday he will pursue two
fronts to resolve his problem, which began when the City Council last November
suspended a tree-cutting permit that it issued him during the summer.
The first front was to fight the city in the courts. The second was to
continue quiet negotiations with state officials to maybe sell the 258 acres
along the pristine Rainbow River to the state for conservation land and avoid
the fight altogether.
As for the first front:
In December, Dodd filed a lawsuit in Marion County Court asking a judge to
intervene, saying he was not given due process when the City Council pulled
his tree-cutting permit.
In addition, he argues the city did not have the authority to suspend the
permit once it was issued.
During the past two months after filing the lawsuit, Dodd, however, did not
pursue that avenue and instead allowed the Dunnellon council to try to decide
what to do about the suspension. He intended to pursue the issue in court if
the council ruled against him.
Soon after the council voted to hand the issue over to its Code Enforcement
Board, Dodd's lawyers moved to have the lawsuit served on city officials.
The code board met Monday to discuss its March 19 meeting about the permit.
Some board members questioned why the council was handing them this issue,
when they didn't suspend the permit in the first place.
During Monday's meeting the five-member board decided they'd need their own
attorney - preferably Larry Haag - because Dunnellon city attorney Ted Schatt
is representing the City Council.
The code board chairman, Kurt Bond, also requested a law enforcement officer
at the meeting, and said the board would not tolerate disruptions. He said
violators would be escorted from City Hall.
As for Dodd's second front:
He said Friday he is meeting with state officials and discussing the
possibility of the government buying the land.
Dodd described the discussions as preliminary, but said he hired real estate
experts to appraise the property, which he bought for $7.5 million in 2004.
Dodd said discussions about the state buying the land began last year, and
they are continuing.
As for the price he wants, Dodd, citing the Florida real estate market, would
say only that prices have increased in the past two years.
Meanwhile, Dodd said he continues to push the lawsuit based on the council's
suspension of the tree-cutting permit. Dodd complained he had yet to get any
information from the city about specific violations to the permit.
He said he also had not been informed by the city that the council on Jan. 22
decided to let the code board rule on the suspension. The council had debated
whether to lift the suspension but failed to reach a decision.
The city staff, however, reported it saw no violations. Area residents and
some environmentalists reported last year to the council that they had seen
violations and urged the council to act.
Last month, the city's code enforcement officer resigned. He said residents,
including one Dunnellon council member, were trying to pressure him to say
there were tree-cutting violations.
Schatt would not comment on the lawsuit other than to say the city was served
with the paperwork and would respond.
Schatt said he was preparing a notice to inform Dodd of the council's decision
to allow its Code Enforcement Board to rule on the permit issue.
THE ISSUE:
The proposed Rainbow River Ranch development near Dunnellon
WHAT'S NEW:
The Dunnellon Code Enforcement Board prepares to hold a meeting on the permit.
Meanwhile, the developer is pursuing a lawsuit and negotiations with the state
over selling the property for conservation.
WHAT'S NEXT:
A Code Enforcement Board meeting March 19 at City Hall
Fred Hiers may be reached at fred.hiers@starbanner.com
or (352) 867-4157.
Venice may escape 'big city' fate
Now that downtown Venice, with its height overlays and its nomination to the
National Register of Historic Places, finally seems safe from demolition and
development, our concern must turn to what may be called uptown Venice --
upscale, up-to-date and much higher up. A mixed-use project proposed to follow
the three too-tall towers does promise to provide some desirable amenities: a
hotel, a waterfront restaurant and even some public parking. (Think of it: Park
uptown; walk downtown!) But at what price in terms of height? And could it be
stopped there?
In his May 14, 2006, column, titled "North Port turns a corner,"
Herald-Tribune columnist Larry Evans suggested that "now is the time to
envision a big city between Fort Myers and Sarasota."
Is it possible that anyone envisions planner John Nolen's Venice as that
"big city"? We hope not. Concrete canyons cast long shadows and can
spread like cancer. The only ones who benefit are the builders.
Judith and
Anthony Fazzolare Sr.
Venice
Developer given extra year to start Silver Oaks
By Jim Reeder
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
FORT PIERCE — A developer who won approval of a 365-unit subdivision two
years ago has been given an additional year to start work on the Silver Oaks
project.
Attorney Gary Hunter, representing Lennar Homes, cited the cooling real
estate market and delays in construction of Lennard Road among the reasons for
postponing the project.
Silver Oaks will be on the north end Lennard Road, a section to be paid for
by special taxes or assessments on landowners.
"We need right of way for the road, and when we get it, we're ready to
go," County Engineer Mike Powley said.
Residents of the area hoped commissioners would deny the extension of time
and require the developers to start over.
"They've had two years to do what they need to do," resident
Elizabeth McCabe said. "The real estate market is shot and we have enough
development already."
Other residents told commissioners they want to preserve the rural
atmosphere, with dirt roads and horses.
The Lennard Road project has been controversial among residents who will be
affected by its construction or widening.
Savannah Club residents are unhappy that proposals include widening to four
lanes a two-lane portion of the road that divides their community.
More-detailed studies are required on that portion because federal money will
be used to widen the road.
Powley said it's likely to be two years before that section is ready for
construction.
Another meeting for residents to express their views is expected next fall.
Red grouper stocks rebound - but wait
The bad news: Gag grouper are down. Recreational anglers face a one-month
ban.
STEPHEN NOHLGREN and TERRY TOMALIN
Published February 7, 2007
Finally, some good grouper news.
Red grouper stocks, long perceived by regulators to be overfished, have
rebounded to nearly complete health in the Gulf of Mexico, government scientists
say.
That is good news for diners. In 2004 and 2005, federal regulators shut down
the commercial fleet and wiped out fresh grouper sandwiches for months to
protect red grouper.
Recreational anglers also should applaud. Years of tighter red grouper
restrictions could eventually ease a bit.
But, as always in fisheries management, nothing is simple.
Recent data indicate that gag grouper, the gulf's other major grouper
species, are now in serious trouble. Because gag grouper and reds swim together,
people fishing for one species also kill the other, regulators said Tuesday.
Relax red grouper restrictions too quickly, and gags may suffer.
"Those two species represent 85 percent of the commercial shallow water
catch and 95 percent of recreational catch grouper," said Stu Kennedy, a
biologist for the Gulf of Mexico Fisheries Management Council. "They are
linked at the hip."
Beginning next week, recreational anglers will be banned from all grouper
fishing in federal waters for a month. Commercial fishermen have faced a Feb. 15
to March 15 closure for several years, but this is a first for the recreational
sector.
"Overfished" red grouper were the original justification. Now, a
shortage of gag grouper is to blame.
Florida, which often follows the federal government's lead on fishing rules,
did not impose the one-month closure in state waters, which extend from shore to
9 miles out in the gulf.
Most grouper are caught in federal waters, though they often come closer to
shore during winter.
People who depend on grouper for fun and livelihoods aren't pleased with the
federal ban.
Dave Bayes, manager of Dogfish Tackle in Seminole, figures he will lose
one-fifth of his business during the one-month closure. Grouper rods and reels
are his best sellers.
Spokesmen for recreational and commercial fishermen acknowledged that some
restrictions on gag may be necessary.
But their already shaky confidence in federal "stock assessment"
models was rattled further by details in the red grouper report, which passed
its final major review last week and will be formally presented in March at the
next gulf management council meeting.
The assessment showed that red grouper reproduction was stronger than average
in 1996 and huge in 1999. This created millions of baby fish that could grow up
to be mommies, daddies and sandwiches.
But those fish were too small to be counted during the previous red grouper
stock assessment, completed in 2001.
Not realizing that young grouper had surged, regulators continued to tighten
restrictions years after those babies were born and the stock was rapidly
rebuilding.
Two years ago, the National Marine Fisheries Services, using emergency
powers, lowered the maximum red grouper catch for recreational anglers from five
fish to two, and later to one.
When they also tried to halt recreational gag grouper fishing to protect
reds, the Florida chapter of the Coastal Conservation Association successfully
sued to overturn that rule.
"This whole situation has gotten out of hand," said Ted Forsgren,
director of the group. Regulators "overreacted. They should have looked at
what the trend showed before they took such radical action," he said.
In November 2004 and October 2005, regulators shut down all commercial
grouper fishing because the fleet had exceeded its red grouper quota. Mexican
imports filled the void.
"They caused severe economic impact on our industry because of
shortcomings in these models," said Bobby Spaeth, who owns the Tampa Bay
area's largest seafood house as well as commercial boats.
Kennedy, the federal biologist, said the gulf management council might lift
the one-month federal closure in 2008, but not until it gains more information
about gag and figures out how to regulate both red and gag with one set of
rules.
Developer scales back big plans in Volusia
Fewer homes, more land are in his vision for 5,000 acres near Deltona, Sy
Vogel says.
Denise-Marie Balona
Sentinel Staff Writer
February 2, 2007
The man who hopes to build a mega-development on nearly 5,000 acres near Deltona
has new ideas for jump-starting the project.
South Florida developer Sy Vogel said he went "back to the drawing
board" and came up with a proposal he thinks environmentalists and other
opponents will like better.
It's also one he hopes is safe from another potential legal challenge by Volusia
County.
To succeed, the property east of Deltona needs to be annexed into the city,
where the project has political support from officials who say it will boost the
local economy. The county, which currently has jurisdiction over the expansive
rural plot known as the Leffler property, wants to preserve it.
Vogel would not provide details about his changes but said he cut the number of
homes and preserved "much more" land.
His original plan included about 10,000 homes plus businesses and set aside
3,000 acres for conservation.
"It's going to be beautiful," said Vogel, who will present revisions
to city officials in coming months. "It really is. It's going to be a
showplace."
City Commissioner David Santiago said he hasn't seen or discussed the new
proposal but already welcomes it.
"That's part of Deltona's future," Santiago said.
County Chairman Frank Bruno said he likes the project, too. And he appreciates
the changes Vogel shared with him. But the development is in the wrong spot,
Bruno said.
"I have said it before, and I will say it again: not in the rural heart of
our county," he said.
Nevertheless, Vogel is trying to get more land in response to a circuit judge's
ruling in September.
The judge found that the Leffler property could not be annexed because the tract
was connected to Deltona by only a 350-foot-wide sliver of land.
Vogel wants additional land so he can create a more significant connection
between the city and the 5,000 acres.
Montye Beamer, county director of growth and resource management, said she
couldn't estimate how much land Vogel would need to avoid another challenge from
the county.
"The Leffler property is so large," Beamer said, "it would take a
considerable amount to make it what we would deem contiguous."
Vogel's attempts to get more land have focused on Deltona Farms Estates, where
each home sits on at least 10 acres.
Residents there have been buzzing about the issue for months.
Nick Mongello, a director of the neighborhood homeowners association,
distributed fliers warning residents that Vogel might ask them to switch from a
county to a city address.
Mongello said property owners can't do that on their own. The entire
neighborhood would have to agree. And that won't happen, he said.
In a letter to the association late last year, Vogel offered one resident
$100,000 to allow his acreage to be annexed.
Mongello hopes the resident doesn't give in. The county is assisting the
homeowners group in the matter, he said.
"The County Council is working on that issue -- the legality of them
changing their address," he said.
Locals such as Sirena Schrum are worried Vogel's development would ruin their
peaceful lifestyle. A lot of people there ride horses. Some keep chickens and
goats.
Schrum, a mother of four, said she hates the thought of Elkcam Boulevard
expanding to accommodate the growth.
"The traffic itself would hinder us," she said. "The traffic
flying up and down Elkcam would cause problems with the horses, possibly injure
people."
Vogel said he knows there will be critics, even with changes aimed at making the
project more environmentally friendly. But the benefits of the project outweigh
concerns, he said.
"We are patient people," he said. "We're going to take our time
with it."
Denise-Marie Balona can be reached at dbalona@orlandosentinel.com or
386-851-7916.
46 Nations Vow To Help Warming Planet
By ANGELA CHARLTON and SETH BORENSTEIN The Associated Press
Published: Feb 4, 2007
PARIS - Forty-five nations answered France's call Saturday for a new
environmental body to slow inevitable global warming and protect the planet,
perhaps with policing powers to punish violators.
Absent were the world's heavyweight polluter, the United States, and booming
nations on the same path - China and India.
The charge led by French President Jacques Chirac came a day after the
release of an authoritative - and grim - scientific report in Paris that said
global warming is "very likely" caused by mankind and that climate
change will continue for centuries even if heat-trapping gases are reduced. It
was the strongest language ever used by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change, whose last report was issued in 2001.
The document, a collaboration of hundreds of scientists and government
officials, was approved by 113 nations, including the United States.
Despite the report's dire outlook, most scientists say the worst disasters -
huge sea level rises and the most catastrophic storms and droughts - may be
avoided if strong action is taken soon.
In his call to action Saturday at a French-sponsored environment conference,
Chirac said, "It is our responsibility. The future of humanity demands
it."
Without naming the United States - producer of about one-quarter of the
world's greenhouse gases - Chirac expressed frustration that "some large,
rich countries still must be convinced." They are "refusing to accept
the consequences of their acts," he said.
It is mostly European nations that agreed to pursue plans for the new
organization, and to hold their first meeting in Morocco in the spring.
Chirac, 74, is seeking to leave his mark on international affairs before he
leaves office, likely in May, though his own environmental record over 12 years
as France's president is spotty.
Former Vice President Al Gore, whose Oscar-nominated documentary "An
Inconvenient Truth" on the perils of global warming has earned worldwide
attention, cheered Chirac's efforts.
"We are at a tipping point," Gore told the conference by
videophone. "We must act, and act swiftly. ... Such action requires
international cooperation."
The world's scientists and other international leaders also said now that the
science is so well-documented, action is clearly the next step.
"It is time now to hear from the world's policy-makers," Tim Wirth,
president of the United Nations Foundation, said Friday. "The so-called and
long-overstated debate about global warming is now over."
Granger Morgan, an energy expert at Carnegie Mellon University, predicted the
latest climate report "will kick a few more folks to get on board."
Jason Grumet, head of the U.S. bipartisan advocacy group the National
Commission on Energy Policy, said: "The debate has clearly shifted from a
battle over the science to fighting over the scope and design of the
solution."
Many questions remain about Chirac's proposed environmental body, however,
including whether it would have the power to enforce global climate accords.
Chirac's appeal says only that the group should "evaluate ecological
damage" and "support the implementation of environmental
decisions."
Many countries have failed to meet targets for cutting greenhouse gas
emissions laid out in the 1997 Kyoto Protocol. The United States has never
ratified the pact. On Friday, the Bush administration reiterated its rejection
of imposed cuts on greenhouse gases.
Chirac warned last week in a published interview that the United States could
face a carbon tax on its exports if it does not sign global climate accords.
The European Union, which agreed to the Kyoto Protocol curbing emissions, has
committed to a 20 percent reduction in carbon pollution by 2020, said Yvo de
Boer, executive secretary of the U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change. If
others join them, they could try for 60 percent cuts by 2050, he said.
The United Nations also is considering a summit of world leaders to tackle
global warming, and de Boer said he would expect the United States to send
high-ranking officials to attend.
Oceans' health linked to warming
Advocates hope to capitalize on climate-change talks
WASHINGTON -- People in low-lying coastal zones, like much of the state of
Florida, might want to take a better look at the ocean waters that a new global
warming report predicts will steadily creep ashore.
The seas aren't just rising because of human influence on climate, as a United
Nations panel reported last week. They are in terrible condition, too.
Advocates for quick action on ocean problems, which include red tide, dead
zones, dwindling fish stocks and dying coral reefs are hitching their agenda to
a flurry of activity on Capitol Hill aimed at combating global warming.
After all, these groups say, the oceans are a much bigger factor in global
warming than the buzz about ethanol would suggest. They argue it isn't enough to
address warming by tackling greenhouse gas emissions; oceans that have borne the
brunt of warming effects so far need attention.
"Everyone's talking about climate change these days ... but the federal
government is ignoring a critical piece of the climate puzzle, and that's the
oceans," retired Adm. James Watkins, former chairman of the U.S. Commission
on Ocean Policy, told reporters last week.
Congress created the commission in 2000 and charged it with a comprehensive
report on ocean health, which the panel released in 2004 with dire warnings and
sweeping recommendations.
The White House has taken steps to achieve some of the panel's scores of
proposals. Congress made progress in December by updating the national fisheries
management law that Bush signed in January -- a major event considering the law
technically expired in 1999.
But Watkins and environmental watchdogs say the efforts fall far short, given
the magnitude of the problem and the role oceans play in climate change.
Watkins now co-chairs a private group called the Joint Ocean Commission
Initiative with Leon Panetta, a former Clinton chief of staff who led an
independent ocean study by the Pew Charitable Trusts. They want to capitalize on
the growing determination in Congress to address climate change, which President
Bush mentioned in his State of the Union address last month and is likely to be
lavished with money.
"If 2006 is a year where we finally acknowledge the damage due to global
warming ... our hope is that 2007 will be a year of action to try to save both
our planet and our oceans," Panetta said.
A is for acid
The two oceans reports released in 2003 and 2004 described a deepening crisis.
Global warming had yet to gain the steam it has in recent months among lawmakers
now clamoring to address it. Ocean advocates say many of the problems are
linked.
Oceans help regulate the temperature of the atmosphere and the frequency and
severity of hurricanes and other weather events. But oceans, which also are
getting warmer, are absorbing large amounts of the carbon emissions blamed for
climate change. Many scientists say that makes oceans more acidic and harms
marine life.
Sen. Barbara Boxer of California, Democratic chairwoman of the Environment and
Public Works Committee, last week listed damaged coral reefs and fisheries among
more commonly cited global warming effects such as severe storms and droughts.
"We need to act soon," Boxer said at a hearing on global warming,
"before we reach a tipping point when irreversible changes to the world we
know may occur."
The Bush administration says it has made progress on oceans since the U.S. Ocean
Commission report in 2004. The White House reacted that year with an action
plan, required by Congress, with 88 objectives. The administration said in a
recent report it has met 73 of those goals, many of them creating new structures
to coordinate policy and science at various levels of government.
Rep. Sam Farr, D-Calif., faults the administration for setting the bar too low.
Farr, co-chairman of the House Oceans Caucus, introduced a bill last month that
would carry out many more of the Ocean Commission's recommendations, which
include strengthening the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.
Farr said he expects the new Democratic leadership in Congress to act.
"All weather on the planet originates in the oceans," he said.
"If the oceans are unhealthy, the weather is going to be unhealthy."
Anticipating criticism on the issue, the administration on recently touted
increases of $143 million for ocean programs at several agencies in its 2008
budget proposal, compared to its request for 2007. The White House will release
the new budget on Monday.
Watkins and Panetta said the funding request pales compared with their
recommendation that ocean management receive an additional $750 million each
year for at least the next five years.
The picture isn't much more positive for NOAA, the nation's primary ocean
agency. Bush is expected to ask Congress for $3.8 billion for NOAA in 2008, a
$100 million increase from his budget request for 2007. But Congress gave NOAA
$3.9 billion in 2006.
"For an agency that constantly serves so many Americans, the committee
cannot comprehend the Department of Commerce's failure to champion NOAA's
abilities," the Senate appropriations committee wrote in its 2007 spending
report.
F is for funding
The National Academies of Sciences concluded in a report last month that the
nation may lose about half of the environmental instruments aboard a network of
aging satellites by 2010 because of cutbacks at NASA and problems at NOAA.
"We can't afford to go without the tools that help us monitor and prepare
for the effects of global warming," Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., told the
Environment panel last week. "And we can't afford to cut corners when
lives, property, economies and ecosystems are at stake."
Environmental groups nevertheless acknowledge that, after decades of relative
inaction, progress has been made in recent months on ocean health.
The first significant sign came last June, when Bush created a vast marine
national monument off Hawaii. Still more encouraging to environmental groups was
passage, after a long stalemate, of the new Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Management
Act in December. The act is widely regarded as a step toward curbing overfishing.
Still, the Joint Ocean Commission Initiative gave the federal government a C-
for progress toward better ocean governance and an F for funding. A report card
released last week, however, gave states an A- for effort, citing the formation
of state-sponsored regional ocean management panels on the Pacific coast and
along the Gulf of Mexico.
Ocean advocates increasingly turn to coastal states to lead on these issues,
with California considered the most advanced. A coalition of environmental
groups is lobbying Republican Gov. Charlie Crist of Florida to step up Florida's
ocean protection efforts.
"The state faces some very substantial challenges, as evidenced by the red
tide incidents, obviously the experience with hurricanes, the eroding
shorelines," said Sarah Chasis, director of the oceans initiative at the
Natural Resources Defense Council, which is part of the coalition pressuring
Crist on the issue.
"There are a lot of serious challenges there."
Mike
Thomas
As Earth warms, coastal housing sales must cool
Published February 4, 2007
Anyone notice we didn't have winter this winter? I'm running the air
conditioner more than the heater.
And in a few more months, I'll be battening down the hatches.
The debate about whether we are cooking up bigger hurricanes with global
warming just got a little less debatable. It is "more likely than
not," the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change said last week.
This means that most experts worldwide think it is likely, even if Dick
Cheney and Exxon think it is not. What does this mean for Florida?
Imagine being in the ring with Mike Tyson in his prime. But every round, he
gains a pound of muscle.
And the fight never ends. More likely than not, that is our future.
The traditional theory about hurricanes is that their number and intensity
go up and down with natural cycles. We had a calm cycle from the 1970s
through the mid-'90s. And then came the active cycle we now find ourselves
in. This theory is comforting in that it tells us calm eventually will
return.
Many hurricane experts still abide by this. But a growing number think
global warming is juicing that cycle, just like it is throwing every other
weather pattern out of whack.
In effect, we are creating a cycle of stronger storms that will last for
centuries, not decades.
That is bad enough.
But the climate-change panel also says sea level is expected to rise up to
23 inches by the end of the century. Many experts consider this too
conservative because it doesn't take melting polar ice sheets into account.
Some scientists foresee a 3- to 5-foot rise by 2100.
Florida is a geological submarine that surfaces and submerges with the sea
level, which rises and falls with the Earth's temperature. All those nice
hills in Lake County are old beach dunes from a time when Cocoa was a
sandbar. We are fast-forwarding back to those days.
Rising seas. Bigger hurricanes. Higher storm surges. More buildings. More
people. And we're not alone.
A team of NASA scientists reported last year that with rising seas, a
Category 3 hurricane could put much of New York under water and shut down
its transportation system.
Just as insurers are bailing out of Florida, you will see them bail out of
other coastal areas.
The good news is that this increases Florida's argument for a federal
hurricane-insurance program.
The bad news is that it points out the insanity of Charlie Crist's taxpayer
bailout of the coastal-insurance market. Insurance rates on the coast need
to go up, and he is cutting them. And now he wants to cut property taxes for
those who own investment or second-home condos on the beach.
Such measures are intended to prop up an overbuilt and inflated coastal
real-estate market.
Crist is from St. Petersburg, where condo sales are foundering badly,
particularly on Clearwater Beach.
Senate President Ken Pruitt is from Port St. Lucie, where the median sales
price for a home in December was $240,000. In December 2005, it was
$263,300.
House Speaker Marco Rubio is from Miami-Dade, which may be the most
saturated and precarious condo market in the nation.
They are using taxpayers to prop up their hometown real-estate values.
And the result is that this will only encourage more dense development as
local governments look to cash in on the property taxes.
Our coastal growth machine is about to collide with storms, the likes of
which we may never have seen. Even hurricane experts who don't buy the
global-warming theory have argued that for years.
If possible, this just ups the ante.
Mike Thomas can be reached at 407-420-5525 or mthomas@orlandosentinel.com.
Associated
Press
All
18 young whooping cranes led south from Wisconsin by ultralight aircraft last
fall were killed in storms that hit Florida, dealing a devastating blow to a
project to create a second migratory flock of the endangered birds in North
American, a spokesman said.
The cranes were being kept in an enclosure at the Chassahowitzka National
Wildlife Refuge near Crystal River when the storms moved in and intensified
Thursday night, said Joe Duff, senior pilot and co-founder of Operation
Migration, a nonprofit organization coordinating the project.
Duff, contacted by telephone, speculated that an unprecedented storm surge
drew the tide in and overwhelmed the birds or they were electrocuted from
lightning strikes reported in the area.
The cause of the deaths wasn't immediately known, but Duff said the birds
would soon be tested at the University of Florida.
Duff said there was no way of knowing whether other whooping cranes that
winter in the area had survived the storm
DOT Says It Postponed Road Projects, Others Say They're Erased
|
By Bill Rufty
bill.rufty@theledger.com
One of the earliest and most heated political subjects that American
legislatures and local governments had to deal with was the politics of roads.
It continues today despite what was to have been the establishment of an
objective bureaucratic system for dealing with roads.
It used to be that road projects and the old road boards were filled with
cronyism … a road routed to cross a political ally's property for big
right-of-way bucks or to enhance a business.
But that stopped years ago with the system of letting local governments on local
metropolitan transportation committees set the priority of road projects.
Uh, it did, didn't it?
Well, there are priorities and there are priorities. The Department of
Transportation cut major roads from its five-year plan, developed by these local
committees, saying it didn't have the money.
The DOT says they have just been postponed.
State Sen. Paula Dockery, R-Lakeland, lost several roads in her district
and disagrees with the portrayal of the projects as having just been postponed.
She is now, perhaps to the discomfort of some DOT officials, a member of the
Senate Transportation Committee.
"They say the projects have not been killed but delayed. That is not true.
I have looked at the plans and many are no longer there. They are discarded, and
these are projects that local governments spent months developing among
themselves as the most equitable,'' she said.
DOT officials get a little miffed when asked if this was just a maneuver by the
bosses up the chain to squeeze more money for roads out of the Legislature -
most of the removed projects were deemed as the highest ranked or most crucial
in some areas. But during the now-cooling building boom the cost of materials
and labor climbed.
Dockery was successful more than a year ago getting Lakeland's In-Town Bypass
restored, although trimmed down a bit. And she said she has a promise that the
DOT will begin taking right of way for the project to put four lanes of U.S.
17/92 through Lake Alfred.
And DOT officials have tried to be accommodating, Dockery said, but it is not
enough because they have not respected the wishes of the community officials who
put the work plans together.
"The five-year plans were drawn up locally and then sent to us in the
Legislature and we approved them. Then they have cut programs that the
Legislature has already passed on and the governor has signed off on.''
But changes are a coming. Dockery said a bill is being drafted that would
require that changes in any five-year road plan that has been approved by the
Legislature would come back to the Legislature for approval before those changes
are made.
In other words, the DOT would have to get permission to cut a road already
approved.
Of the 61 road projects killed, uh, postponed, uh, delayed, five were from Polk
County.
IT'S PARTY TIME IN AVON PARK
A new political party has just been formed with strong ties just next door in
Highlands County.
The American Party of Florida is listed on the state elections site with its
chairman, Tom Macklin.
Last July, as mayor of Avon Park, Macklin proposed the Illegal Immigration
Relief Act that would have applied to Avon Park, if passed. It would have fined
any that business hired or rented to illegal immigrants and could have even led
to a suspension of the occupational license, meaning they could not have
operated a business within the city.
The measure failed 3-2.
Macklin later became the lieutenant governor running mate of Reform Party
candidate Max Linn. Although he could not be reached to learn more about
the party on Friday, the mailing address and headquarters are listed as being in
Avon Park.
There are several organizations listing themselves nationally as the American
Party.
The main American Party, which split from the American Independent Party in the
1970s has a Web site that, among other things, accuses President Bush of
"spending 18 percent more than Bill Clinton on social
programs." They also say that "seven out of the nine current members
of the Supreme Court were appointed by Republican Presidents" implying that
Republicans, to them, aren't the real conservative party.
Then there is the American Independent Party California and Independent American
Party of Nevada both which are affiliates of the national Constitution Party.
The original American Independent Party had its most famous candidate in 1968 -
former Alabama Gov. George C. Wallace, who chose Gen. Curtis E. LeMay
as his running mate. The party split in 1976 into the American Party and the
American Independent Party, with the later made up mostly of southern
conservatives and the former of northern and mid western conservatives.
And there are many others, mostly regionalized.
You can access any of the parties not by calling here, but by getting on the old
computer and doing a search.
Ledger Political Editor Bill Rufty can be reached at bill.rufty @theledger.com
or 802-7523.
3,700 more homes eyed for northwest Hernando
By MICHAEL D. BATES
mbates@hernandotoday.com
BROOKSVILLE — It may not have garnered much attention yet, but when it goes
before planning and zoning commissioners sometime early this year, Lake Hideaway
is sure to get its share of headlines.
This proposed community is so big it will contain its own mini-city.
When it is built, Lake Hideaway in northwest Hernando County will have an
estimated 2,400 single-family homes and 1,300 townhouses and apartments.
This 3,700-home development is expected to be a huge magnet for families and
create even more of a demand for a new regional park in that part of the county.
The project is considered a development of regional impact (DRI) because it
has more than 1,000 homes. As such, the developer — Metro Development Group
— is required to meet more stringent infrastructure and other land use
requirements.
For example, the Withlacoochee Regional Planning Council (WRPC) must review
the developer’s application to see how it would affect the surrounding
community.
To date, the WRPC has completed two reviews and has asked Metro to address
several concerns, including more specific details about wetland protection
sites, pedestrian walkways, water supply and hurricane shelters.
Metro was granted a 30-day extension of time to address those and other
concerns.
The zoning request is expected to go before planning and zoning commissioners
early this year. They will then make a recommendation to the county board.
The 885-acre Lake Hideaway would be located on the east side of U.S. 19,
about four miles north of State Road 50. The northern boundary is Hexam Road and
the southern boundary is Star Road.
Lake Hideaway would wrap around Whitehurst Pond, which was once a popular
spot for mud-boggers. The developer is planning to enhance the pond to make it
more of a focal point for the community.
The eastern boundary of the property would be Weeping Willow Road, which
could be extended to Hexam.
The application sets aside 180,000 square feet for neighborhood commercial
use, 20,000 square feet for office space, 20 acres for a park and 30 acres for a
future school site. Another five acres is planned for a possible fire or police
station and satellite government offices.
Reporter Michael D. Bates can be contacted at 352-544-5290.
Pasco Protects Dwindling Green Space
Published: Feb 3, 2007
The development frenzy that's made Pasco the nation's 38th
fastest-growing county has heightened the need to protect environmentally
sensitive lands. Fortunately, greener times are ahead, thanks to a 2˝-year-old
county land-purchasing program.
The program, funded by a portion of the penny sales tax that voters approved
in 2004, achieved a major milestone last week when the county completed its
first purchase - 111 acres north of State Road 52 between U.S. 41 and the
Suncoast Parkway. Called the Upper Pithlachascotee River Tract, the $1.1 million
tract includes a riverbed and a cypress tree believed to be at least 200 years
old.
This is a deal worth celebrating. Not only will an undisturbed part of Pasco
be preserved, protecting the environment and saving the expense of more
infrastructure to serve development, residents will eventually be able to hike
on planned trails there. It's a win-win for taxpayers.
And more good news is on the way. Pasco also expects to buy 11 acres adjacent
to the tract for $426,500. This land, which includes a house that could be used
for a nature center, will give the public easier access to the Upper
Pithlachascotee Tract. In addition, program manager Rene Wiesner Brown says the
county expects to purchase, at a cost to be determined, a conservation easement
that includes the river's headwaters.
Pasco is a bit late to preserving sensitive lands for future generations.
Hillsborough created its environmental lands acquisition program in the late
1980s. Still, as the county's first acquisition last week showed, it's not too
late. It's exciting to watch the young program begin to make an impact in a
county where development dominates the landscape.
We Value Our Parks Much More These Days
|
By Tom Palmer
tom.palmer@theledger.com
As I was preparing to cover the recent opening of Colt Creek State Park,
I had a nagging question.
How did our coverage of this park opening compare with the way we covered
the opening of Lake Kissimmee State Park in 1977?
This took a little research.
First, I had to find out exactly when Lake Kissimmee State Park opened.
The folks at the park didn't know.
I checked at the Polk County Historical Library and someone there was kind
enough to check the microfilm for the Lake Wales News, a local weekly, to
come up with the date, which was Aug. 5, 1977.
Then I went to The Ledger's microfilm and looked at newspapers published
around that date for evidence that we had noted the opening of the first
state park in Polk County's history.
I could find nothing.
I persisted and finally located an article on Aug. 11, 1977, somewhere
inside the local section, that let readers know that the park was finally
open.
Even without the advance publicity, the park attracted 700 visitors in the
first three days, according to the article.
I thought about this and talked to some parks folks I know about this
discrepancy in the way we cover state park openings then and now.
The consensus is that parks, especially large parks for nature-based
recreation, are something the public appreciates a lot more today than it
did 30 years ago.
This is especially true in this part of Florida, where tracts of scenic
landscape are as likely as not to be bulldozed the next time you drive by
them.
In that context, the remaining land is a refuge from the urban onslaught for
the people as much as for the wildlife.
I visited Lake Kissimmee State Park often in those early days. It was a
great place to experience some memorable moments in nature study.
I watched a raccoon with its young foraging in broad daylight.
One cold day I found a small bird called a blue-gray gnatcatcher sitting
against an oak tree trunk and was able to reach down and pick it up.
Another day I sat on a tree limb near Lake Kissimmee and a bald eagle flew
by so closely I could hear its wing beats.
I remember the first time I flushed a woodcock in the pinewoods.
In the early days there were still old pots and "cat face" scars
on the trees from turpentining.
In those days there weren't many alternatives if you wanted to enjoy the
outdoors without trespassing.
There were no other state parks in the county and it was years before voters
approved the county's environmental lands program or the water management
districts began buying land in the Green Swamp or along the Kissimmee River
to form today's amazing network of preserves.
In the meantime Polk's population has grown by about 200,000 and they have
to live somewhere, so the preservationists are racing with the developers to
claim what's left.
In the intervening years, as more natural areas have opened, I have visited
them, too.
I've see something new every time I visit, no matter how many times I've
been there.
The natural world is always changing and my journeys sometimes take me along
a slightly different path at a different time of day or different time of
year and I make another discovery.
These are usually small things - a wildflower I've never seen before, an
interesting insect, a hummingbird sipping nectar from a wild rose, an
unexpected encounter with a bobcat - but they enrich the experience and keep
me coming back for more.
Now that Colt Creek State Park is open, near the opposite corner of Polk
County from Lake Kissimmee State Park, I look forward to another string of
discoveries.
I recommend it to you all.
GREAT BACKYARD BIRD COUNT
The Great Backyard Bird Count is coming Feb. 16-19.
This is a good chance to take stock of the bird life that's literally in
your own backyard or thereabouts.
The great part about this count is that you can spend as little as an hour
or as much as a weekend, depending on your schedule.
Anyone can participate.
Last year participants turned in 60,503 checklists with sightings of 7.6
million birds representing 622 species.
To learn more, go to www.birdsource.org/gbbc/.
Tom Palmer can be reached at 863-802-7535 or tom.palmer@theledger.com.
Playing at 20 questions
Is Dunnellon developer abusing a special
river and the legal process?
BY PAUL MARRAFFINO
SPECIAL TO THE STAR-BANNER
The Star-Banner editorial ("Missing the forest for the trees,"
Jan. 19) regarding the Rainbow River Ranch tree cutting permit seems off the
mark. Some questions that should be asked of the Rainbow River Ranch
developer regarding tree cutting are:
Does the Rainbow River have special protection because it is a Florida
Outstanding Water, a Surface Water Improvement and Management (or SWIM)
Plan river, a Florida Aquatic Preserve and a federally designated natural
landmark by the U.S. Department of the Interior?
Is the area around East Blue Cove designated as a conservation area on
the Dunnellon future land use map?
Is the area around East Blue Cove designated as a conservation area in
the 2001 stipulated agreement between the former and current owners and
the city of Dunnellon?
Did the Rainbow River Ranch tree removal permit issued on Aug. 23, 2006,
state that the tree removal was limited to "dead and endangering
trees"?
Did the photographs taken by Burt Eno and Councilwoman Mary Ann Hilton
on Sept. 28 and presented to the city manager on that date and later to
the City Council show numerous live trees had been cut down?
Is the land adjacent to the Rainbow River from the water's edge to the
edge of the old railroad right-of-way defined as wetlands in the Rainbow
River management plan?
Does cutting 90 percent of the forest next to a SWIM Plan river, a
wetlands, a conservation area and a Florida Outstanding Water contradict
the Florida Forestry Manual Best Management Practices and the developer's
stated goal "to improve the health of the shoreline"?
Should the concept that cutting 90 percent of the forest next to a SWIM
Plan river, a wetlands, a conservation area and a Florida Outstanding
Water and burning the wood in the upland pasture constitutes silviculture
be rejected?
Does section 74-69 of Dunnellon's ordinances state, "The provisions
of section 74-67 notwithstanding, the proposed removal of cypress (Distichum
spp.) or trees in excess of 24 inches DBH shall require application to and
authorization by the board of adjustment. The standard to be exercised by
the board of adjustment and recited as a finding shall be either that: (1)
There is no practicable manner of effecting the proposed construction upon
the parcel other than through removal of the subject tree; or (2) The
subject tree simply is not a specimen deserving of enhanced
protection"?
Did the Rainbow River Ranch developer cut cypress trees without getting
the required "finding" from the Dunnellon Board of Adjustment?
Did the developer continue to cut trees after the Dunnellon City Council
suspended his permit to do so?
Was the developer cited for cutting trees after the suspension and did
he continue to cut trees and pull trees out with a tree tractor after that
citation, as reported at the Jan. 17 City Council meeting?
I believe the answers to all these questions are "yes."
The developer has abused the river and the Dunnellon legal process to do
"development site preparation" before pursuing the permit
reviews of the city of Dunnellon, the Southwest Florida Water Management
District and the Army Corps of Engineers.
The tree removal permit suspension should be made permanent.
Paul Marraffino is a retired electrical engineer who has studied
natural and municipal water systems for the last 10 years.
No love lost between residents,
developers over proposed Mariana Oaks construction
By Jeff Burlew
DEMOCRAT STAFF WRITER
A possible final decision on the proposed Mariana Oaks development on Old
St. Augustine Road could come next week.
And it appears that the developers are no closer to an agreement with
nearby residents, who want a big reduction in the number of home sites.
Former Tallahassee Mayor Scott Maddox, who is representing the neighbors,
met late last month with attorney Rick Bateman, who is representing the
developer, Helios Investment Group.
"We made absolutely no progress in that meeting because the
applicant's attorney was unwilling to discuss closing the access to the canopy
road, buffering or any other conditions," Maddox said.
The proposal currently under review calls for only one entrance - from Old
St. Augustine, a protected canopy road. The canopy-road cut is permissible if
the development has no other entrance.
But the developer, under a different corporation, also is planning a
residential development called Mason Creek just west of Mariana Oaks. And
Bateman has proposed building a road that would go through both developments
and allow cars to enter and exit through Williams Road.
Maddox said the argument that Mariana Oaks doesn't have access other than
from Old St. Augustine Road is "disingenuous at best."
But Bateman said only one tree would be lost because of the canopy-road
cut. And he said it's possible that the entrance from the canopy road would be
closed after Mason Creek is built.
"That's just something we've discussed," he said.
County staff members have said that Mariana Oaks basically complies with
the Comp Plan, the local blueprint for growth. However, it's the type of
development that comes under review by county commissioners, and they have
voted against it twice so far.
Mariana Oaks has 52 home sites on about as many acres. Nearby residents
live on much bigger lots, and they don't want more compact housing next door.
They're worried about traffic congestion, flooding and harm to trees and
wetlands. But mostly, they're worried the area will lose its country feel.
"Basically speaking, they're going to ruin the neighborhood,"
said Bob Nelson, who lives on nearly 14 acres on a hill above Mariana Oaks.
Nelson says he has no doubt the homes will be attractive, but he says there
will be simply too many of them.
A public hearing is set for Feb. 13. Commissioners aren't saying much about
the situation because the developers are suing the county over previous
commission denials. Commissioner John Dailey would say only that he wants
"something that the neighborhood is pleased with and the developer."
What: Public hearing on Mariana Oaks development
When: 6 p.m. Tuesday, Feb. 13
Where: Fifth floor of the Leon County Courthouse, 301 S. Monroe St.
3 executives join Lake Nona Holdings
The trio will help oversee the expansion of the Orlando community.
Jerry W. Jackson
Sentinel Staff Writer
February 3, 2007
A former top administrator with the city of Orlando and two veteran
development-and-construction executives have joined Lake Nona Property
Holdings to help oversee expansion of the 7,000-acre
residential-and-commercial community in southeast Orlando.
Richard Levey, who served as Orlando's chief administrative officer from 1999
to 2005, joins Lake Nona to oversee master planning and community design and
management. He will also oversee economic-development activities including
recruitment of health-care, biotech and medical-education companies.
Robert Wilson joins Lake Nona as a vice president and will oversee
construction and development in Lake Nona South. He was employed by Hoar
Construction in Orlando for more than 29 years, most recently as vice
president of the Florida division. He specialized in large-scale projects such
as Lake Sumter Landing at the Villages, Thornton Park Central, and the Ritz
Carlton at South Beach.
Jim Bennett joins Lake Nona as construction administrator and senior project
manager for vertical construction -- including the future Burnham Institute
for Medical Research -- on the Lake Nona South property. He previously worked
for Marriott Corp. as a senior project manager and director, and one of his
projects was the Orlando Grande Lakes luxury resort.
Levey, who resigned from Mayor Buddy Dyer's staff in 2005, had worked for the
city since joining the planning department in 1986. He left the city to direct
land entitlement throughout Central Florida for Donald W. McIntosh and
Associates.
Jerry W. Jackson can be reached at jwjackson@orlandosentinel.com or
407-420-5721.
Fluid Industry
By MARC VALERO
mvalero@highlandstoday.com
AVON PARK — Dairy farmer Dennis Coulter starts his day with
buttered toast, two eggs over medium, bacon and of course a glass of milk.
“I’m supporting the grain industry, poultry business and dairy, and
with a couple pieces of bacon, that takes care of the hog industry,” he
said.
Coulter owns and operates the Wabasso Road Dairy on State Road 64 east of
Avon Park.
The dairy industry faces declining per capita milk consumption, stagnant
prices, rising feed costs and environmental concerns.
But, despite these challenges, local and Florida dairy farmers are working
year round to keep the state’s supermarket coolers supplied with milk.
In 1974, when Coulter entered the business, there were more than 400 dairy
farms in Florida. Now there are about 160.
To meet the growing population and demand for milk, the 160 dairies are
producing as much or more milk than the 400 were producing then, Coulter said.
It’s pretty much like every other industry, everything is having to get
bigger and bigger to survive economically.
Along with larger farms, advances in dairy cow genetics has led to more
milk per cow, increasing dairy production, he said.
The Wabasso dairy is milking 2,000 cows three times a day, which yields
16,000 gallons a day.
With cooler temperatures making for contented cows, this is the peak
production time for Florida dairy farmers. Cows are very sensitive to heat,
Coulter said. When they are cool and comfortable they have a bigger appetite
resulting in more milk.
The rain and humidity makes it miserable for the cows, said Nick Bishop, of
the Bishop Brothers Dairy, Lorida.
“If it’s 9 or 99 [degrees], if it’s dry, it’s not so bad,” he
said. “But, when it’s 99 and wet, it’s bad.”
In an effort to produce enough milk for the growing population of the
Southeast, particularly Florida, the winter months see excess production with
milk shipped out of the state, according to Southeast Milk, Inc., a dairy
cooperative. Conversely, the summer’s heat and humidity reduce production
levels and create a milk deficit situation and SMI procures and moves milk
into the state.
Protecting The Environment
Thirty years ago there were basically no environmental costs associated
with dairy farming, but today it is one of the industry’s biggest concerns,
Coulter said.
“We are in favor of most all of it,” he said. “It’s accelerated the
pace at which farms get bigger. You’ve got to spread the cost. It costs as
much to make a 100-cow dairy environmentally acceptable as it does a 1,000-cow
dairy.
The Bishop Dairy implemented its first environmental plan around 1991, Nick
Bishop said. The dwindling number of dairy farms in the county is largely due
to the environmental regulations.
“We are in compliance and have been in compliance, but they want more and
that comes out of our milk check,” he said. “We just can’t raise the
price of our milk because the government agencies want us to do more
[environmentally].”
The environmental groups are bad mouthing the farmers saying we are
polluting, we are polluting ... they are running us out business,” Bishop
said. “If they complain about having a gallon of milk for $3 when they go to
the store and there is not a gallon of milk in the store, that’s going to be
problem.”
It’s getting harder and harder for young farmers to get into and stay in
business in any kind of farming, he added. It’s very costly and the price of
land is getting so high now.
Highlands County dairies have been impacted more by the environmental
pressures than Hardee County dairies, Southeast Milk, Inc. President Joe
Wright said.
“In Highlands County, a lot of it is in the Okeechobee Basin with all
those Lake Okeechobee issues,” he said. “In Hardee County we have a little
different type soil, clay soils, and it’s a little easier to comply with
environmental regulations.”
Rising Feed Prices
The big push to use corn for ethanol as a replacement for petroleum is
going to hit the consumer’s pocketbook, Wright said. It substantially
increases a dairy farmer’s operating costs and also affects the beef,
chicken and hog industries.
What does not eat corn, Bishop asked. It’s going to hurt all farmers.
Most cow feed is comprised of byproducts such as cotton seed and cotton
seed hulls, citrus pulp and hominy.
Feed is a dairy operation’s biggest expense, amounting to 40 percent of
the production cost, Coulter said.
A dairy cow eats about 40 to 48 pounds of feed each day.
“A year ago we were buying corn products for $100 a ton and today they
are $160 to $170 a ton,” Coulter said. “That’s a 60 percent to 70
percent increase to a part of our cost that equals 40 percent of the total
cost of production.”
The consumer thinks ethanol is grand, but it’s based on corn costing
$2.50 per bushel, he said. Now all of a sudden corn is $4.50 a bushel.
The price of oil has gone down a little, “so, I think it’s all based on
false economies,” Coulter said.
“We are going to have to produce several billion more bushels of corn in
this country to supply the ethanol deal,” he said. “Whether it’s going
to be economical to do that, I don’t know.”
Per Capita Consumption Down
In 1909, Americans consumed a total of 34 gallons of fluid milk per person
– 27 gallons of whole milk and 7 gallons of milks lower in fat than whole
milk, mostly buttermilk, according to Amber Waves, a publication covering
rural farming.
Fluid milk consumption shot up from 34 gallons per person in 1941 to a peak
of 45 gallons per person in 1945. Milk was not rationed during World War II.
Since 1945, however, milk consumption has fallen steadily, reaching a
record low of just under 23 gallons per person in 2001 (the latest year
statistics were available for the report).
The decline in per capita consumption of fluid milk may be attributed to
competition from other beverages, especially carbonated soft drinks and
bottled water, a smaller percentage of children and adolescents in the U.S.,
and a more ethnically diverse population whose diet does not normally include
milk, according to the Amber Waves report.
The per capita consumption of lower fat milks was 15 gallons in 2001, up
from 4 gallons in 1945 and 6 gallons in 1970.
Touting The Health Benefits
“We’ve had some very favorable scientific studies in the last couple of
years about the importance of whole milk products.” Coulter said. “For the
last 20 years, all we’ve heard was negative stuff.”
Eggs went through a similar cycle with studies showing the negatives, but
that has also changed now, he said.
“We like to think milk is nature’s most perfect food – and complete
food.
Pizza’s popularity is a plus for the dairy industry.
It takes about a gallon of milk, which weighs 8.6 pounds, to make a pound
of cheese and on a really good quality pizza there will be a pound of cheese,
Coulter said. So the pizza industry has been good to the dairy industry.
Pricing
The federal milk marketing program requires most milk producers and
handlers to set minimum prices on their products and to pool their revenues.
Southeast Milk, Inc., handles pricing, within the federal limits, for many
local and southeast U.S. dairy farms.
The Wabasso dairy nets about 17 cents for a pound of fluid milk, Coulter
said.
He recalls getting 12 cents a pound 30 years ago, when diesel fuel was a
quarter a gallon.
“We don’t see that trend changing,” he said, about the price
remaining low compared to the rising prices of most products and services.
“We are going to continue to have to get bigger,” to remain profitable.
“It’s kind of sad in a lot of ways, but I don’t see it changing,”
Coulter said.
Proposed coal plant slated for construction near
Lafayette County
By Ira Mikell, Free Press Reporter
— Construction of a coal-fired power plant to generate electricity
is scheduled to commence sometime next year and is projected to be completed
by 2012. It will be built on 3,000 acres of pineland near the Fenholloway
River in Taylor County and approximately five miles north of the Lafayette,
Taylor County line off US 27.
Since it was first discussed in 2005, this new plant, called Taylor Energy
Center, has created a massive controversy. It is an ongoing heated debate
among the citizens of Perry, health and environmental officials, local
interest groups, and others, the effects of which can be felt as far east as
Baker County. Even several surrounding counties—Dixie, Madison, Leon, and
Wakulla—have become involved in the fight.
The coal plant, according to TEC officials, will be a state-of-the-art
facility that is environmentally friendly. For example, TEC officials have
stated that the quality of the air we breathe will not be compromised because
the plant will strictly conform to all air quality standards set forth by law.
Those opposing the plant disagree. They believe the effects from it will do
greater harm to the environment than the benefits it will produce. One such
opponent is Diane Whitfield who is a Taylor County resident. According to
Whitfield, coal plants produce an abundance of carbon dioxide that pollutes
the air. “The coal plant proposed is 800 megawatts big and will have two or
three 700 ft high emission stacks. It will emit enough carbon dioxide that it
would take over 800,000 acres of young planted pines to absorb a year’s
worth,” Whitfield said.
Capital Medical Society, based in Tallahassee, is also adamantly against its
construction and warns those in favor of it, as well as residents who will be
in its wake, of the dire health effects that will be produced. “From a
healthcare point of view, we are opposed to a coal-fired power plant in our
area because it will be detrimental to the health of our patients who have
lung and cardiac diseases and because it increases the incidence of both
respiratory conditions and neurologic developmental problems with children,”
CMS said. In addition, according to CMS, the pollutants that are emitted from
the plant do not respect state or county lines.
Advocates of the plant contend that it will bring additional jobs, revenue,
and produce byproducts that local businesses can use. Examples of these
byproducts include ash for concrete and gypsum for making drywall.
Whitfield has attended many of the meetings in which the coal plant has been
debated. When asked if she was aware of anyone from Lafayette County in
attendance, she said that she has not seen any residents or county officials
come and participate. But added, that she hopes to see citizens of Lafayette
County start to come out and attend the meetings and voice their concerns.
Watch the Free Press for continuing coverage of proposed coal plant
200 turn out to oppose Charlotte County mine
Residents tell Charlotte officials about worries over
truck traffic
CHARLOTTE COUNTY – More than 200 people packed the commission chambers
Friday to oppose a shell mine that a citrus company plans to dig on Neal Road.
People who live and work along the road are concerned that traffic from the
40-acre mine, proposed by American Citrus, will put their lives in danger.
"I have a son. I plan to have more children and I'm just worried about
safety," said Robert Smith, who recently built a home on Neal Road.
Kevin Russell, the county's hearing examiner, heard testimony on the case for
nearly four hours Friday. He will make a decision within about 10 days on
whether the proposal follows county law.
Steve Lawrence, the county's land development supervisor, recommended against
approval of the mine because of the potential safety hazard.
He said four other mines are being contemplated in the same area and all of
them would use Neal Road.
Each mine generates an average of 500 truck loads a day, which equates to
1,000 trips.
James Williams, owner of a farm that straddles Neal Road, said he fears the
added traffic will slow his business and kill his workers.
Near the close of the hearing, Russell said he understood concerns that
approving one mine on Neal Road could open the route for even more traffic
later.
"Unfortunately, I can only look at this case," Russell said.
Whether mines continue to be approved on a case by case basis, rather than in
a more comprehensive may, rests on the shoulders of the county commission,
Russell said.
The county commissioners plan to meet Tuesday at 9 a.m. to discuss whether
they need to change mining laws.
About 20 mines already operate in Charlotte County, double the amount of
neighboring counties. Without changes in the law, the county could see the
number of mines climb to 50, Lawrence said.
Many of these mines are sprouting up on farmland.
Williams, for instance, already has a mine on his property and plans to build
another 100-acre mine.
Farmers are turning crops into mines, with financial help from the Southwest
Florida Water Management District, nicknamed Swiftmud. Once the dirt, shell or
rock is extracted from the earth, the mines become lakes that farmers can use
to irrigate their fields.
Swiftmud encourages the mines in hopes that farmers will wean themselves from
dependence on groundwater for irrigation.
On Friday, representatives from both the Florida Farm Bureau and Swiftmud
spoke in favor of the Neal Road mine.
Williams also spoke in favor of the mine itself, but so vigorously opposed the
use of Neal Road as a route that he brought dozens of his farmworkers to the
hearing.
Michael Haymans, attorney for American Citrus, told Russell there is no
alternative route.
He added that only eight people live and receive mail on Neal Road.
But landowners on the road say that rural characteristic is changing.
Gavin Mann said he owns 60 acres on Neal Road and plans to build a home there.
He said his daughter and son-in-law also plan to build homes there.
Sunny Diver and other east Charlotte residents voiced general concern about
the influx in traffic the mines are generating on State Road 31.
"It's just phenomenally dangerous," Diver said. "Every time I
go out on the road I feel like I'm taking my life in my hands."
Ravi Devaguptapu, transportation engineer for American Citrus, said 3,600
vehicles use State Road 31 daily and half of them are trucks.
New regional park planned for U.S. 19
By MICHAEL D. BATES
mbates@hernandotoday.com
BROOKSVILLE — It used to be that motorists heading north on U.S. 19 toward
Citrus County could set their car’s cruise control and casually take in the
wooded scenery on either side of the road.
But in recent years, the traffic has increased and the number of housing
developments has grown. More subdivisions are planned.
With more people headed toward Hernando County’s northwest section,
county commissioners believe it’s time to consider a new regional park.
In fact, it’s beyond the consideration phase. Parks Director Pat Fagan is
already crunching numbers and looking at funding options to make the park a
reality. Other than state-owned land, there are no parks or recreational
facilities along U.S. 19, from just past Glen Lakes to the Hexam Road area.
“That is really the only area in the county right now that does not have
a park site on it,” Fagan said.
But before residents pack a picnic lunch and head out to the new park, the
county will have to purchase 50-75 acres of land, design and build it. And it
won’t be cheap.
Preliminary cost estimates are coming in at about $15 million over a
10-year period.
And there is only $600,000 in impact fees in that district to help pay for
the new park and all the goodies the county would like to include.
There is also another park in that district — Ernie Wever Park — that
is slated for improvements, so that pot of money will have to be split.
Ideally, here is what the county would like to see in the new regional
northwest park: softball and baseball complexes, multi-purpose fields,
basketball courts, tennis, bocce ball, shuffleboard, racquetball, handball and
volleyball courts.
Visitors would also find a playground, picnic shelters, fencing along the
perimeter and sidewalks.
One way commissioners are trying to offset the costs of new parks is asking
the developers in that area to help pay for them.
The county is already asking them to pay their fair share of road
improvements in certain areas, so why not needed services such as parks, they
reason.
Partnering with the school district
There may be a way to build the park without breaking the bank.
Fagan said one inexpensive option of getting the new park built cheaper and
quicker is by partnering with the school board, which will build a new high
school in northwest Hernando County in the next three years.
The school is planned for a 70-acre site on the east side of U.S. 19,
three-quarter miles south of Centralia Road.
The high school will be built on the southern portion of the site and
accommodate between 2,000-2,500 students. Eventually, an elementary school
will be built on the northern end, with 750-900 students.
With that many families moving in, it is in the best interests of school
and county officials to team up, commissioners believe.
Partnering with the school board would not only save money, it could move
up the creation of the park by about five or six years, Fagan said.
“It would save money by not having to duplicate efforts,” he said.
The school district needs athletic fields. The new school is right in the
middle of the expected residential growth.
“If we work with the school system, it would be a win-win situation for
both of us,” Fagan said.
County Administrator Gary Kuhl agrees that a partnership with the school
board is the preferred way to build the proposed park.
Partnerships with other public or private entities are probably the ideal
way to fund other big-ticket capital projects earmarked for the future, Kuhl
added.
And the northwest area is sure to need its share of infrastructure
improvements as development there ramps up.
Gearing up for growth
“A lot of the growth is headed that way,” Deputy County Administrator
Larry Jennings said of the northwest region.
That growth is driven largely by the expansion of GlenLakes and up to
11,000 unsold lots at Royal Highlands, Jennings said.
Other large-scale housing developments in the Northwest include Seville and
World Woods and the proposed Lake Hideaway.
Planning Director Ron Pianta agrees that he is braced for development
activity along U.S. 19 heading north.
Fagan admits he has his work cut out for him. He plans to present a budget
to county commissioners in the next two months or so, showing the cost
breakdowns of the park, with or without school board involvement.
“There’s a lot to do and my priority is to work with the school system
to build a park with amenities so we can both use them,” he said.
Reporter Michael D. Bates can be contacted at 352-544-5290.
Housing Slump Delays Roads
By KEVIN WIATROWSKI The Tampa Tribune
Published: Feb 4, 2007
At the northern edge of Hillsborough County, Sunlake Boulevard wends
through a quiet, residential section of Lutz before petering out in dirt and
potholes.
Beyond the end of the road lies Pasco County and Long Lake Ranch, owned by
Nick and Pete Geraci.
Pasco County officials see a day when Sunlake Boulevard continues north
from Hillsborough, crossing Long Lake Ranch, Bexley Ranch and more Bexley
family land before meeting State Road 52 just east of the Suncoast Parkway.
County officials say extending Sunlake Boulevard will take traffic pressure
off increasingly congested U.S. 41. For now, however, Long Lake Ranch and the
extension are tied up in regulatory knots as Nick Geraci tries to remove
nearly 300 acres from the project's southeast corner to develop separately.
An extended Sunlake Boulevard is part of a network of future roads Pasco's
planners hope to put in place in the next 20 years.
That network looks dramatically different from the one that exists now:
Four-lane roads swell to six or eight, overpasses replace congested
intersections and miles of new roads cut through the vacant acres of central
and east Pasco.
The county is depending on developers to build many of those roads as part
of future subdivisions and shopping centers. As a result, the county's
transportation network hangs on the economic forces driving both the housing
industry and the road-building business.
"We're really at their mercy," said Pasco County Commissioner Ted
Schrader.
The recent slide in Pasco's housing market has put a crimp in the county's
plans for that road network as developers delay their housing projects and the
roadwork associated with them. On top of that, the recent run-up in road
construction costs is giving some builders second thoughts about how much
they're willing to do.
Road Plans Don't Jibe
In short, it's becoming clear that the county's road-building plans don't
always jibe with developers' market-driven schedules. The county has few tools
to force developers to build roads ahead of their own schedules nor the money
to build the roads itself, said commissioners.
"They're supposed to be the developers' responsibility to do,"
commission Chairwoman Ann Hildebrand said. "It would be nice if we could
do it, but I don't know if we have the financial wherewithal."
Road construction costs peaked last year at $6 million a mile, a figure
that forced everyone from developers to the Florida Department of
Transportation to rethink plans.
At the moment, county officials seem willing to wait the developers out.
"Other than shutting them down and not giving them any more building
permits, I don't know what we can do," Schrader said.
A shutdown last summer forced Seven Oaks' developers to start fulfilling
their commitment - made in 2001 - to widen Bruce B. Downs Boulevard in Wesley
Chapel.
Developer Craig Weber has secured a $34 million line of credit to finance
the project, which could start this fall.
There is one notable exception to Pasco County's wait-and-see approach to
its developer-built road network: State Road 56.
The eastern extension of Pasco's newest highway was envisioned as a relief
valve for chronically congested State Road 54, giving drivers a second route
to Morris Bridge Road, Zephyrhills and Tampa.
The project was originally the responsibility of Meadow Pointe developer
Don Buck. Buck passed the job to Pulte Home Corp., as part of its Wiregrass
Ranch development west of Meadow Pointe, and GL Homes, which is developing the
Wynfields project east of Meadow Pointe.
Wiregrass Ranch has bogged down in its two-year course through county
review, leaving its part of S.R. 56 unbuilt years after it was supposed to be
finished.
S.R. 56 'Has To Be Built'
Commissioner Pat Mulieri expressed her frustration with the stalled project
during discussions about Wiregrass and its potential impact on traffic in
eastern Pasco and northeastern Hillsborough counties.
"[S.R.] 56 "The people who live there believe 56 will help
them."
The first phase of the road calls for two lanes stopping short of Meadow
Pointe Boulevard.
Pulte vice president Scott Neal has said work on the road could start this
spring.
But the Department of Transportation has told Pulte it won't accept the
road unless it connects with Meadow Pointe Boulevard.
Until that happens, the road is a driveway into Pulte's Del Webb project.
Pulte is working on plans to fill the gap and win DOT approval, said county
engineer Jim Widman.
In the meantime, Rick Costello, GL Homes' Tampa president, hears the clock
ticking on the commitment he made in 2005 to build S.R. 56 from Meadow Pointe
Boulevard to U.S. 301.
"The deadlines right now are extremely tight, but they're tighter for
other people than they are for us," Costello said.
Costello's part of the road is supposed to cross Zephyr Egg's property,
southwest of Zephyrhills, to reach Morris Bridge Road.
The development of that property was thrown into question last year when
Zephyr Egg and Metro Development Co. went to court in a dispute over timing of
the project. It's unclear when that dispute will be resolved.
For the moment, Costello is focusing on the part of the project Pulte must
build.
"The timeline is going to be dictated by what it takes to get the road
to us," Costello said. "Otherwise we're building a parking
lot."
WAITING FOR ROADS
County officials expect developers to build many major road projects. That
approach puts the future transportation network at the mercy of changes in the
housing market and road construction costs. Here's where four major road
projects stand now:
CURLEY ROAD: Lennar Corp. hopes to renegotiate its deal with the
county over widening and relocating the southern end of Curley Road. The
developer wants to do the work as part of developing Epperson Ranch instead of
paying $20 million upfront so the county can do the work.
STATE ROAD 56: A falling out between the owners of Zephyr Egg Co.
and Metro Development Inc. has cast into limbo plans for extending Pasco's
newest east-west road to meet Morris Bridge Road southwest of Zephyrhills.
SUNLAKE BOULEVARD: A dispute between brothers Nick and Pete Geraci
over their Long Lake Ranch project in Odessa has made it unclear when work
will begin to extend Sunlake Boulevard north from Lutz to State Road 54. Other
developers have begun work on segments north of S.R. 54.
CLINTON AVENUE EXTENSION (S.R. 52A): A yearlong delay in developing
Bella Verde has set back plans for building the western end of Clinton Avenue,
which will form the resort community's main entrance. Work could begin next
year.
Reporter Kevin Wiatrowski can be reached at (813) 948-4201 or kwiatrowski@tampatrib.com.
Meadow Pointe districts argue over use of facilities
As a result of the community's growth, its reciprocal use policy appears
on the way out.
GINA PACE
Published February 4, 2007
WESLEY CHAPEL - When Demetrius Greene returned from serving his country in
Iraq last year, he was happy to be back in the United States, away from
community strife.
But lately, the soldier has seen a neighborhood rift, right in his back
yard in Meadow Pointe.
His kids Asha, 13, and Ashton, 9, were headed over to use the Meadow Pointe
II clubhouse a few weeks ago, but they weren't let in the door. The kids
didn't really understand why, and it turns out, neither do most Meadow Pointe
residents.
From the outside, Meadow Pointe looks like one big community. But the area
is actually four distinct community development districts - governing boards
originally created by developers. They can levy taxes for infrastructure needs
and oversee community issues.
The districts are responsible for the clubhouses and pools each area has,
and for years have had agreements where residents could go to any facility
they wanted. The agreements were signed when the developers still controlled
the boards, but residents were elected as the population grew. That's when the
conflict crept in.
The latest example is when Meadow Pointe II built a new fitness room. It
started demanding IDs for admission and wouldn't allow residents from Meadow
Pointe I, said Dennis Smith, district representative from Meadow Pointe I.
Smith said that rather than argue about the issue, his board would just
cancel their 10-year reciprocal use agreement, which is to end in March.
Meadow Pointe I's chairwoman, Patricia Asklar, sent over a written notice
to Meadow Pointe II's leadership.
That notification was reprinted in Meadow Pointe II's January newsletter,
along with a note that said because of Meadow Pointe I's decision, those
residents were no longer allowed in any of Meadow Pointe II's facilities.
A group of about 15 angry residents gathered Thursday night during a joint
meeting of the two groups to complain.
Some residents of Meadow Pointe II were upset they could no longer use the
lap pool in Meadow Pointe I. Most didn't understand how the decision was made
in the first place.
Gerald Lynn, the chairman of the Meadow Pointe II CDD, defended the
original decision, saying that the new fitness center could not hold more
visitors than those who live in his district.
He would not comment further when contacted Friday, other than to say the
matter would be discussed at the next district meeting.
Sandra Minieri, 64, said the matter has devolved into a power struggle
between the two districts, with residents suffering.
"It cured me from moving into these developments," said Minieri,
who moved to Meadow Pointe II from California two and a half years ago.
"You have a few people making decisions for thousands of people, and I
don't know who they answer to." They answer to the residents, who vote on
district board members as part of general elections.
Smith thinks part of the problem is that builders and Realtors perpetuate
the notion that any resident of the area - which now stretches nearly nine
miles - has access to everything under the umbrella of Meadow Pointe.
He's not opposed though, to working out a new agreement - if everything is
on the table.
"If there is an agreement that treats everyone the same, I would vote
for it in a minute," he said.
Gina Pace can be reached at (352) 521-6518 or gpace@sptimes.com.
Residents Oppose Cork Annexation
By RAY REYES The Tampa Tribune
Published: Jan 27, 2007
PLANT CITY - They called themselves "country folk" and wore
matching yellow shirts with black lettering that declared their opposition to
development.
The most outspoken of them stood before city commissioners at a public
hearing Monday night and defended their rural lifestyle. Those residents from
the Cork area - a tract of cattle country north of Interstate 4 and east of
Thonotosassa Road - said annexation and future development of their area would
destroy what they hold most dear.
"We treasure this land," said Cork resident Judith Branch-Trauner.
"We see great beauty in the orange groves, the hayfields and the farmlands.
[Annexation] will change the culture of our community and our way of life
forever."
After a series of objections from Cork residents, commissioners decided to
strike the annexation request from the agenda and postpone voting on the issue
until March. The 288-acre Cork tract was one of three annexation requests
totaling about 1,600 acres that commissioners planned to vote on as one item.
Mayor John Dicks said he would like to see the developer provide clearer
details on access roads into the Cork property. City Attorney Ken Buchman
requested more time to study whether the annexation request adhered to state
statutes.
The other annexations - which included berry farmer Carl Grooms' 187-acre
Fancy Farms and a neighboring area owned by developer JL Plant City Ventures on
County Line Road - were approved with a unanimous vote.
A new subdivision with up to 715 single-family homes may be built in the Cork
area if annexed into the city. Resident Charlotte Nelson told commissioners she
doubted Wallace Branch Road, the lone stretch of asphalt that winds its way
through the tract, could handle increased traffic. Additional access points such
as Cason Street dead-end on private property, Nelson said.
"I welcome people to come into the city" but "715 units for
Cork would overtax" Wallace Branch Road, Dicks said.
"I would not want to give petitioners the idea that we like that kind of
density," Dicks said.
Nelson also argued the annexation request didn't meet requirements of state
law.
Buchman told commissioners he would need about a month to investigate
Nelson's claim. If Buchman's research determines the annexation can move
forward, public notices would have to be published in newspapers and
commissioners would vote at their March 12 meeting at the earliest, Buchman
said.
After Monday's vote, resident Kim Fields said she felt commissioners listened
to the pleas and arguments of her fellow self-proclaimed country folk dressed in
yellow.
"It feels like a step forward," Fields said. "It's a temporary
victory."
Reporter Ray Reyes can be reached at (813) 865-4433 or rreyes@tampatrib.com
Newell pushed land deal to associate
By Tom Dubocq
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Sunday, February 04, 2007
Palm Beach County Commissioner Warren Newell, champion of a $50 million
taxpayer initiative to protect public access to the waterfront, steered $14
million to a private Hypoluxo marina where he docks his personal yacht.
Newell met privately with the marina's owners and county staff, then voted
with other commissioners to pay $14 million to keep the Palm Beach Yacht Center
a working boatyard, county records show. County administrators said they never
were told about Newell's business ties to the marina. No record could be found
that the four-term commissioner, before voting on the purchase, publicly
disclosed his lengthy association with both the business and one of its owners.
Newell wouldn't talk about it. "There are several prosecutions pending
against other individuals and I do not want to do anything to compromise the
integrity of those pending matters," he wrote in response to written
questions from The Palm Beach Post.
Documents The Post obtained show the commissioner's connection to the
marina went beyond tying up Long Shot, his 38-foot fishing boat, in a
yacht-center slip:
• While pushing the $14 million acquisition in 2005, Newell owed the yacht
center $35,900 for unpaid dockage fees and maintenance. Newell never reported
the debt on his state-required financial disclosure forms. He did report it in a
May 2005 financial affidavit that he filed in his divorce.
In a brief interview, Newell said the debt has been paid. His boat remains at
the yacht center, and his monthly marina payments are current, he said.
• Newell and Leo Berman, who owns 45 percent of Palm Beach Yacht Center,
were among investors who applied in September 2005 to open Legacy Bank of
Florida. Newell invested $300,000 in the Boca Raton-based bank while Berman, the
largest single stockholder, had a $1.6 million stake, according to the Florida
Office of Financial Regulation. Before that, Newell and Berman were directors
and shareholders of Southern Community Bank of South Florida, which was launched
in 2002 and sold in 2004.
• Newell's engineering and surveying firm, West Palm Beach-based SFRN,
provided the property surveys needed for the county's acquisition of the yacht
center's development rights. Surveys on file with the county show that the firm
had mapped the yacht center in 1996 and updated the survey last year.
Newell, who owns 26 percent of the firm, wouldn't say how much SFRN was paid,
and the company, through its attorney, wouldn't comment. Berman did not return
phone calls or answer written questions faxed to his office.
Florida ethics law prohibits a public official from voting on matters that
would provide a "special private gain" to a business associate. Under
the law, the official is supposed to declare the conflict of interest, then
abstain from voting and file a written explanation.
Newell's business associations came to light as federal prosecutors continue
to probe county government for corruption, an inquiry triggered by reports that
former Commission Chairman Tony Masilotti profited from public land deals while
hiding his interest in them. Masilotti pleaded guilty last month to honest
services fraud and faces up to five years in prison.
In the aftermath of the Masilotti scandal, Newell called for empanelment of
an ethics commission to instill greater public trust in government. He also
advocated full disclosure of anyone benefiting from county land use and zoning
changes to help prevent conflicts of interest. "It's one more way to make
sure government's in the open as much as possible," he has said.
The public investment in the yacht center came from a special countywide
property tax voters approved in 2004 - a popular drive Newell led. At the time,
he was running for reelection and faced a formidable opponent for the first time
since 1992. The $50 million bond issue was approved by a 2-1 margin. On the same
November ballot, Newell's reelection was a squeaker. He won by less than 1
percent over opponent Harriet Lerman.
Newell's first pitch to protect the waterfront came in April 2004 when the
owner of Sailfish Marina Resort, an Intracoastal Waterway landmark in Palm Beach
Shores, was negotiating with a condominium developer. The county's marina
industry was "under attack by developers," he told commissioners.
Newell was encouraged by commissioners to bring back "global
recommendations" to save public access to the waterfront.
A month later, the commission endorsed Newell's recommendation to ask voters
to approve a $50 million bond issue.
The bond issue had the backing of the county's marine industries, which
warned they were being forced out of business by rising land values and property
taxes along the waterfront. Access to the water by about 40,000 county boaters
was in jeopardy, they warned.
The vote was unanimous, with Newell and other commissioners rallying for
Sailfish Marina. A month later, Newell without fanfare began pushing for Palm
Beach Yacht Center as well.
"This marina, along with other critical facilities, is being heavily
solicited by land developers," he wrote on June 29, 2004, to county real
estate manager Ross Hering. Newell forwarded a letter from the marina's owners
and asked Hering to meet with them "immediately," as well as with the
owners of two other unidentified north-county marinas. "I know you are
diligently working on Sailfish, but these other marinas are also very
critical," he wrote.
A year later, with the commission decision looming on how to spend the $50
million, Newell arranged a July 26, 2005, meeting in his office with Hering and
the yacht center's owners to work out details.
"That project definitely originated with Commissioner Newell,"
Hering said when asked how the yacht center discussions got started. "He
had the contacts with the owners. They didn't pick up the phone and call
me."
Newell never told county staff or the commission that he docked his yacht at
the marina, that he had owed back rent or that he was opening a bank with one of
the owners, Hering said. "There was no discussion of that at any
level," he said.
Under the yacht center terms, the county would acquire a property easement
that required an operating boatyard and boat storage shed on the premises. Forty-four
boat slips on submerged state land forever would be reserved for paying
customers. The owners would keep all the marina profits.
Additionally, they could develop 65,000 square feet of the property and
maintain full control of another 40 boat slips.
The owners' price, according to Hering, was non-negotiable: $14 million for
an easement the county's appraiser later valued at $9.3 million.
For most of 2005, Hering and his staff shopped for marinas along the
Intracoastal with limited success. Finally, at a November workshop, Deputy
County Administrator Verdenia Baker told commissioners that the staff was
negotiating with only two: Sailfish Marina and Palm Beach Yacht Center, and that
the cost for both was $29 million, leaving considerably less money for expansion
and improvements at publicly owned marinas and boat ramps.
Newell suggested dropping Sailfish Marina from the plan. But protecting the
yacht center was "critical," he said, because it was the only business
in the south end of the county where boats could be dry-docked for repairs.
A commission majority balked, saying the purchase of development rights at
both marinas was too expensive. In a 4-3 vote, with Commissioners Jeff Koons,
Karen Marcus and Newell dissenting, the commission directed staff to continue
negotiations with Sailfish and the yacht center without a firm money commitment.
The following day, Newell wrote a memo to Hering reiterating the board's
direction - that negotiations with the two marinas should proceed.
At Marcus' urging, the commission changed course in December 2005, agreeing
to acquire development rights at Sailfish Marina with $10 million from the bond
issue and $5 million borrowed through the state. Last February, on motions from
Marcus, commissioners voted to seal both marina deals.
Newell voted without disclosing his association with the yacht center and
owner Berman, meeting records show.
Then-commissioner Masilotti opposed the Sailfish Marina deal, saying the $15
million would be better spent to expand a public marina. But there was no
quibbling from Masilotti and other commissioners about the yacht center's costs,
even though the $14 million price was 50 percent more than its appraised value.
The Sailfish acquisition had represented a far better deal. It was valued at $22
million, and the county was paying $15 million.
Hering said he was surprised the yacht center deal was approved. "I gave
them the facts," Hering said. "I thought the board was going to say,
'Go away.' "
With the deal approved, the yacht center's owners filed an appeal with the
county's Value Adjustment Board, a panel of three county commissioners and two
county school board members that weighs challenges to real estate assessments
raised by the county property appraiser.
The marina owners argued that the county's newly acquired easement entitled
them to a tax break, that the property's new $28.4 million tax value was
inflated. The new assessment would have boosted their property tax bill nearly
$400,000.
At a Dec. 12 hearing, Special Magistrate Harold Overbey agreed that the
county easement diminished the property's value. He recommended that the Value
Adjustment Board slash its value to $9.4 million - a $340,000-a-year
property-tax cut.
For the county's marine industries, Palm Beach Yacht Center represented a
victory over soaring property taxes and development pressures. Barring a court
challenge by the property appraiser, all the yacht center needs is the signature
of the Value Adjustment Board's chairman endorsing the tax cut.
The chairman: County Commissioner Warren Newell.
Tough Going in the Glades
By Kelly Wolfe
Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Sunday, February 04, 2007
Loretta Pugh, 85, greeted guests in a faded housecoat, her hair in a tight
white bun. She lives on the lip of Lake Okeechobee in a ruined, leaky shell of a
home filled with memories and misery.
Hurricane Wilma tore open her roof in October 2005. Water pours in when it
rains. The floors are soft and squishy, like a kitchen sponge.
Blue tarps drape over her treasures: family photos, old china and moldy
knickknacks.
"I fixed it as best I could," said her daughter, Loretta Henson,
50.
Henson lives in the house with her mother and teenage daughter.
She stared up at the stained and swollen ceiling. "I've had more than
half my history thrown out," Henson said.
Dozens of Glades families are in this same situation, making the best of it
in soggy, moldy, hurricane-damaged homes. They are uninsured, poor, undocumented
or unable to navigate the confusing system of building permits.
Dozens more are homeless, staying in Federal Emergency Management Agency
trailers or apartments paid for with county grants.
But because the last hurricane was so long ago, deadlines are approaching.
Help is running out.
FEMA trailers go back to the government in April. And the $1 million county
grant that housed 118 Glades families for the past year is depleted.
It's unclear where these people will go.
The Palm Beach County Disaster Recovery Coalition has a plan to rebuild
hurricane-damaged homes using volunteers from faith-based organizations.
But the process is long and tedious. Time is crucial. It's like trying to
weave a safety net beneath people already falling.
But church leaders, such as the Rev. Danny Moore of Higher Ground Ministries,
are behind the plan.
"I think it's going to be our only solution out here," Moore said.
"People will put their trust in organizations like us because we're
local."
Moore persuaded FEMA to donate 70 trailers to his Higher Ground Ministries.
But now he has to tend to the business of running a non-profit. He's surprised
God's work comes with so much red tape.
"This is America," Moore said, after leaving Pugh's home. "We
live in a blessed country. No one should have to live like that."
Sheri Taylor, director of the Palm Beach County Disaster Recovery Coalition,
is rarely quiet. She talks about low-income housing with passion, making pitch
after pitch in a rat-a-tat, machine-gun style.
But Thomas Roberts just stunned her silent. Roberts is the executive director
of the low-income housing organization Neighbors Organized for Adequate Housing.
He said 118 families are about to become homeless. The county grant that paid
their rent for the past year is gone.
"Some are leaving and we don't even know where they are going," he
said. "We're loath to put them out, but funds are drying up."
One woman on Taylor's team rested her forehead in her palm. They had hoped
Roberts would help them find homes for families they are already tracking.
Instead, he's doubled their caseload.
"That's a whole different group of people we didn't even know
about," Taylor said.
Taylor met with Roberts to find out why he hasn't fixed 14 hurricane-damaged
units in Amaryllis Gardens, a low-income housing complex in Pahokee owned by
NOAH.
Roberts rattles off the various reasons why those units are still sodden
shambles. Even a computer glitch at the U.S. Department of Agriculture delayed
the $1 million project, he said.
"It's deeper than a lot of people know," he said.
This is Taylor's second trip to the Glades in three weeks. These cases were
once in the hands of the Federal Emergency Management Agency. But FEMA's
programs, Project Hope and Project Recovery, ended in 2006.
"FEMA supports those projects financially," Taylor said.
"There was a termination date."
Taylor spent the better part of seven hours photographing hurricane damage in
the Glades recently. She stopped when her camcorder died. She said she wants
state and local lawmakers to see the rows of naked trusses, shredded blue tarps
and boarded-up windows.
Meantime, she's calling on churches to help people like Loretta Pugh and her
daughter.
"Most people couldn't afford to pay rent," she said. "So, we
try to do what we can to repair where they are."
Taylor also intends to pressure landlords and the local housing authorities
to fix storm-damaged rentals so people can move back in.
"Why is the housing deteriorating when there is such a huge need?"
Taylor asked.
Julia Hale, executive director of the Pahokee Housing Authority, said about
500 public housing units in Pahokee suffered storm damage during Hurricane
Wilma.
More than 60 families had to be relocated.
The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development awarded the Pahokee
Housing Authority more than $2 million to fix the units, Hale said. Hale said
she recently hired contractors to begin renovation.
"We certainly don't want to lose housing and leave people
homeless," she said.The Rev. Danny Moore has lived in this town of 5,000
all his life. He worked in the sugar industry two decades before becoming a
preacher four years ago.
"I've got a heart for Pahokee," he said. "I've been here 44
years and I've never seen it in the shape it's in."
Moore's nonprofit, Higher Ground Ministries, is fledgling at best. And he's
overwhelmed with desperate people who need help.
One man lived under a blue tarp - as if it were a tent - for about a year
before Higher Ground stepped in. Moore is now busy trying to find a trailer for
a family with children. Their old trailer's floor is so waterlogged "you
can't hardly walk in it."
People are poor here, Moore said. Even some of the people living in his
donated Federal Emergency Management Agency trailers can't pay the $300 lot fee
each month.
"They just don't have an income," Moore said. Big sugar is
downsizing, he said. And there's no industry here.
Sure, he said, there might be people who take advantage. There might be
people who don't save. There might be people who buy cigarettes instead of
paying lot fees. But does that mean they should go homeless?
To combat this problem, Sheri Taylor wants churches to partner with the
United Way's Prosperity Center to teach people about budgeting and money
management.
"Residents need to take ownership in the recovery process," she
said.
Moore said he likes Taylor's plan. He said he welcomes the help from
organizations such as the coalition, but also agrees locals have to take care of
one another. Some folks out here are suspicious of smooth-talkers from West Palm
Beach or Tallahassee.
"People are scared of being taken advantage of," he said.
He said one 75-year-old woman threw out her FEMA paperwork because she feared
it was a scam.
In Canal Point, Loretta Henson said she can trust Moore to help her.
Henson works three days a week at the American Legion. Her mother is on a
fixed income. They do not have insurance.
Henson said she tried to help herself, but became lost in a permitting maze.
She said she tried to fix her roof, but a code enforcement officer caught her
and told her she needed permits. She said she didn't know she needed permits to
fix her own roof.
"I was put on a merry-go-round," she said. "This one told me I
had to talk to that one. They transferred me around until I was back where I
started."
"So what do I do?" Henson asked Moore. "Do I completely go
nuts and insane because I can't get any help?"
Moore studied the ceiling.
"I think I can get some people together to at least stop the
leaks," he told Henson.
Moore said he'd also help her pull the permits.
She said she was grateful.
Then they went quiet for a minute.
"You know, it used to look a lot different," Henson said of her
childhood home.
"I can still picture you right out in this yard, out there
playing," her mother, Loretta Pugh said, pointing out the kitchen window.
"Yeah, well I was younger then," Henson said.
"Yeah, a little bit," Pugh said.